15 ms·
I just wrote an article about US tax implications regarding Bitcoin holdings (not transactions! transactions are easy, and well-covered on the Bitcoin wiki). U
by gamblor956 13y ago
I just wrote an article about US tax implications regarding Bitcoin holdings (not transactions! transactions are easy, and well-covered on the Bitcoin wiki). Unfortunately it needs to wind its way through the editorial/fact-/cite-checking process, so it will be some time next year before it makes it into print.
If you have questions about US compliance obligations regarding Bitcoins held in non-US wallets (meaning every major exchange, such as BTCChina, BitStamp, MtGov, and BTC-e), feel free to ask and I'll try to respond over the course of the next day or two.
- eof 13y ago1) If I held xxx bitcoins in a foreign exchange, having bouhgt y% of those xxx coins there; and transfered z% of the coins there; then later turned into cash w% of those coins and withdrew it to my USA bank account; then transfered the remaining xxx-w% coins to my local wallet; what do i do about taxes. 2 ) additionally, of those xxx-w%; i lost a password protecting all of the coins and paid 10% of xxx-w% (measured in bitcoins) for someone to crack the wallet passphrase, then what do i do about taxes? 3) then, my computer got hacked and someone stole the remaining bitcoins leaving me with 0 on my local machine and n (where n is << xxx-w%) in a different, us based wallet, then what do i do about taxes? to be clear, i have 3 questions what happens if 1) happens. what happens if 1) THEN 2) happens. what happens if 1) THEN 2) THEN 3) happens? edit: the z% of coins transferred into the foreign exchange came from services rendered at a fair market value of `d`
- Guvante 13y agoI am not a tax expert, so take this with a grain of salt, but I believe these are accurate answers. 1. Once you mix your coins the value of a coin from your perspective becomes the average cost of a coin. So if you paid $1 for a coin and $100 for another coin, put both into something that made the distinction impossible, and then sold a coin for $150, you would have to pay taxes on $150 - ($100 + $1)/2 or $99.5 of income. Note that turning into non-Bitcoin is the event, type of Bitcoin does not matter, but anything but a Bitcoin does. 2. Technically you would have an income on your gains of xxx-w%. I don't know offhand if you could write off the expense, but I doubt it. 3. You are talking about bitcoins being bitcoins, so no taxable event. Whether it counts as an expense for writing off purposes is another point I don't know. This would likely be a loss so could be deducted. Your edit: Assuming you account for the value of the bitcoins gained at the time you gained them as income (which you should have) then you can consider that as the cost of the bitcoins. If you never counted the value of the bitcoins when you gained them then your cost basis is $0, so the entire value of the cash out is income. There may also be penalties involved in that but they likely won't care for small amounts of original value.
- gamblor956 13y ago1) You pay them! Gain is measured the same way it is with any other asset (including any non-USD currency): sale price less acquisition cost (aka "cost basis" in tax parlance) and certain maintenance expenses. There are other adjustments which probably aren't applicable to digital currency. In this case, it doesn't appear that w was entirely y or z coins, and probably includes coins from both groups. Since the z have a different acquisition cost, generally the calculation is split into smaller sub-calculations to the extent the data is available (gain on sale of the y coins sold, and gain on sale of the z coins sold). The cost basis of goods acquired as compensation is generally the amount treated as income for other tax purposes, usually the fair market value. If a = y coins sold and b = z coins sold, then gain should be... =[sales price allocable to a coins - purchase purchase allocable to a coins] + [sales price allocable to b coins - purchase purchase allocable to b coins] =[[a/w * w sales price - [a/y* y purchase price]] + [b/w * w sales price - [b/z* z purchase price] 2) It should be possible to add the cost of the cracker into the "cost basis" of the xxx-w coins, which should affect the amount of taxable gain on a later sale of some or all of those coins. However, there should not be any immediate or current year tax implications. 3) There are some write-offs for lost or stolen goods. Don't know how applicable they would be to digital goods like Bitcoin since nobody has actually gotten to that point yet! It's not really been established whether digital goods can be "lost" for tax purposes. If analogizing the tangible property, its likely that a court would eventually say they can be lost and thus written-off, but no courts actually gone out and said it...yet. (There have been cases dealing with this on non-tax grounds.) However, in this situation, the tax from #1 is still there, at best there could be a deduction for the losses incurred in #3.
