4 ms·
I don't think anyone is going to argue about the FDA's role in ensuring drugs are safe, but most countries don't require positive proof of effectiveness and, fr
by Symmetry 13y ago
I don't think anyone is going to argue about the FDA's role in ensuring drugs are safe, but most countries don't require positive proof of effectiveness and, frankly, have better health outcomes than the US. Doctors are quite capable of reviewing the evidence to see if drugs are effective, and the FDA doesn't in practice do anything to prevent the sail of non-poisonous snake oil.
- seiji 13y agoDoctors encompass the entire range of people (from morons to geniuses). As a group, they aren't some magnificent godlike all knowing figure. "Programmers are quite capable of reviewing the evidence to see if code is effective" — yet, we end up with thousands of people using MongoDB based off fad and hype and losing data by the day. (Wait, did I just advocate for a government-level code approval board? In the right hands it would probably help if it prevented more Mongos and Hadoops from entering the world.)
- jbooth 13y agoLosing data when you're a professional who should have known what you're doing is one thing. Losing your life when you're a layman in the medical field is another.
- Symmetry 13y agoDoctors make mistakes, but there isn't anything preventing that in any event. In theory a doctor can prescribe any drug for any ailment (though there are lots of checks and consequences), and prescribing drugs for things other than their FDA approved use is very common[1]. You have to rely on doctor judgment at some point and efficacy trials don't substitute for competent doctors. And sometimes the whole process goes awry because a drug is approved for one problem, later becomes the only treatment for some people with a second problem, then the FDA withdraws approval because there are now better treatments for the first problem, leaving those with the second problem in the lurch.[2] [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Off-label_use http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Off-label_use [2]http://nielsenhayden.com/makinglight/archives/007140.html http://nielsenhayden.com/makinglight/archives/007140.html There's some important context in the comments.
- JPKab 13y agoI think the US's for profit healthcare system makes the FDA very important. Here in the US, we have pharmaceutical salesman who come in and schmooze the staff to then get to the doctors. Pharmaceutical rep is a job known to be very amenable to attractive women with little skills outside of flirting.
- nickff 13y agoYour definition of "for profit" is somewhat misleading, as many Canadian doctors, nurses, pharmacists, etc. are the residual claimants ('profiteers') of almost any course of testing or treatment; and I suspect that this is true of many countries with less strict drug regulations.
- venomsnake 13y agoCan you please give example of such a country? I can't think of any country with working healthcare where you are allowed to claim anything medical (or heaven forbid perform) before clearing it with the authorities.
- Symmetry 13y agoNo, every country I can think of requires new medicines to be cleared with the authorities. The difference is what that clearance entails.
- _delirium 13y agoA number of western countries take a strategy that tries to make questionable-but-safe drugs legal-but-rarely-used. For one, they ban direct-to-consumer advertising; the USA and New Zealand are the only two developed countries where it's legal to advertise to consumers. And for another, state health-care systems will typically not pay for drugs that lack evidence of efficacy, and most people are used to getting their healthcare through the state health system. That leaves it technically legal for consumers to buy, out-of-pocket, a drug that can't be advertised to them. In practice a handful of people do so, but not too many. It looks like they do sell this in Europe. Although I'm not sure if that's because it's approved at all, or just because Europe considers it some kind of novelty product rather than a medical device; the FDA and EU categorization of drugs/devices/etc. is a bit different.