9 ms·
Geeks for Monarchy: The Rise of the Neoreactionaries
- amerika_blog 13y agoGlad to see this here.
- sobkas 13y agoThe rise of Neomorons. People that don't know anything about monarchy, want to be a new aristocracy.
- 1337biz 13y agoSurprised to see some techcrunch article that appears to be more substantive than just another rewritten fluff piece. But it seems to pushing very much the narrative towards the "racists" angle.
- davidgerard 13y agoThat's human biodiversity advocates.
- rollo_tommasi 13y agoIf the jackboot fits...
- Chen77 13y agoWe identify the biodiversity in other species. Don't see why it's a surprise to see the same curiosity in relation to humans. Especially when you see a number of social policies based on ignorance.
- gaius 13y agoStarts well, then perhaps facing a looming deadline, concludes, actually they're just racists, the end. Weak article about an interesting subculture.
- dhoe 13y agoDo you believe they're not? It may not be the primary motive, but from all I've read, most are indeed racist and would not deny it.
- a8da6b0c91d 13y agoThat's essentially true but if you don't discuss the views in greater depth "racist" is just used as a conversation stopping epithet. Affirmative Action is racist, but I don't think Tech Crunch would write about that by sneering "racist" and dismissing AA measures.
- Ygg2 13y agoYou are correct assuming ,that in regular speech one uses racism as set of beliefs that people are divided into races. However, in normal speech racism is defined as believing that human are separated into different races and that there is a hierarchy of superiority, usually with your own race being on top of it. There is nothing wrong with helping usual target and/or victims of racial or other hate to offset the potential effects said hate. Unless you of course believe safe shelters for women are inherently sexist. In which case you are just old fashioned rasist slash chauvinist.
- a8da6b0c91d 13y agoBy that definition the "neo-reactionaries" or HBD advocates under discussion are not racist. The understanding that many differences in group outcomes and metrics in varied dimensions and directions are rooted in DNA, well that says nothing about superiority or inferiority. It can be without value judgment and is empirically falsifiable. Really, I think your definition is in practice useless. The reality of the word is that when identity politics are involved and people hear something they don't like, they scream "racist".
- davidgerard 13y agoYou can say they don't come up with a hierarchy only by ignoring that they're just fine with the present one and use their racism as the explanation for why it's right and natural.
- anonymousexcn 13y ago“To an observer from the medieval or Renaissance world of monarchies and empires, the stability of democracies would seem utterly supernatural,” he wrote. “Imagine telling Queen Elizabeth I – whom as we saw above suffered six rebellions just in her family’s two generations of rule up to that point – that Britain has been three hundred years without a non-colonial-related civil war. She would think either that you were putting her on, or that God Himself had sent a host of angels to personally maintain order.” Ergo why the elite love democracies - they hold the power and keys while the people think they're the ones in control. Privatize the gains, publicize the losses. Divide and conquer the people through the illusory red team versus blue team paradigm, all the while everyone is robbed blind with nary a hope for real change.
- molsongolden 13y agoMore please.
- djur 13y agoLife for the average person worldwide has improved substantially more in the liberal era (1700-now, roughly) than in any other span of time in recorded history. I have yet to hear any reactionary explain what suffering or harm people are suffering now that will be solved by their alternative systems. Instead, I just see blanket claims that we are obviously being duped, abused and robbed.
- JetSpiegel 13y agoThe Diamond Age was a documentary? Neomorons are a more apt name.
- gojomo 13y agoCan I upvote your first sentence and downvote your second?
- nsxwolf 13y agoHow did I not know this was a thing?
- davidgerard 13y agoYou're not on LessWrong? They're a plague there. (Though note in the comments where Eliezer specifically disclaims neoreaction.)
- Apocryphon 13y agoWhere did he do that?
