3 ms·
Rewriting a cross platform browser in C++ is way more difficult than writing something that took a small team 6 months to do. I'm not trying to say that it's a
by davidw 17y ago
Rewriting a cross platform browser in C++ is way more difficult than writing something that took a small team 6 months to do. I'm not trying to say that it's a weekend, but have a look at SO. Unless there's something I'm missing, it's not "deep hacking", but more "crank it out" (not to take anything away from that team - they certainly did nice work!). Scaling might be an issue sooner or later, and that would take some more thinking, but the basic thing just doesn't strike me as some Big Hairy Problem.
So, yeah, be wary of "hey, that looks easy!", but don't think things are impossible either.
- raganwald 17y agoRewriting a browser isn't impossible either, as Firefox proves. Perhaps SO is an order of magnitude easier than a browser, but I stand by my suggestion that copying an existing application you didn't actually write is often much more difficult than expected and has led many teams to their doom.
- davidw 17y agoMy comparison was "writing something from scratch" vs "copying". If a team has trouble with copying, wouldn't "writing it from scratch" be even more likely to end in failure? Also, with something like SO - you can pretty much see the models, and how they interact. That's already giving you a lot.
- dinkumthinkum 17y agoThat's interesting. However, there are already several clones of SO and a couple that reproduce the vast majority of the functionality.
- wlievens 17y agoYou can't even check that, because a significant part of SO's functionality could be hidden from you.