5 ms·
Doctors and police are unqualified to have an opinion on what blood looks like? They seem to be the two groups most likely to have an accurate opinion. There's
by kevinpet 13y ago
Doctors and police are unqualified to have an opinion on what blood looks like? They seem to be the two groups most likely to have an accurate opinion.
There's nothing in this article that jumps to conclusions. He's saying it looks off to him. He did some analysis to look for obvious ways it could have been altered and reports that he didn't find any of those. He then investigated the possibility that it's a real but staged photo and offers some possibilities with just slightly more validity than "it looks off" and doesn't overstep the actual data and evidence he has.
- EdwardDiego 13y agoDid you miss the last line? > While it may seem obvious that something is wrong, these issues went unnoticed by a veteran photographer, the Associate Press, and every news outlet that ran the photo. If they are not noticing details like this, then what other forms of media hacking are they not noticing? He concludes 1) It's fake 2) He's smarter than everyone else. It went far beyond "offers some possibilities" way into "making wild assumptions on the basis of a single photo" territory.
- photoJ 13y agoSee earlier history of making strong accusations that were later disproved. http://petapixel.com/2013/05/14/forensics-expert-claims-world-press-photo-winner-a-fake-photographer-responds/ http://petapixel.com/2013/05/14/forensics-expert-claims-worl...
- EdwardDiego 13y agoOh wow, same guy? That's a pretty conclusive debunking of his claims...