- davidgerard 13y agoComments of the TechCrunch post this post links to. Direct comment link http://fyre.it/ebaVZi.4 http://fyre.it/ebaVZi.4
- WalterSear 13y agoBecause it isn't. It's a handful of loud mouthed guys who have the phone number of a reporter who was looking for an article to write.
- davidgerard 13y agoIt's pretty trivial. I wonder if they were actually seeking publicity.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoWhen people say that freedom and democracy are incompatible, I wonder what it is they are wanting to do.
- fennecfoxen 13y agoIt's a good question. I guess freedom comes from things like "limited government" and "pluralism", not directly from democracy, and maybe those things are more important than actually letting the people rule themselves -- for an individual person, the notion of their vote being a meaningful voice in a democratic government is kind of a fantasy anyway. But there's not really any better guarantees of freedom under any other system. The whole "let's have lots of micro-states with easy exit" condition proposed by these advocates here sounds borderline quasi-plausible, IF somehow you could get that going to begin with (not bloody likely)... but even from a purely economic perspective, the transaction costs in choosing a new place to live and moving there are very high, so one would suspect this layout would lead to inefficient results. (and that's economic efficiency, which includes your overall well-being.) And who enforces that you get to up and leave whenever you want, anyway? The other micro-states, using WAR?
- praxeologist 13y agoHow about no states? I just subscribe to the protection agency I like, no need to move, nobody claiming arbitrary sovereignty over a whole geographic area. This is a less common type of legal system than whatever flavor of statism but societies like this existed and maintained civil order for centuries.
- krapp 13y agoBut doesn't any such successful agency become a state in its own right?
- praxeologist 13y agoNo, a state is a territorial monopoly. There might be some local/state/federal hierarchy, but whatever place you live in everyone has the same "stack". There's studies that show police in monopoly systems wait and respond to crime much more often than actively patrolling and preventing crime. A polycentric legal order would have people living in one area who might subscribe to any number of different private security and arbitration firms.
- tgb 13y agoEven if you're not that interested in neoreactionary stuff, reading the linked anti-reactionary FAQ by Scott Alexander [1] is quite interesting. Fair warning though - it's huge. [1] http://slatestarcodex.com/2013/10/20/the-anti-reactionary-faq/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2013/10/20/the-anti-reactionary-fa...
- Naga 13y agoI'm actually a monarchist, but not like this. I just believe the current political system of Canada is strong and shouldn't change into a republic. I've never even heard of this movement. I hope I never have to again.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoHow would it affect Canada for its constitutional head of state to not be a professional descendent?
- Naga 13y agoIt's actually a really interesting question, and to answer it I'll need to give a whirlwind explanation of the Canadian political system, since it is quite intricate and different from the American. It's hard to say really what would happen. The Crown (The Queen of Canada, although for all intents and purposes it really means the Governor-General) is an incredibly powerful position. The royal prerogatives, which are not really written down anywhere, since the Canadian (as well as the British) constitution is partially unwritten and based on convention, include appointing ministers (including the Prime Minister) and dismissing them at will, as well as calling and dissolving Parliament, declaring war, signing bills into law through Royal Assent, etc. Conventionally, though, these powers are used only through the advice of the Prime Minister, since the Prime Minister has some degree of democratic legitimacy (although interestingly enough, the Prime Minister is not elected directly by the people. The Prime Minister is Prime Minister only because he is the leader of the party that was chosen by the Crown to form government) and the Crown does not, since the Governor-General is appointed by the Monarch, with the advice of the Prime Minister, and the Monarch is obviously a hereditary position. Now, if the Crown were given democratic legitimacy, say through an elected head of state, suddenly the position is empowered and the stability of the system is called into question. Maybe the Crown decides not to sign a bill into law, or dismisses a minister, or dissolves Parliament for no reason, the Crown could say that he (or she) has the mandate of the people to do so, which is obviously bad for the country. I'm not saying its necessarily bad for the Crown to be empowered like that, just that the system is stable and strong as it is, and it is not broken, so why fix it? It throws a lot of the political system into question and unbalances the delicate balance of our constitution.