- otoburb 13y agoThe real question around US compliance is how to position Bitcoin holdings in the most favourable light and prove it so that if the IRS initiates an audit then you can provide enough of a trail (e.g. blockchain) to show that you've held onto them for long enough to qualify for certain tax rates and satisfy conditions for capital treatment. When you refer to "wallets" in your comment above, it seems you're only referring to ones that are on Bitcoin exchanges. I think many people would like to know where personal wallets fall, mainly wallets that are on personal computers running bitcoin-qt/Armory/Multibit.
- gamblor956 13y agoThe real question around US compliance is how to position Bitcoin holdings in the most favourable light and prove it so that if the IRS initiates an audit then you can provide enough of a trail (e.g. blockchain) to show that you've held onto them for long enough to qualify for certain tax rates and satisfy conditions for capital treatment. Proving length of ownership is necessary for all capital goods for which the taxpayer hopes to qualify for capital gains rates in the face of an audit. However, audits are retrospective--you don't need IRS permission to claim capital gains rates on your return. You simply need to have supporting documentation to defeat an audit if the IRS audits your return and challenges to applicability of the capital gains rates. I refer only to wallets held on exchanges above because wallets held privately or in the US generally don't incur compliance obligations under the FBAR (foreign bank accounts) or FATCA (foreign financial assets) information reporting regimes. Specifically, the issue is that the FBAR and FATCA reporting regimes apply to accounts held in foreign financial institutions. Any business that holds financial assets for others is considered a financial institution, so any exchange offering bitcoin wallet services should be a financial institution under these laws. Because all of the major bitcoin exchanges are foreign, FBAR and FATCA reporting becomes an issue for U.S. taxpayers. The threshold for having a FBAR reporting obligation is $10,000, and for FATCA is $50,000. In both cases, the value of foreign accounts or assets is translated to USD. Note also that financial institutions are actually defined somewhat differently for FBAR vs FATCA contexts. Bitcoin payment processors appear to be financial institutions in the FBAR context, but not in the FATCA context. However, all of the major payment processors are US-based, so FBAR and FATCA don't apply. Generally, U.S. tax law doesn't require you to disclose your domestic assets (the income is what matters.)
- modeless 13y agoIf I transferred money to MtGox, bought bitcoins, and then withdrew those bitcoins from MtGox, does that trigger a foreign account reporting requirement even though the money was overseas for a small amount of time (e.g. 1 month)? If I hold bitcoins at Coinbase, or in my own personal bitcoin wallet, does that trigger a foreign account reporting requirement? Coinbase is a U.S. company, but could the law be read to consider any bitcoin holdings as foreign and therefore require reporting?
- gamblor956 13y agoThat depends on the value of the Bitcoins held in the MtGox account. If it was worth more than $10,000, which is very possible considering the meteoric rise of Bitcoins this year, you could have an FBAR reporting requirement. A FBAR reporting requirement means that next year you would need to file a Form TD-F 90.22-1, electronically, by June 30th. The form itself is for the most part simple and self-explanatory. As for the Coinbase coins, for the most part, "foreign" in "foreign currency" means issued by a foreign government. The government generally refers to Bitcoin and other digital currencies as "virtual" currencies. EDIT: Followup. FATCA, the other foreign reporting requirement, only kicks in if the value of total foreign financial assets exceeds $50,000 at the end of the taxable year. If total foreign financial assets aren't worth $50,000 at the end of the year, FATCA shouldn't apply.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- tadruj 13y agogamblor956 could one get you on the phone/skype/mail?
- trobbs 13y agoFYI SCAM ALERT GAMBLOR956 IS NOT THE AUTHOR OF THIS ARTICLE. I AM. MY EMAIL ADDRESS IS ON THE WEBSITE BITCOINTAX.INFO REPEAT. GAMBLOR956 IS NOT THE AUTHOR OF THE WEBSITE.
