6 ms·
Google’s Role In Woodland Child Pornography Arrest Raises Privacy Concerns
- pstuart 13y agoThis is a tricky subject because all of us (excluding the pedophiles) can agree that sexual abuse of children in all forms is a bad thing. That said, the erosion of privacy in the name of "think of the children!" is equally a bad thing. In this case it appears to be a legitimate case of a sexual predator sharing his digital trophies and rightfully being caught. But "protecting the children" doesn't have to mean giving up our expectations of privacy in the normal course of affairs.
- tokenizer 13y agoSorry for being pedantic, but pedophilia is psychiatric disorder. I'd imagine all pedofiles WOULDN'T think child abuse is good. That said, the word you were looking for, is child molester. People need to realize that not all pedofiles act on their attractions, nor that all of them would want to. It's important to note that the feelings of attraction, do not automatically mean they want to rape all children...
- Tohhou 13y agoYou just labeled yourself a child rape apologist by social justice warrior feminist standards.
- tokenizer 13y agoWell to me, I'm simply highlighting the fact that not ALL pedofiles are rapists. It doesn't surprise me that some/most people believe this, but I believe that defending simple truths to be important. Again, pedantic. But necessary. Especially if people who go by social justice warriors, believe in the persecution of pedofiles who've never commited or will commit a crime.
- nawitus 13y ago>This is a tricky subject because all of us (excluding the pedophiles) can agree that sexual abuse of children in all forms is a bad thing. More like the society doesn't allow discussion on these topics. Any opinion which is not perfectly in line with the "official truth" is not acceptable, so there's no point to talk about it.
- Empathenosis 13y ago^ Pretty much this. However, as much as it would be great to have the freedom to talk about specific topics. I am moreso concerned on figuring out why Google gives a shit, and what else they are hand-delivering to the feds. Looks like it's reformat, and use a different search engine time.
- arrrg 13y agoSo, uhm, you think there are large numbers of people who think that sexual abuse of children in all forms is a good thing? And that they don’t dare speak? I sure hope not! Or what was your point again.
- nawitus 13y agoThe point was that no points can be made.
- DanBC 13y ago>is equally a bad thing. You really think that rape of children is equivalent to telling law enforcement about images of that child abuse?
- sitharus 13y agoThere's a mild concern here, but it does rely on two things - having a known image and having it uploaded to a web service. Judging by the information in the article an original image wouldn't be matched, and it is in the ToS (good luck reading all of that). The organised groups that make money off this are much wiser and harder to catch. More interesting is the quote "Microsoft also developed Photo DNA to match pictures using just a pixel". I'm not sure it works quite how they suggest.
- sigzero 13y agoThe Picasa policy spells out that they don't allow those kinds of things. I would assume one way they would check would be some kind of algorithm. I see "no evil" here on Google's part.
- venomsnake 13y agoYeah. But a companion question should also be - if they use a potent technology for something i approve of (and we all approve of that uses) can it be (ab)used for something we dislike.
- Karunamon 13y agoSure, that's only reasonable. But you're at that point only one step away from a slippery slope argument. (How meta..) Problem is it's not always a valid question given the context. Automagically scanning images with an algorithm to find known sexual abuse pictures is in a completely different world than scanning images with an algorithm to find copyrighted content, for instance.
- greenyoda 13y agoI think this is a crucial point. To make it more concrete: In the U.S., having a video of Osama bin Laden congratulating the 9/11 terrorists might be grounds for suspicion. In China, having a picture of a guy standing in front of a tank in Tiananmen Square is highly frowned upon.
- wdvh 13y agoThe least you should expect when you upload something onto a cloud service is that your data will be subject to all kinds of algorithmic analysis. And it's just not tenable for Google to not do this kind of matching. Imagine the flak they would get if they refused to match against a database of child porn citing "privacy concerns." Such a refusal would be neither pragmatic nor ethical.
- kmfrk 13y agoFrom how I read it: Google match all images to a database of file hashes. I wonder whether they do it for redundancy purposes like Dropbox, or whether it's entirely to crack down on child pornography.
- greenyoda 13y agoIf they only did it to remove redundant pictures, they would have no way of knowing that a given image was porn; all they'd know was that it was identical to some other image on their servers.
- duskwuff 13y agoSee: http://www.missingkids.com/Exploitation/Industry http://www.missingkids.com/Exploitation/Industry There is apparently both a database of MD5 hashes of "known bad" image files, as well as a "PhotoDNA" system for fuzzy image matching.
- increment_i 13y agoConsidering this person uploaded explicit pictures of children to a cloud server, is anyone actually surprised that the FBI showed up at his door soon after? In addition to what federal and international law says on the matter, basically every web service on the face of the earth explicitly forbids these kinds of images in their terms of service. Once he hit the upload button, this guy's 'privacy concerns' were kaput.
- pwnna 13y agoSlightly offtopic: "Microsoft also developed Photo DNA to match pictures using just a pixel." What. So if I give Microsoft a pixel with value #F00 it can determine if that's from a specific photo? Great reporting with great insights and sources.
- Houshalter 13y agoYa that's ridiculous but it would be hypothetically possible if you had a sufficiently high number of colors. Then the chance of two images having a pixel with the same R, G, and B values all exactly the same would be exponentially small. You could possibly do this by averaging all the pixels together for example.