- znowi 13y ago> You may have seen them crop-up on tech hangouts like Hacker News I hang out on HN fairly often and haven't seen a single royalist.
- kijin 13y agoI've seen one instance of a Moldbug fan: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5965530 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5965530 Other than that, I agree that HN just looks like a healthy mix of democrats, (crypto-)libertarians, and an occasional conservative.
- davidgerard 13y agoAnd Urbit, which is Moldbug's.
- djur 13y agoTwo or three clicks away from the Urbit homepage you can get to any number of charming screeds about how the United States is communist and how scientific racists are being persecuted by the communist power structure, etc. Kind of put a different light on the whole thing.
- davidgerard 13y agoFor an example of fully rampant Typical Mind Fallacy in Urbit, see the security document: http://www.urbit.org/2013/08/22/Chapter-6-security.html http://www.urbit.org/2013/08/22/Chapter-6-security.html About two-thirds of the way down, you can actually see Yarvin transform into Moldbug and start pontificating on how humans communicating on a network should work, and never mind the observable evidence of how they actually have behaved whenever each of the conditions he describes have obtained.
- _delirium 13y agoThis is starting to feel like LoseThos will present fewer pitfalls.
- WalterSear 13y agoSo the organizers and crowd behind Singularitarian movement got bored, so they moved on to Sea-steading, life extension through 'that one crazy trick' and other Paleotarian claptrap. And now, they've jumped that shark too. What a circus.
- a8da6b0c91d 13y agoI think it's more correctly and broadly described as people who think "Politically Correct" is insidious.
- WalterSear 13y agoOr terminally self-absorbed and petulant children looking for their next press release.
- JamesArgo 13y agoMichael Anissimov was quietly dismissed from MIRI - I imagine it had something to do with his political views, that or his complete lack of technical expertise.
- AndrewKemendo 13y agoMIRI has quite the history of shape shifting and hiring inexperienced CEOs - the list of which you can't find unless you know the history, so here it is: Michael Vassar, Michael Anissimov, Luke Muehlhauser. None of them have anything close to management experience. Peter Thiel is behind a good proportion of anything these individuals want to do which is interesting in and of itself to me.
- davidgerard 13y agoTo his credit, Luke is pretty much kicking arse now he's in the job. I've seen what not-so-great charity CEOs are like (I have many decades' experience in sub-competent charities of various varieties) and Luke's sheer energy is just what MIRI needed.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoYes, they want a monarchy, as long as they get to be peers. I don't see them saying "working as a wage-slave is fondest goal" - that would be for the other people.
- WalterSear 13y agoThe guys involved in this movement can't conceive of a universe that they aren't the center of. A very Ayn Randian bunch.
- AndrewKemendo 13y agoI can't speak for any neo-monarchists but the thing I see the most is the theory of eliminating the wage slave all together through automation and a basic income. I don't think those goals are by virtue in conflict with democracy but I can see how they could be. Whether you agree with it's plausibility or not, I think that in and of itself is a worthy goal.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoWith automation and a basic income, why does it matter what government you have? Economic system is independent.
- AndrewKemendo 13y agoAgreed to some extent. I think certain types of governments would not allow that level of disengagement.
- zabuni 13y agoI've seen stuff like this on both sides. It's what happens when one's desire for change and despair at trying to get the vulgar masses to the self evident "right" thing drives them to misanthropy. It's a misanthropy that sees the rise Leninist vanguard revolutionaries, or Straussian nocturnal councils. Or every armchair revolutionary on the Internet, on any side, who has ever furiously stamped on his keyboard the hoary phrase "Wake up SHEEPLE!" It is the person who cannot convince the world of their position, and then comes to the conclusion the problem is the world.
- justanother 13y agoThis post reminds me of my problems with reading sites like Zerohedge. They're right about a few things, including severe structural issues in the current monetary system. But as soon as I hit the word 'SHEEPLE', I immediately close the browser tab and stop reading. The word strikes me as intellectually lazy on several levels, and this is certainly one of them.
