4 ms·
So let me get this straight:
1. Give up all your free time to working out.
2. Eat nothing that is delicious ever again.
3. Statistically, not significantly pro
So let me get this straight:
1. Give up all your free time to working out.
2. Eat nothing that is delicious ever again.
3. Statistically, not significantly prolong your life. You could still die of heart disease at 50 because your genes are just not good genes. You could get cancer and keel. You could sleep an hour to long, and throw a clot and die.
4. Some people feel better in general doing the above 3 steps.
I am overweight, by a fair margin. But I'm not especially unhappy, insecure, or immobile. I have plenty of hobbies that involve outdoor things and my lifestyle doesn't inhibit those. My doctor says that losing weight is more for reducing long-term stress on my joints: my cardiovascular system is fine so long as I don't gain more weight.
So why the fuck should I, or the legion of people like me, care or listen to what this exercise freak says? I've got dogs, a girlfriend, and some hobbies taking up all the non-work time in my life. Who actually wants to do what he says, especially when the benefits are so incredibly dubious?
Statistically, it does prolong life, since being overweight is correlated with heart disease. Yes, you can die of heart disease when you've done everything right, but it's not likely.
Your argument is "Look at these things that are very unlikely to kill me. That's why I feel justified doing things are likely to kill me."
Trying not to overeat and get more exercise don't have to take up all of your free time.
I think you are missing the authors point. He's saying that he doesn't care what others do just don't assume his situation is god given.
This goes with something I heard on the radio last week. There was a news segment about how a group was lobbying the American Medical Association (AMA) to classify obesity as a "disability" which would give them free benefits under some government health insurance program. Then they trotted out a sound bite from a poor over weight soul who proclaimed "It isn't my fault I am the way I am".
I find it exceptionally hard to believe that that there is anyone who genuinely follows a healthy diet and is reasonably active and still can't maintain a healthy weight.
Bringing it back to this article it's like a broke business owner looking at a successful one and saying if only I was born with their smile and sense of charisma I could start a successful company too. When, in reality, it probably came down to persistence and hard work as the separating factor.
No, I got his point. He wants credit for spending all his time to be skinny. He doesn't like the idea that maybe hes naturally skinny, he wants credit to be given for the HUGE chunk of his life he's allocated to being skinny.
There's some credit. He sure does work hard at it.
And then he goes off, like everyone who talks about fitness, on how you could be like them. As if we wanted to. Just spend 6 days a week working out, run on the side, and eat like a tibetan monk. PS, listening to LL Cool J can also help.
I will never listen to LL Cool J. That is where I just have to draw the line, so I guess the whole diet isn't for me.
And why are you so angry about this? Obviously, the writer has bought heavily into making fitness a lifestyle - and I think he's totally on the wrong track because he has to be so ridiculously disciplined about it. But I think the point worth taking home is more along the lines of:
Yes, you can ignore it all and be reassured by a gaggle of paid professionals that you're within the national averages and they'll know how to deal with you when your health fails you.
Or you can say, "Most people are unhealthy. I don't want that." The evidence from prehistoric times strongly indicates that this is our actual situation today. And going from that premise, you start making some changes. Maybe they're small ones, or big ones. Maybe LL Cool J plays a role. But the conclusion always involves working a little bit because society has made it hard to be naturally fit and healthy.
Probably because the authors point is trivial.
Of course if you spend you entire time to be thin by exercising and eating like a bird you will be skinny.
That's no challenge when that is what you do. The challenge is to do that, work for 10 hours a day, have time with the kids, sex with the misses, hang out with the friends, see the family and so on.
Then it's interesting. But the authors claim is reminiscent to a body building screaming "see me I'm muscular"
Or just eat less.
To quote former FDA commissioner David Kessler from the book I just read (and the impetus for this post), The End of Overeating, “People get fat because they eat more than people who are lean…we finally have strong evidence that weight gain is primarily due to overeating.” Period.
This has been conventional wisdom for years now. Everything else is just details, though people love to obsess about the details, because "eat less" doesn't provide the same level of excitement and optimism as "eat this freaky diet." Even the theory behind most of the low carb diets is that avoiding high-glycemic-index foods smooths out your insulin levels, which helps regulate your appetite, which helps you avoid overeating.
Likewise, exercise is a big help for me in eating less, because it improves my mood, which makes it easier for me not to overeat. I've talked to lots of other people who, like me, find that a moderate amount of exercise actually decreases their appetite. (If you burn enough calories, you end up driving your appetite back up, but not many people burn many calories in relation to their intake. I work out about three days a week; averaged over the week, I burn about 150 calories per day, which is helpful but not a big deal.)
So you put "Don't eat delicious things" higher up the chain that he does.
