5 ms·
I think that's totally missing the point of the article. The license plates are being used to track where every person goes over a long period of time, which ca
by greenyoda 13y ago
I think that's totally missing the point of the article. The license plates are being used to track where every person goes over a long period of time, which can uncover some very private information about people, like whether the person is cheating on their spouse, or sees a psychiatrist on a weekly basis.
And yes, you can find this out just by physically following someone wherever they go, but since that's impractical to do on a mass scale, it's not likely to be done for people who aren't targets of specific criminal investigations. License plate scanning collects this personal information indiscriminately about totally innocent people.
And this information is likely to be abused by people in positions of power, just like existing records about people are. I can't count how many times have I've heard about cops getting in trouble for running unauthorized database searches on ex-girlfriends, etc. Detailed data about a person's every movement would be even more tempting to abuse.
- VladRussian2 13y agowell, it is called intelligence fusion centers and license plates is just a minor piece. Pretty spotty. Face recognition info from surveilance cams pretty spotty as well. Credit card transactions - similar. Cell phone position is much better... Once taken together ("fused" dare i say :) - works like a charm i guess. Guys from Palantir would know better i guess what Suspicious Activity Reports are cooked there: http://www.palantir.com/_ptwp_live_ect0/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/PCL_FusionCenters.pdf http://www.palantir.com/_ptwp_live_ect0/wp-content/uploads/2... "...many Fusion Centers have gradually shifted to a broader mission of providing general criminal intelligence and all-crimes, all-hazards analysis support for constituent agencies."
- Amadou 13y ago"...many Fusion Centers have gradually shifted to a broader mission of providing general criminal intelligence and all-crimes, all-hazards analysis support for constituent agencies." Inevitable given that terrorism is effectively non-existent in the US. When you have a great big expensive hammer, you just have use it on something.
- diminoten 13y agoYou're taking actions in public, of course it's not private. Where do we get this idea that, not only do we have a right to privacy, but we have a right to privacy everywhere, all the time? As for potential for abuse, guns can be abused too - that doesn't mean guns aren't allowed at all. Or if your country does ban guns, think of something else that might be abused but is allowed anyway. Just because something could be abused doesn't mean that's a valid reason for not doing that thing.
- pfraze 13y agoThe implication of license plates changed from individual tracking (recording the plate during a crime) to mass tracking (recording all plates all the time). That's very different. Also, misusing a gun is different than misusing information.
- angersock 13y agoWhen one is in public, out of eyesight of any non-friendlies, one does indeed expect privacy. When one is moving across several disparate geographical locations, there is indeed an expectation of privacy. The simple "hurf durf you're in public ergo no privacy ever" argument is horseshit, to put it bluntly.
- res0nat0r 13y agoNot really. Where are these exceptions above you mention defined in the law?
- nitrogen 13y agoAs one example, you are not legally allowed to record a conversation to which you are not a party, and in some states, you need all participants' consent.
- res0nat0r 13y agoBut driving down the street and having your unique identifier on the back of your captured via camera isn't against the law.