- Apocryphon 13y agoI've heard about Leo Strauss, and his influence on neoconservatism, but do nocturnal councils actually exist, or are they a hypothetical philosophical idea? A far-right equivalent to vanguard revolutionaries would be interesting.
- guard-of-terra 13y agoThere is a desperate call for better democracy. A good way to demand it is by exposing other options. Btw, there was a prime minister of Bulgaria who was also a king by birthright. Talk about elective monarchy.
- ajcarpy2005 13y agoIn theory, democracy can be a somewhat workable system. (I wouldn't say robust but workable.) In practice, at least in the last many decades, we have seen what happens when special interest groups get to write their own laws and regulations behind the scenes...often getting voted on in Congress before there's time to even read the bills. Maybe the solution is to somehow 'democratize' the special interest groups? Well, I've basically advocated for awhile now that we need a larger group of representatives. (it seems ridiculous to expect a few hundred elected lawmakers to regulate the government. Either that or we just need smaller government but if we want the government to regulate as much as it does in modern times, it's going to continue evolving as technology and industries evolve and that's one reason why special interest groups have gained so much power. They serve a purpose in government. It's just not transparent and 'refereed' like it should be.
- spindritf 13y agoIt may be a small, minority world view, but it’s one that I think shines some light on the psyche of contemporary tech culture. It does. And investigating why geeks are into HBD or nootropics could probably be an interesting article. I wondered about it. Maybe you could even take a look where this disappointment with the regular media/science/gov is coming from. this interest just happens to coincide with growing media attention being paid to the problems of the tech industry, from sexism in video games to “bro culture” in the tech industry to gentrification in the Bay Area. Haha. Or inflate your own importance and call people racist. That will probably, and sadly, get even more clicks (while fuelling disapointment with the media).
- ejstronge 13y agoUsing the word 'racist' is inflammatory and often seems to be an affront, so I can appreciate your disappointment with the author. However, I don't see how many 'human biodiversity' (HBD) claims are not racist - that is, they make claims about individuals based on the social construct of race though they ostensibly mean to discuss 'biology.'
- davidgerard 13y agoThey seriously talk about "African" as if it were a tight genetic grouping (like Icelanders or Ashkenazim) - Africa has the greatest human genetic diversity per distance of anywhere, as one would expect (diversity per distance is greatest near the point of origin).
- Chen77 13y agoWho is they? What I find amazing is that people are surprised that group differences have arisen over the last 50,000 years. Gene-culture coevolution makes it seem inevitable that different cultures will favor different traits. Therefore you're going to see some average differences. There are obvious examples, a more polygamous society where women do more of the work (eg female farming systems) with lower paternal investment, might favor different traits to those where there is State control, monogamy and greater paternal investment. I'd recommend that you read some posts by Steve Hsu, Peter Frost, or 'The 10,000 Year Explosion: How Civilization Accelerated Human Evolution'.
- kijin 13y agoThe problem with Kings and Queens is that even the best ones expire after a while (... but maybe not, if you believe the transhumanists) and the replacement tends to be even less accountable than the Presidents and Prime Ministers of today's governments are. If you get Nerva, Trajan, Hadrian and Marcus Aurelius all in the same century, you're lucky. You could have just as easily gotten five Neros and five Caligulas in a row, or an alternating series of Catholics and Protestants who try to kill everyone who was loyal to the previous monarch. With a democracy, you can't optimize the society to the same degree of perfection as you can with philosopher kings, but you also get to avoid the worst crashes. Do you want extreme performance or do you want reliability? Hint: human lives are supposed to be many times more important than records in your database.
- AndrewKemendo 13y ago>With a democracy, you can't optimize the society to the same degree of perfection as you can with philosopher kings, but you also get to avoid the worst crashes. A great point; I like to think of Democracy as median filtering, it smooths extremes.