And then you still burn a huge chunk of free time accomplishing no tangible thing in exchange for a dubious assurance of a fractionally longer life.
I used to be in much better shape than I am now, but my life was miserable. Exercise did not make me feel better, coming to terms with my life and my environment and having some control over my situation made me feel better. My opinion has been that the "workout high" is more about having control over yourself and your situation than any real lasting benefit.
Eat all the delicious, unhealthy things you want, just keep it around 2000 calories.
So if you want to have an enormous, 1500 calorie meal at a casual dining restaurant, go for it, just keep it light for the rest of the day.
But I'm not especially unhappy
But you are very aggressive and defensive about it. What makes you think that healthy thin people devote "all" their free time to working out? Or that a "healthy weight" involves never eating delicious food?
Is it really fair to call him a "freak"? He's the unusual stand-out fairground attraction? A thin person who eats vegetables and bikes to work, excuse me, what?
So why the fuck should I, or the legion of people like me, care
I take it you are this aggressive and defensive when someone writes a blog post about Java or Flower arranging or anything else you're not interested in?
> "But you are very aggressive and defensive about it"
I'm not aggressive or defensive. I'm tired of people who do this. "I am not a health freak, but I love my life and I'm pretty sure that it's great, and I feel I deserve credit for it. PS, this is how you can be like me."
> Is it really fair to call him a "freak"? He's the unusual stand-out fairground attraction? A thin person who eats vegetables and bikes to work, excuse me, what?
Sorry dude, working out 6 times a week means that you're exceptionally into it. I am a compsci and photography "freak", I didn't mean it as a pejorative, I meant it as a clear descriptor of someone who devotes nearly all his time to one specific task. My contempt for his article stems from the disdain for the same formulaic structure I see on all health posts.
> I take it you are this aggressive and defensive when someone writes a blog post about Java or Flower arranging or anything else you're not interested in?
I am not afraid to give my opinion. Check my twitter. Better yet, ask me about Python if you run into me. I'll see if I can achieve barfight status.
Wow, that's pretty defensive.
I've seen a lot of "I love my startup and I'm pretty sure it's great, and I feel I deserve credit for it. PS, this is how you can do a startup like me" stories posted on HN, never bothered me any. You can find lots of these stories in blogs everywhere in different fields, like photography and music and writing. I'd hate for these to disappear.
Working out 6 days a week may not take as long as you think. I worked out every other day for a while when I had my home gym, and I only do half an hour every workout.
You don't have to give up eating delicious things. The original author does go extreme in not eating any meat, when in many cases meats are actually healthier than vegetable products (e.g. properly prepared chicken vs. deep fried potato fries or HFCS containing products). I'd probably wager that in many cases it's the vegetable products (sugars, white rice, white flour, HFCS, vegetable oil) that are the worst offenders.
I'd wager to say that fast food/chain restaurant food is not only less healthy, but is also less delicious. E.g. Thai Green Curry chicken with brown rice seems to be a lot more delicious than a meal at Denny's (and is actually cheaper).
(I'll address the exercise issue -- including the original authors' mistakes in a separate -- in a separate comment).
It's a bit of an unfair comparison that you're making - you're picking essentially the worst, most high-calorie nutrient-free vegetable products.
Flipping it around, I could just as well say that fresh vegetables (kale, spinach, cabbage) are far healthier than animal products (bacon, beef tallow, chicken fat).
So much of the equation is in the specific foods you pick - a vegan could eat the foods you listed and be deeply unhealthy, while an omnivore could eat large portions of fresh vegetables with a bit of free-range meat and be quite healthy.
> 2. Eat nothing that is delicious ever again.
Eh? You’ve never had delicious veggies? Or fruits?
Sorry, but I eat delicious & healthy food regularly. All you need to do is learn to cook.
( I also eat horribly on a regular basis, when I’m too lazy to cook. )
Anecdote: I've been running 40-50 miles a week, tried various diets, but I still was chunky. Last two months I run 5-10 miles a week, eat sugars and crap but I record everything and eat around 1200-1500 calories a day. I've lost a crapload of weight.
Yeah, I'm also a 6'3'' and I was 220 in March so I'm probably grossly undereating but after a week of hunger and headrushes you get used to burning fat (I also drink coffee) for energy and feel great while losing weight.
All these facts, myths, and rules of thumb depend on the operating definition of "fat" as well as what group of "fat people" are being analyzed. People who are medically "overweight" or "obese," meaning having a BMI over 25, eat more on average than those with a BMI under 25. I would consider exercising and eating to be of tantamount importance in correcting this, but certainly genes and upbringing can instill a predisposition to obesity or even hinder sincere efforts to lose weight.