- Houshalter 13y agoI don't know how I feel about this. Merely looking at CP doesn't actually hurt anyone, and pedophiles are not necessarily attracted to what they are by choice. But there is an argument that it's existence encourages or can lead to child abuse in the real world, especially the production of more CP. This seems to be demonstrated by this case. They caught the guy through CP but it turns out he actually abused a kid. Maybe he wouldn't have been caught otherwise. On the other hand is punishing them and throwing them in jail for years actually helpful? As opposed to a lesser sentence or rehabilitation of some kind maybe? Another problem is that it's incredibly easy to frame people for. Just put some cp on someone's computer or Google account and you can have them sent off to jail with little effort and no way for them to prove they are innocent.
- samstave 13y agoChild PORN should not exist for people to look at. I take great issue with your first sentence. Who the hell do you think was harmed in the creation of said CP? If you are in any way sympathetic to those that would "harmlessly" watch it, then you are tucking delluded as to the reality of such a situation. Seriously, take a moment to think about what you said and try to not pretend to be so "academic" about your position. I'll assume you have no children.
- anonymoushn 13y agoDo you mean that looking at images harms people, or that people choose to be pedophiles?
- Houshalter 13y agoI take issue with it's creation, but once it exists, looking at it is a victimless crime whether or not you find the act objectionable. Which is another reason to be skeptical of the laws as they main reason they exist is because people find it objectionable, rather than rational arguments about what actually prevents child abuse.
- marquis 13y ago
- _nullandnull_ 13y agoLaw Enforcement have been using the hashes of known child pornography images to find pedophiles for probably a decade. This technique is no different than what anti-virus vendors do to detect malicious software. I'm starting to hate Google in lieu of their new campaign on killing privacy and anonymity but I don't see the privacy concerns here. Server side hashing of images and comparing them to a database isn't exactly gives metadata to the NSA. I think it's good that Google is doing this. Odds are more image hosting providers should be doing. It's low hanging fruit but at least it could protect a child.
- decasteve 13y agoIs a matching hash enough to get a warrant or is a warrant even necessary? Or is it probably cause to raid the user's house at that point? I'm curious to know the process once a matching image fingerprint is found. Or will we soon be hearing of a police raid on a person's house because of an errant MD5 collision?
- kanamekun 13y agoAccording to US law, any online service provider that receives actual knowledge that child porn exists on their services is required by law to report it to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children... or face a fine of $150k for a first offense, or $300k for subsequent offenses: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/2258A http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/2258A To my knowledge, Google wasn't required to check its hosted files for specific image hashes: "Nothing in this section shall be construed to require an electronic communication service provider or a remote computing service provider to— (1) monitor any user, subscriber, or customer of that provider; (2) monitor the content of any communication of any person described in paragraph (1); or (3) affirmatively seek facts or circumstances described in sections (a) and (b)." But once they did, they were required to report the results. Any privacy concerns are waived as an "[exception] for disclosure of communications" as part of 18 USC § 2702: "Voluntary disclosure of customer communications or records". http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/2702 http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/2702 It's not surprising that Google is affirmatively scanning its servers for child porn, as they have a long history of providing assistance to NCMEC: http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2008/04/building-software-tools-to-find-child.html http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2008/04/building-software-too... http://googlepublicpolicy.blogspot.com/2012/01/crowdsourcing-to-protect-ncmecs-newly.html http://googlepublicpolicy.blogspot.com/2012/01/crowdsourcing... "$1 Million from Google to Fight Child Sexual Exploitation Received by the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children" http://www.missingkids.com/news/page/4898 http://www.missingkids.com/news/page/4898
- mtgx 13y agoThe question is what else are they scanning for, to give to the FBI/police. I remember Facebook announced a while ago that it would scan its Facebook chat for "criminal activity", to give the info to the police. http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57471570-93/facebook-scans-chats-and-posts-for-criminal-activity/ http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57471570-93/facebook-scans-... Where is the line drawn? And will we know where it's drawn? Stuff like this makes me trust "cloud computing" less and less. I hope Google and others realize this, before it's too late (for them) to change course. I can take a guess where this is going, though, if NSA's actions are any indication - there won't be a line anymore, if they (government/corporations) are left alone to continue with stuff like this. Every single crime, no matter how small and insignificant, will be reported to the police, thanks to the mass surveillance capabilities of the alliance between NSA/government and corporations. After all, when "safety" is the ultimate goal, above all else, that outcome is all but inevitable. It's already started: http://falkvinge.net/2013/11/24/nsa-mass-surveillance-has-already-been-used-for-ordinary-police-work/ http://falkvinge.net/2013/11/24/nsa-mass-surveillance-has-al...
- dreamdu5t 13y agoSeems incredibly easy to frame someone for child porn.
- mtgx 13y ago“The state must declare the child to be the most precious treasure of the people. As long as the government is perceived as working for the benefit of the children, the people will happily endure almost any curtailment of liberty and almost any deprivation. ” -Mein Kampf, Adolf Hitler, Publ. Houghton Miflin, 1943, Page 403
- khawkins 13y agoThis doesn't make me significantly worry about my privacy using Google services. Google knows that it needs to maintain trust with its users and that's why it's only tackling a crime which has little controversy with respect to its heinousness and is almost trivial to detect, from a systems perspective. I'd far rather Google show good faith and help fight crime on their terms, rather than the government come in and start imposing safety regulations and make it obligatory.
- nemof 13y agoWow, there's some fucking dire opinions being expressed in this thread. How fucking removed from reality are some of you.