3 ms·
I participated in this Hackathon. It was a good hackathon. I am happy for the winners. The truth of the matter is, there were so many entries, that it was a
by breck 13y ago
I participated in this Hackathon.
It was a good hackathon.
I am happy for the winners.
The truth of the matter is, there were so many entries, that it was a complete lottery who ended up winning. I personally thought our app was great, and had a decent shot at winning, but I went to bed assuming 99% odds we wouldn't get picked. With that many entries the odds were not that great.
As lame as this sounds, I've learned the way to really win at Hackathons is to build something you wanted to build anyway. That way, if you win, it's a nice bonus, but you'll come out ahead no matter what.
The judging processes in these things is always suboptimal. I knew it was going to be a nightmare to try and narrow down that many entries to 5 in just a few hours. They were very optimistic in thinking they could pull that off. I think ChallengePost has a great opportunity to improve here by innovating so that if you enter a Hackathon, you get direct feedback from the judges (either quantitative numerical feedback or qualitative comments), so you get some acknowledgement for the hard work put in. The judging was indeed very light--as another data point I don't think we got a single hit on our app-- but I thought they tried to do something unprecedented and did a decent enough job and can learn going forward.
It was a very cool event, I'm happy for the winners, and hopefully some of these Hackathon software tools like ChallengePost and HackerLeague can continue to get better and help alleviate some of these transparency concerns for future Hackathons.
I would definitely recommend participating in future Salesforce Hackathons.
- zaguios 13y agoPaying $500 for a 0% chance to win; that doesn't sound like the best deal to me. You can get a lot more value from a regular hackathon that you can actually get some attention and feedback from and that isn't going to charge you a crazy amount of money. I don't understand how you can justify the competition when your app wasn't even viewed. Edit: Apparently the ticket price was $100 and then reimbursed. That makes it better, but I would still argue you get more benefit from a standard hackathon.
- jorde 13y agoTickets for the Hackathon were $99 a head but they quickly started giving them out for free. I also heard stories that people got reimbursed fro the ticket price if they had payed.
- breck 13y agoOur team (2 people), paid $99 each for Hackerpass tickets, which Salesforce then reimbursed after they started giving them out for free.
- mceoin 13y agoLaunch Hackathon had the best process of the dozen-or-so large hackathons I've been a part of. They split the judging into two rounds: a 4 minute face-to-face interview with 2 mentors (2-minute presentation, 2-minutes for questions), and if you were the top team in your group (10 teams per interview group) then you made it on stage for the grand final pitch to the audience and a judging panel of 6. Things they did well: * Each team received a score and brief feedback afterwards. (Ours was "7/10, it looks like you've solved a real problem for that industry" - so not extensive but our effort was validate, which is psychologically important for the end of a weekend hackathon - especially when you don't make the final round : ) * 20 mentors for preliminary round meant that everyone had their pitch and the process went smoothly and ran on time (seemingly a rare occurrence for these events). * 3 wild-cards. (13 teams eventually pitched) * Face-to-face interviews. A nice change to the theater of pitching an audience. * Grand final was short instead of a 2-hour fiasco where everybody loses interest.
- mceoin 13y agoI don't know anyone involved in the judging or the winning team, but if what is alleged is true (that a team won that violated the terms of service) then my guess is that it was the team actively breaking the rules, and a judging panel selecting what they saw was the best product and being unaware of the violation. Honestly, judging hackathons is tough and screening each team ahead of time is close to impossible - it's not like you're going to code review everybody. Cheaters always get caught.