5 ms·
"SV thinks it's extremely meritocratic. It's only very meritocratic. This is a big problem."
by SilasX 13y ago
"SV thinks it's extremely meritocratic. It's only very meritocratic. This is a big problem."
- 21echoes 13y agoI would in no way say that SV is even very meritocratic. Compare start-up demographics numbers to population-at-large numbers... The fact that commenters like you would read this article, hopefully think for half a second, and then still insist that SV is "very meritocratic" is exactly the problem.
- hacker789 13y agoYes, there are too many pesky east-Asians and Indians. There might be a Jewish problem as well.
- Crito 13y agoI'm not sure if you are making an intentional reference to this or not, but it does make an interesting counter-point to the assertion that mathematics is a meritocracy: http://arxiv.org/abs/1110.1556 http://arxiv.org/abs/1110.1556 "This is a special collection of problems that were given to select applicants during oral entrance exams to the math department of Moscow State University. These problems were designed to prevent Jews and other undesirables from getting a passing grade. Among problems that were used by the department to blackball unwanted candidate students, these problems are distinguished by having a simple solution that is difficult to find. Using problems with a simple solution protected the administration from extra complaints and appeals. This collection therefore has mathematical as well as historical value." (Previously discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3096793 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3096793 and here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4759642 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4759642)
- hacker789 13y agoI don't think that's a counter point; it's a long discontinued practice of deliberately discriminating against people of a given race because other people of that race were too successful. It's not something I support, by the way, in case the sarcasm in my above comment wasn't apparent.
- Crito 13y agoIt is one example (of many) of access to a mathematics education not being a meritocracy. In the linked discussions on that paper, there are people arguing that this practice is ongoing in the US (although tweaked a bit to be less obvious). Regardless, I think it is important to realize that access to a [mathematics] education not being a meritocracy is different from mathematics itself not being a meritocracy. It is related, so this is only a partial counterpoint, but I think it is interesting to consider nevertheless. Certainly one has to keep in mind that biases in our education system will influence what we see in industry, even if the industry really is a meritocracy.
- waps 13y agoIsn't that the definition of "positive discrimination" and "affirmative action" ? Both of which are most certainly in wide use today.
- beat 13y agoThe problem, I think, is external to SV. It's not that women and minorities find themselves blocked within SV - it's that they don't get into that path in the first place. The problem starts long before someone gets the opportunity to drop out of Stanford CS to pursue their dream of selling Facebook for Cats to herd-mentality VCs.
- mtrimpe 13y agoAnd what if it's only moderately meritocratic? Or even below average? I'd love for PG to run an analysis once of what words occur most frequently in flagged posts and their comments. I don't think you could get a better representation of this community's unspoken biases than that. I'm also pretty sure you'd find that words like feminism, female, sexism e.a. would feature quite high on the list.
- newnewnew 13y agoMaybe the community has a bias against pointless class warfare. You want to make an effective feminist statement in Silicon Valley? Start with a github profile.
- wonderzombie 13y agoRight, right. Let's skirt past the idea that men may be in any way responsible for the industry they dominate, and focus on the fact that women aren't creating enough GitHub profiles or having enough hackathons. In addition to shifting the blame, this is a convenient way to avoid taking any sort of responsibility for our own behavior or our peers, so congratulations on squaring that circle.
- hacker789 13y agoThis community, like most others, has an unspoken bias against third-wave feminist bullies. Look what happened to the "Atheism Plus" communities. They have been completely taken over by bigoted "social justice warriors" and their activism. Completely. Atheism is almost never discussed. And when it is, it is always discussed in the context of third-wave post-modern feminism. Think I'm lying? Take a look at any Atheism Plus community. Any! Once a community accepts the tenants of post-modern discourse, it's over.
- sp332 13y agoSV believes so strongly that it's meritocratic, that every successful person believes they deserve it. That's a problem.
- freefrancisco 13y agoWhy is that a problem? Because someone who can say with moral certainty "this is my money, I earned" is not an easy mark for the sort of people who produce nothing but demand an equal share of the work of others? Because they won't subscribe to the ridiculous notion that there is no virtue in creating wealth but only virtue in giving it away? Maybe that is precisely why those who produce nothing hate the concept of meritocracy so much. It makes it harder for them to guilt people into giving away what they rightfully earned.
- sp332 13y agoIt's important to be able to tell the difference between something you earned and something you were given without earning it. If someone fails, does that necessarily mean they didn't deserve success? Or is it possible that external forces took from them something they had, "with moral certainty", earned? The article points out that white males are overrepresented in SV success stories. Are you going to argue that they are dozens of times more productive than women, or non-white people? Let me make the point in a way that does not pit groups of people against each other. If you do the same thing over and over, hustling and making pitches, and then one day you get someone to fund you, does that make you inherently better on that day? Do you have more "virtue" on that day than you did the day before? Let's say someone founds a company and it fails. This person feels like they didn't deserve to fail, so they start another company and it succeeds. This person will take the success as s true measure of what they deserve, and will ignore the failure as a fluke. But they will look at failed companies around them and feel superior, even though they also failed once. There are lots of people founding similar companies, making similar pitches to the same investors. I can't see an argument that they "deserve" wildly different valuations. Holding wealth creation as a virtue devolves very quickly into worshiping money. Anyone with money is to be respected, and anyone who doesn't have money has nothing interesting to say.
- 13y ago