- Apocryphon 13y ago“What I want is a good, strong monarchy with a tasteful and decent king who has some knowledge of theology and geometry and to cultivate a Rich Inner Life.”
- davidgerard 13y ago"And a magical flying unicorn pony that ejaculates rainbows." When we actually get a donkey with an ice cream cornetto smooshed onto its head, wings nailed on and it's been fed laxatives and food colouring. So yeah, software requirements documents.
- strlen 13y agoSeems like a reaction (no pun intended) to a false dilemma: either unlimited direct democracy (majoritarianism) and equality of outcomes or unlimited monarchy and lack of what is termed "equality of liberty" (every individual is treated equally before the law). Whenever I hear someone who claims to like liberty preach against democracy in favour of reaction and monarchy, I feel they miss that when classical liberal enlightenment thinkers (who were the first to speak of individual liberty, advocate for free trade, property rights, and abolition of compulsory membership in guilds) critized democracy, the word democracy didn't mean what it means today: it meant direct and unlimited Athenian-style democracy, that lead to Socrates' death. To add to this, they mistake traditionalism/conservatism of Edmund Burke (in a way, the intellectual founding father of the US republican party and modern Tories) who happened to criticize French revolution with actual continental reactionary politics (of Hegel, Metternich, De Maistre, etc...) Here's a tendency to explain Burke's support of American Revolution followed by opposition to the French revolution for a change in his views: in reality, they were consistent -- he was appalled by the Jacobins, but supported constitutional law, equality of freedom (arguing for emancipation of Catholics and against imperialism/subjugation of India), and so forth... When reactionaries speak against democracy they do so for entirely different reasons than when US founding fathers (or the philosophers that inspired them) warned against democracy. The reasons reactionary thinkers from Plato onwards despised democracy had more to do with the fact that they saw democratic cities as having _too much_ freedom. They absolutely despised private property, trade, and the middle/upper-middle classes (all of which are likely sacred with these neo-reactionaries). Their idea of monarchy was far more similar to Byzantine absolutism, as opposed to constitutional monarchy of e.g., Franz Josef of Austro Hungarian Empire (who, incidentally, also despised nationalism and presciently saw it as an incredibly destructive force) or even "enlightened absolutism" of Fredrick The Great. So here's a "radical" thought: despite all of its flaws, limited (de-facto or de-jure) constitutional government (a.k.a. "rule of law" in English speaking countries, and "rechstaat" in German speaking countries), genuine social _and_ economic liberalism (aka "classical liberalism"), and democracy have (overall) greatly increased human liberty, happiness, and productivity. There's tons of rooms for debate -- but I'd imagine most honest left-liberals would much prefer to live in, e.g., US under Reagan or UK under Thatcher than in Fidel's Cuba, while most honest libertarians/conservatives would much prefer to live in social-democratic countries of Western Europe/Scandinavia than in Spain under Franco, Portugal under Salazar, or Chile under Pinochet[1]. Conservatives may wax enthusiastically about low taxes in semi-authoritarian Singapore, but I'm not sure if that enthusiasm would continue if they realized that the country also punishes firearm possession by death. Personally, I hope that a broader centrist liberal party emerges in the US (which would also include libertarians as part of its big tent coaliation -- Reagan and Thatcher parroted libertarian ideas, while expanding perhaps most anti-libertarian agenda, namely the War On Drugs). The NSA spying scandal was awful, but one of its results was the begging of a left-right coalition focused on civil liberties. So in all, I think the idea that rule by a new generation of philosopher kings will somehow make us more free seems silly: it's ease to get caught up in the aesthetics of the idea, but it's bizzare to think as to how this may actually strengthen the rights to life, liberty, and property. [1] Obviously all sane people would not want to live in Stalinist USSR, Nazi Germany, or North Korea -- but totalitarianism is a far more rare phenomena than "mere" authoritarianism and isn't really a danger at this point: its bloody record speaks for itself.