However, I think what the article is talking about is skinniness as opposed to being "chubby" or "soft," not flat out obese. If you're somewhere in the region between "skinny" and "chubby," but not near being under- or overweight, then what you eat and how you exercise is important; even subtle changes to your routine can have noticeable effects.
No offense, I mean this with the best of intentions, but you do come off as very defensive. The OA was not condemning anyone, the advice was given openly without any tone of admonishment.
Imagine an artist who draws well and writes a post about how he gets annoyed when people talk about how lucky he is to have that talent and how they "can't draw a straight line." Then goes on to explain how much work he went through to develop that ability, and that anyone can improve their drawing ability. Sure the guy has a chip on his shoulder, but who would be offended by that? It would have to be someone who had an even bigger chip on their shoulder.
Now if you're associating this with society projecting unrealistic body image expectations, then I agree that that's very annoying. However it's not fair to bite someone's head off over fitness advice. It's perfectly reasonable for someone to be proud of their achievements. It doesn't automatically make them a smug a-hole anymore than being annoyed by it makes you an oversensitive jerk.
But there are other bigger societal issues at play here.
> Sorry dude, working out 6 times a week means that you're exceptionally into it. I am a compsci and photography "freak", I didn't mean it as a pejorative, I meant it as a clear descriptor of someone who devotes nearly all his time to one specific task.
Okay working out 6 days a week is not "devoting all nearly all your time". The average American watches 4 hours of TV a day, and we don't call everyone TV freaks. It's perfectly reasonable to go the gym for 30-60 mins a week without having your life be devoted to it. Someone who simply works out regularly is not a freak. Go to the gym (especially one with a silhouette of bodybuilder on the sign) and you'll be able to see the freaks first hand.
I agree that the gym is a bit unnatural in that it's a contrived form of exercise, but as human beings we are evolved to get a reasonable amount of exercise. Sure in the short term we are programmed for laziness because it's more efficient, but our bodies aren't really made for the life of leisure we enjoy. Regular people all over work out because it makes them feel better in general. It's not because they are freaks, or gluttons for punishment, or love breaking a sweat.
Is it someone's fault that we live a sedentary lifestyle? Not really, it's just the natural course of progress, but I don't think it's right to jump down someone's throat just because they happen to expend some effort to keep healthy and they want to share. If you don't like it don't read it.
The other side of the coin is nutrition. And in this case I think the food industry and farm subsidies really are to blame. The grain-based diet advocated in the food pyramid is a scam, and people who want to eat healthy are forced to pay more for fresh vegetables and free range/grass-fed meats because of the powerful grain lobby. With the type of food available to us today, it takes real willpower (almost to the point of "freakishness" as you say) to eat what would be considered a very average diet at any point more than 60 years ago.
I think nutrition science is still in the dark ages, and the general advice given is not going to be a good fit for everyone. At best it's a partial picture, and at worst it's explicitly corrupt. I think the only reasonable way to eat healthy is to avoid processed foods as much as possible, and even go for locally and sustainably grown produce to avoid nutrient-depleted genetically-engineered-and-identical monocrops grown using nitrogen-based fertilizer.
I guess it makes me angry that the food industry promotes bogus science in order to increase profits at the expense of all our health, then people turn around and get angry at anyone who advocates a healthy diet simply so they can feel better about themselves. It's like being complicit in our destruction.
Sorry to go off on a rant, but getting some exercise and eating right does not have to be this huge ordeal, and we shouldn't lash out at people who want to do it and talk about it just because we have our own issues or guilt around the subject.
" The average American watches 4 hours of TV a day, and we don't call everyone TV freaks. It's perfectly reasonable to go the gym for 30-60 mins a week without having your life be devoted to it. Someone who simply works out regularly is not a freak. Go to the gym (especially one with a silhouette of bodybuilder on the sign) and you'll be able to see the freaks first hand."
Come on, almost no one here at HN is in the demographic that watches 4 hours of tv a day. I might hit 2 if I miss yesterday's dailyshow/colbert and watch both in a night. And even if I do, that is time I can also spend with my girlfriend or my dogs. And again, we're not talking about someone who works out "30-60 min a week" going 6 times a week, unless you're at the gym for 5-10 min at a time?
Personally, I was thrilled I had half an hour to myself the other night to go out photographing a local cemetery 2 blocks away. I then went inside, spent some time with my family, called relatives, and then immediately had to call up some PDFs on current topics I'm studying to keep current for my profession.
" Regular people all over work out because it makes them feel better in general. It's not because they are freaks, or gluttons for punishment, or love breaking a sweat."
I already explained to you what I meant by "freak", you just cruised right by it. You're hell bent on reading persecution here, when what I'm saying is that the post was a vacuous example of how someone with a lot of free time works out a lot more than any 9-5 family man has time for, and then starts saying, "This is how you too can be like me." If it were just a plea for credit where credit was due, that'd be the end of it. But it's not, and given my experience with fitness junkies and their blog posts, it was almost inevitable that it wouldn't be.
