4 ms·
How else would you expect Verrelli to explain what happened once it became obvious what he told the Supreme Court was not true? It's the solicitor general's re
by zaroth 13y ago
How else would you expect Verrelli to explain what happened once it became obvious what he told the Supreme Court was not true?
It's the solicitor general's responsibility, as it is anyman's responsibility when testifying in court, to ensure his testimony is accurate. He didn't say, "as far as I know, this is what I think we might collect."
The Government made a persuasive argument that collection was limited specifically to the extent required to dismiss the case. This was not an honest mistake, it was a material misrepresentation of fact. There is no plausible deniability here.
I think it's appropriate to discuss what the ramifications should be, but it's naive to think Verrilli was not aware. I think it's also reasonable to question whether Chief Justice Roberts was also aware Verrilli was shoveling shit, seeing as how he appointed every judge currently serving on the FISA court.
- DannyBee 13y ago"It's the solicitor general's responsibility, as it is anyman's responsibility when testifying in court, to ensure his testimony is accurate. " While true, i'm not sure what you expected him to do here. He asked and checked with his prosecutors. They told him they were doing something that they were in fact not doing. I guess I wouldn't expect the guy to personally check all of the many prosecutions here. There has to be some level of trust allowed for. At that point, I would just expect him to correct it if he was wrong. "I think it's appropriate to discuss what the ramifications should be, but it's naive to think Verrilli was not aware." So this i just flat out disagree with. You are basically calling him a liar who is covering his ass. Talking with people who know him quite well, i'm basically told he would never do such a thing, and that he did in fact, do what the article says. With all due respect to your opinion, i choose to believe them over you :) If that makes me naive, so be it. (FWIW: I certainly don't expect you to trust me on this, i'm just explaining why I hold the opinion I do)
- Zigurd 13y ago> He asked and checked with his prosecutors. They told him they were doing something that they were in fact not doing. He is responsible for that. Either the individuals who induced him to commit perjury should be prosecuted, or, if he cannot reveal who those people are or is unwilling, then Verelli is just as guilty.