4 ms·
You are seriously claiming bits are less fungible than electric power, with the variety of ways power is generated?
by Zigurd 13y ago
You are seriously claiming bits are less fungible than electric power, with the variety of ways power is generated?
- twistedpair 13y agoMost people don't care how it was generated. They want 120V @ 60Hz. That's it. Power companies don't secretly throttle you and then claim they didn't. The poster is talking about broadband access, not 'bits'.
- toast0 13y agoAbsolutely, internet access is less fungible than electric power. In my area, I can purchase my electricity from specific generators, but they don't run a line to my house from the windfarm; instead, all of the generators are connected to the grid, and so is my house, and I get a nice sinusoidal 220-240 VAC @ 60hz. In contrast, if I choose between different ISPs, ignoring the inherent differences in latency and bandwidth of the medium and protocols, my packets could have a very different path through the internet depending on how my ISP is interconnected with the rest of the network. If they embrace local peering, then my bits may not need to travel over very many networks when connecting to relatively local destinations. If they shun local peering, but have good local transit, then my bits may have to travel over more networks, but not travel far. If they shun local peering, and their transit is also not local, then my bits will have to travel a long way to get where they want to go. If the peering or transit connections are inadequately sized, then there will be congestion there that's dependent on my choice of ISPs. There is fungibility in bringing my bits to a specific carrier neutral location; but bringing my bits to the internet at large is not fungible. If you want to regulate as a utility connecting homes to the nearest internet exchange point, for some definitions of nearest and internet exchange point, that's probably the limit of coherent regulation.
- Amadou 13y agoIf you want to regulate as a utility connecting homes to the nearest internet exchange point, for some definitions of nearest and internet exchange point, that's probably the limit of coherent regulation. Regulating the guys with the physical plant to be nothing more than a physical plant would be a massive improvement over where the US is today. The biggest problem today is that the guys with the physical plant have aspirations of doing more, and that gives them incentive to degrade quality of service for general internet access (which competes with their aspirations). Thus we get things like ~300GB/month bandwidth caps which are enough to impact a typical family of four trying to cut-the-cord and use alternatives like netflix.
- Zigurd 13y agoIn order for that to be true you have to accept vertical integration of ISP as inevitable, rather than artificial. Structural separation could be implemented tomorrow, and would be a Very Good Thing.
- toast0 13y agoGiven today's ISP market with is dominated by vertically integrated players, I assumed "regulate it as a utility" did not implicitly include structural separation. Many other utility examples do not require structural separation to be regulated like a utility. If the point is structural separation would be a Very Good Thing; then that's what we need to say, and not 'let's regulate it like a utility.' Bear in mind that AT&T already has a history of subverting structural separation with line-shared DSL, so don't expect the existing incumbents to turn it on tomorrow without kicking and screaming.
- Zigurd 13y ago> Many other utility examples do not require structural separation to be regulated like a utility. And yet they are, or they can be. Specifically, generation and delivery of electric power and separate in many places.