Sorry, my bad on "30-60 mins a week". I meant a day. That's not an obsessive amount of time by any standard. And just so you're aware that I understand time commitments, I'm #2 in a startup and I have a 5-week old daughter.
> I already explained to you what I meant by "freak", you just cruised right by it.
I'm just saying it's an unreasonable definition to say that someone who works out 6 days a week is automatically a freak or a fitness junkie. As in anything, there is a line where the freaks are, and you've chosen to draw it awfully close to someone who never gets any exercise at all.
Who wouldn't be aggressive and defensive about it? Since you speak English, statistically you are extremely likely to live in a society that likes to blame e.g. rising health care costs on "fatties", that fudges health analyses to ignore that being "overweight" by the usual standard is healthier than being "normal", that is full of people claiming that you are weak willed and "just" need to radically change your life forever to meet with some preexisting beauty standard.
The mere fact that you can claim what you do in your first paragraph means you have never seriously had to deal with these problems. Some people are genetically predisposed to being heavy. When I was 16 and swimming over a mile every day, I weighed 220 ("BMI" claims that the maximum permissible weight at my height with a "heavy" build is 180, FYI). Trying to be 180 would do me far, far more harm than being heavy would, or will; this, too, has been backed up by medical studies (see: miserable effectiveness of dieting. See: health complications from losing and gaining weight.).
But even if you don't eat more, food is being stored as fat as a priority instead of doing other useful things with it, so you can undereat and be both obese and malnourished, by eating the wrong types of food.
You can induce all kinds of freakish pathologies by eating the wrong types of food; that's nothing new. Simultaneous obesity and malnourishment is common in poor communities in the U.S. because of diets that are high in calories but deficient in other ways. I seriously doubt anyone could be obese and calorie-malnourished in the absence of serious medical issues or radical inconsistency in food availability. The existence of odd pathologies like Taubes' lipodystrophy cases doesn't say anything about the vast majority of people.
Taubes acts like the mere existence of these pathologies is mind-blowing. But it's just common sense: the process of storing and metabolizing body fat isn't physically inevitable. It's complicated. There are all kinds of ways it could be suppressed, and you expect that as with any other biological process, there's going to be natural variation in the population, including people where the process goes wrong in an odd way. That isn't a daring supposition. That's just the way any ordinary doctor or biologist would think. The question is dealt with every time a new drug is studied -- how will different people respond to it? Vioxx was a scandal because detecting rare harmful side effects of treatments that work well in most people is routine. The idea that a "healthy" diet might harm some people, especially people already suffering from a metabolic disorder, would not blow anyone's mind. Look at all the research into nutrition for diabetics!
Anyway, I still don't see anything new here. Theoretical speculation is fine and dandy, but the question is, what actually happens? If you practice reasonable calorie restriction on a reasonable diet, your body will adjust. It will not kill you or permanently harm you. It will certainly threaten you and try to convince you that you're dying. Everybody knows that when you decrease your food intake, your body complains. It tries to make you eat more. It makes you feel tired. It makes you feel like exercising would be a bigger mistake than drunk-dialing your boss's teenage daughter. But if you go against those feelings, your body's doomsday predictions don't come true. If the situation described by Taubes actually prevented healthy weight loss -- your body starving certain systems of calories in order to spare body fat -- you would expect that people following reasonable diets and exercise could end up unhealthy. And it doesn't happen.
That isn't just an assumption. There are some seriously strong-willed people out there who are pathologically devoted to low body fat and/or suffer from body dysmorphic disorders. There are also some seriously strong-willed people who are dedicated to athletic performance but rather dumb about how they pursue it. We know people can persist in unhealthy habits to the point of breakdown -- it happens all the time. It's not like there's a great uncharted domain out there of freakish consequences that could result from weird practices. Crazy, stupid, and/or mentally ill people have explored the weirdo options pretty thoroughly, sometimes with gruesome results. So why haven't we seen any gruesome outcomes from the diets that are considered healthy according to the conventional wisdom? The only possible conclusion is that whatever pathological responses our bodies might have to healthy diets -- such as starving important systems to spare body fat -- don't persist over the long term in people with an overabundance of body fat.
In any case, from an overweight person's point of view rather than a public policy standpoint, the only practical question is what will happen if you eat a reasonable diet and exercise. The answer is that if you follow any one of a bunch of reasonable diets, from Ornish to Atkins, you will lose weight and be healthier, and if you exercise, you will be even healthier. I get annoyed when people like Taubes, knowing how eager people are to believe otherwise, go through a complex song and dance that encourages people to believe otherwise even though he doesn't seem to believe otherwise himself.