3 ms·
At some point can't she say "so there's a picture of my left tit on the net, and?" Also I don't understand why people like Moore haven't been sued into the gro
by Nursie 13y ago
At some point can't she say "so there's a picture of my left tit on the net, and?"
Also I don't understand why people like Moore haven't been sued into the ground for profiting from copyright violation.
(edit: I mean other than the whole upfront cost aspect, but given how frickin' insane copyright penalties are, you would think some or other lawyer would take it on a no-win no-fee basis.)
- DanBC 13y agoSure, she can say that. Some professions don't welcome people who have nude photographs of themselves on the Internet - teachers, for example. It seems baffling to me that her partner would consider leaving her, but the article says it was a concern. Or sometimes people at vulnerable points in their lives are outed. Or not even outed, just plain blackmailed. It's very easy to say "just shrug it off", but the numbers of people completing suicide (I've found 3 names in a very quick web search) shows that it's not something that people can just get over. http://www.bbc.co.uk/newsbeat/23724703 http://www.bbc.co.uk/newsbeat/23724703 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-24428437 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-24428437 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-24163284 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-24163284
- Nursie 13y agoThose links are about very different cases of children being blackmailed. What's at issue in the link is leaked pictures of grown women. Clearly the behaviour of the people involved in this is abhorrent (for multiple reasons) but there has to be a point where you stop caring. Moore is not the only asshole in the story by a long stretch. He might not even be the worst. I mean, if the boyfriend thought about leaving her for a second then he's not worth worrying about, he's an asshole. Whoever fired the kindergarten teacher likewise. The real story is not the 'revenge porn', it's the morons that are so upset by it that they fire someone, or that anyone would take kids away from their mother over it, or really any of the societal bullshit about nudity. edit: And seriously, some professions don't like taking people who have been naked on the internet? Those professions need to grow the f*ck up.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- DanBC 13y agoWell, yes, his revenge porn only works because other people are arseholes. But it's because all those other people are arseholes that the victims can't just shrug it off.
- sp332 13y agoWell, if people in their social circle made fun of him saying they'd seen her topless, it could certainly stress things between them.
- Nursie 13y ago>>Well, if people in their social circle made fun of him saying they'd seen her topless, it could certainly stress things between them. That would make him pretty worthless.
- sp332 13y agoIt depends on the relationship of course. Some relationships are worth taking abuse for. Some aren't.
- Nursie 13y agoNo, it doesn't. If the woman you are with has pictures stolen and posted to the internet, and you are anything but supportive, you're a worthless human being. If your friends are somehow abusing you for it and you do anything but tell them where to get off, see above. It doesn't matter if you're going to break up with her the next day or you hate the very sight of the woman, it's basic human decency.
- chris_wot 13y agoThat's one of the worst pieces of advise I've ever read on HN.
- rakoo 13y ago> copyright violation I tend to be on the opinion that all forms of art are in the public domain by default, unless explicitely stated. So, there would be no breach of copyright here. However, there is a clear breach on privacy rights, and I'm scared no one in the article or here seems to think that this is the reason why Moore should be prosecuted. The author says than more than half of her contacts are on the site against their own will, for something that is private to their life. That alone is not OK. Copyrights have nothing to do here.
- Nursie 13y ago>> I tend to be on the opinion that all forms of art are in the public domain by default, unless explicitely stated. So, there would be no breach of copyright here. This is factually incorrect. There is copyright on any and all creations unless explicitly licensed otherwise. This is under the Berne convention. In the US you can register copyrighted works but only to access the higher punitive damages for infringement. It became the law in the US that all works were auto-copyrighted when the Berne convention was signed into law. >> Copyrights have nothing to do here. They do, it's stolen* works that are not licensed to the site, and as the escalation of penalties under copyright law has been so huge recently, it may be the best weapon to take these people down. *(I don't usually like the use of the word "steal" or "stolen" in conjunction with copyright, but where it involves actually breaking in to people's mail accounts and taking things I don't necessarily think it's inaccurate)
- rakoo 13y agoYeah, I was more stating what I think should be the norm (copyright is opt-in, not opt-out). Under the current system, this is clearly copyright violation... but why is it the first thing that comes to mind to build a defense ? How come there is a process for rapidly defending your copyrights, and not something similar for your private life ? Of course I know the answers. I'm just sad about that.
- Nursie 13y agoI agree with most of your comment, except for the opt-in part. If I send you a picture of my vacation, I'm not giving you unlimited license to profit from it as you please. In the case in question the picture wasn't even published or sent to another individual, so various computer breaking-and-entering laws would also apply to the perp that did that, but for people that get stuff from them and re-publish... I guess we could have a digital equivalent of a handling stolen goods charge, but copyright seems as good a law as any - there is no permission to copy.