3 ms·
What would happen if NSA mistakenly targets a nuclear reactor, and a bug in the malicious software caused a meltdown. Is that a declaration of war, similar to
by belorn 13y ago
What would happen if NSA mistakenly targets a nuclear reactor, and a bug in the malicious software caused a meltdown.
Is that a declaration of war, similar to a US launching a nuke? Would US be liable, and under what jurisdiction? Could the US President be put under Interpool arrest warrant, charged as an terrorist?
Sabotage, especially when the target can not be fully verified, is a dangerous game. IP addresses are easily mistakenly taken as identity, even if proxying is the number one method to evade detection.
- betterunix 13y ago"What would happen if NSA mistakenly targets a nuclear reactor, and a bug in the malicious software caused a meltdown." What would happen if the NSA introduced a weakness in a cryptosystem that was used to secure major utilities in the USA? The NSA does not care about such external effects.
- tptacek 13y agoYes, that seems pretty simple: if NSA hacking caused a nuclear disaster, that would be an act of war. And?
- looser 13y agoNo, that would not simply be an act of war. If that was the case, it would actually be a war crime, according to the international humanitarian law.
- tptacek 13y ago"International law" is a lie we tell ourselves to make us feel safer. And, I'm on the "all wars are crimes" side of this issue as well.
- belorn 13y ago> And? Like during the cold war, the world was a button press from global collapse. It is not a good thing that random act of sabotage against targets which the attacker can't and won't verify is happening with such indifference to consequences. As citizens, we should react with more than "And?".
- JanezStupar 13y ago>What would happen if NSA mistakenly targets a nuclear reactor, and a bug in the malicious software caused a meltdown. First order of business is covering your tracks. An accident happened, period. >Is that a declaration of war, similar to a US launching a nuke? Would US be liable, and under what jurisdiction? No. At worst you get to use your diplomatic channels to sort things out. Rembember, the target also needs to save face. Having allowed NSA to cause a reactor meltdown is not something anybody would want in their CV. >Could the US President be put under Interpool arrest warrant, charged as an terrorist? I do not know enough about Interpol to offer an answer on this one. But I would say that it is as likely as having USA kicked out of Nato or UN. One would have to start a parallel institution without US for that to be even remotely possible.