6 ms·
Hyperbole aside, if "Dr" Smacktoward did actually develop a cheap and effective therapy that actually worked, the prior restraint employed by the FDA would like
by logfromblammo 13y ago
Hyperbole aside, if "Dr" Smacktoward did actually develop a cheap and effective therapy that actually worked, the prior restraint employed by the FDA would likely keep it off the market. The same technique employed against snake oil may also be applied to real cures that might provide cost-effective competition to multibillion-dollar blockbuster patent medicines.
- smacktoward 13y agoYes, that's right; if you believe that you truly have developed a remarkable healing elixir in your garage, the burden is on you to obtain scientifically valid proof that it does what you claim it will do before you can go around selling it to people. Whether or not you see this as a horribly unjust burden imposed by an unfeeling government will probably depend on whether you are the inventor or the person the inventor was planning on selling it to.
- logfromblammo 13y agoIf you apply that standard to other products, such as software, what happens? If you cannot distribute software that is certifiably bug-free and algorithmically correct, that is warranted to be fit for a specific purpose, what happens? If you cannot sell a car if it cannot go 70 miles-per-hour, consuming fuel at 50 miles-per-gallon, and have zero fatalities in a head-on collision, what happens?
- Zoomla 13y agotoo bad they are not as rigorous with the food we eat. One example is that they don't even have the resources to check if the food manufacturers claims are true (you can't be sure what type of fish you eat nowadays).
- javert 13y agoThis is a really critical point. People who are pro-regulation are under the premise that regulation actually does protect people. There are countless examples to the contrary. (The finance sector is even much worse than the FDA in this regard---for example Bernie Madoff was regulated, leading people to think their money was safe with him---but in some ways, the FDA is just as bad.) Of course it can help, some. I'm not going to deny the obvious. But it's highly imperfect, and it often hurts.
- gnaritas 13y agoThe only way to know it actually works is to do the necessary science, which unfortunately isn't cheap but them's the breaks. Stopping bad medication from being on the market saves lives, even if it prevents the occasional good one.
- logfromblammo 13y agoThe FDA introduces a bootstrapping problem wherein the proceeds from selling a potential remedy cannot be used to test it, and no one other than the inventor can test it, because the product cannot be sold until after it is tested. In any case, the only hurdle to selling should be "does it do harm?", and "does it work as advertised?" can be determined later, if and only if there is any doubt among the consumers. Elsewhere in consumerland, the product is sold, and independent testing is performed on off-the-shelf samples. Think Consumer Reports or Underwriters' Laboratories. If a problem is found, a recall may occur. If none are evident, the testing body grants its approval to use its trademarks on the product. People look for that trademark from the trustworthy third party. If the FDA did not apply prior restraint, and tested products already available to the consumer, it could regulate the usage of the phrase "FDA-approved" and make perfectly safe everyone who buys only the medicines bearing that approval for the purposes which have been tested.
- aestra 13y ago>Elsewhere in consumerland, the product is sold, and independent testing is performed on off-the-shelf samples Not true. Do you really think I can start legally marketing a car seat or a crib without safety testing it first? Wrong. http://www.cpsc.gov/en/Business--Manufacturing/Testing-Certification/ http://www.cpsc.gov/en/Business--Manufacturing/Testing-Certi... Federal law requires manufacturers and importers to test many consumer products for compliance with consumer product safety requirements. Based on passing test results, the manufacturer or importer must certify the consumer product as compliant with the applicable consumer product safety requirements in a written certificate that it must provide to retailers, distributors and, upon request, to the government.
- 13y ago