4 ms·
One big issue is that people misremember the past, and it's not a random error but a heavily biased one; The second is that CPI tracks the price of a fixed siz
by PeterisP 13y ago
One big issue is that people misremember the past, and it's not a random error but a heavily biased one;
The second is that CPI tracks the price of a fixed size basket of goods&services; but there has been a big change in how much goods&services does 'support a family' means.
For example, if you measure x% increase for cost of housing&utilities, then I'd feel a much, much higher increase simply because "need for space" in my family rising kids is much higher than in my parents' family and the tolerance of living with relatives is less - so we're buying much more "housing space"+heating+stuff for the same number of people and 'social level', and we're obviously paying more for that. In fact, if I think about the goods&services my parents bought when they were young and how much it'd cost if I lived that way, then it would be extremely cheap now, as many of the things that I spend money on simply didn't exist back then and people were happy without them; also many of the habits (how food and trips were done) were done in much cheaper ways - no plane flights for vacations, ever, for example. We're a dual-income family, but I'd say we could live in that 1970'ies style on a single income easily - but, of course, we don't want that.
- msandford 13y agoToday for one or two people flying is often cheaper than driving unless you're marathon drivers. Once you roll a whole family in it still might be cheaper once you consider the food, hotel/motel, lost time due to infinite bathroom breaks, etc in addition to gas and miles on the car. But you've made a good point; people made do with less back then and that should be factored in. I think part of the problem is that the artificially low interest rates are turning "conventional wisdom" or "traditional values" on their head. At 6-8% interest rate and 1-3% inflation saving money makes sense as you get a real interest rate that's positive enough to make saving money smart. Putting away money for future expenses is a good thing as future expenses are discounted today via the interest rate. Living within your means is actually wise. Today only a fool isn't indebted because with interest rates below 1% and inflation at several percent people are effectively paying you to take loans. Saving money for future expenses actually makes them more expensive; better to wait til you need the money and then borrow it so that you can reap the benefit of negative real interest rates, rather than pay it. Because it doesn't make sense to save money, people don't and that means spending. Good for the GDP numbers today, bad for conventional wisdom about money and especially bad for society's ability to withstand credit shocks or employment shocks as nobody has a cash buffer to see them through the hard times.