- gamblor956 13y agoUnfortunately, no. While my firm is generally okay with me providing non-specific comments like this anonymously online, or to provide legal advice pro bono or for compensation, I'm not allowed to provide client-specific tax advice separately from my employment without prior approval. If Mr. Robbins hadn't blown his gasket, I would have suggested contacting him. Unfortunately, I've since reviewed his LinkedIn profile and I can't in good conscience recommend an advisor who has been practicing for less than a year, has no tax background (LL.M, prior accounting employment, or even just experience from time spent in practice), and has demonstrated poor judgment in an online board linked to his real-life profile. Bitcoin taxation isn't a settled issue; most of the concepts are extensions and analogizations from other areas of tax law which can't be fully understood in only a few months of professional practice. My recommendation: if you're on the West Coast, reach out to Loyola Law School's LL.M program and ask them to recommend an alum; if you're on the East Coast, reach out to NYU or UMiami's LL.M programs. LL.M programs are usually very good at helping connect prospective clients to their alumni.
- drewblaisdell 13y agoIf my BTC withdrawals total less than $10,000 in a year, do I still have to worry about paying?
- gamblor956 13y agoPossibly, it's not a matter of withdrawals, it's a matter of how much you have/had in the account. If at any point during the year, your bitcoin account held in a foreign exchange would have been worth more than $10,000 when converted to USD, you're supposed to file the FBAR form (TD-F 90-22.1) by June 30th of the following year.
- trobbs 13y agoYOU ARE FREAKING KIDDING ME RIGHT? THIS IS NOT YOUR ARTICLE. YOU CITE TO MY WEBSITE AND SAY THAT YOU ARE THE AUTHOR?? GAMBLOR956 IS NOT AUTHOR OF ARTICLE AUTHOR OF ARTICLE IS AVAILABLE BY CONTACT INFO ON THE WEBSITE!!!
- trentmb 13y agoThe person you are replying to never made such a claim. Remind me not to hire you as an attorney in the future.
- gamblor956 13y agoCalm down, dude. I never claimed to be the author of your article, and I quite specifically stated that my article was on Bitcoin holdings, not transactions, as the bulk of your article is. Writing an overview about Bitcoin-related tax issues doesn't make you the author of every Bitcoin tax article that will ever be written. There are a lot of tax advisors out there with an interest in Bitcoin; I've spoken with at least a dozen who are submitting articles to various print journals discussing Bitcoin and digital currency-related tax issues. Finally, while we're on the subject of contact info... I can't help but notice that you appear to be employed by an accounting firm. I've actually done business with your firm, and I don't think they would appreciate one of their associates publishing an online tax article without first going through the internal review process and having it vetted. (You should re-read your employment contract, almost every law firm and accounting firm has something on this subject in there.) Moreover, you may want to expand upon your Circular 230 warning and the legal advisory notice at the start of the article, since both are inadequate. Finally, you really should change every instance of would to should because your are implying a level of certainty that doesn't (and can't) yet exist about the tax treatment of Bitcoins. (This is why I used should and probably in my answers--I'm not offering a covered opinion, merely expressing the potential application of the current state of the law to the provided facts as I understand them.) You weren't that hard to find on LinkedIn, and your behavior on this board reflects poorly on yourself and your firm.
- trobbs 13y agoApologies. I had received several emails referring to "my" comments on this board and was obviously upset. People were taking an inference we were the same person that I now see was not intended. As to the rest, appreciate the comments and suggestions.
- otoburb 13y ago>>I just wrote an article about US tax implications regarding Bitcoin holdings (not transactions! transactions are easy, and well-covered on the Bitcoin wiki). The stated author of the article, Tyler S. Robbins, reached out to me to state that you (@gamblor956) are not the author of the article linked by the submitter. Evidently he's been downvoted trying to point this out. Perhaps the unintentional implication inferred by most on this thread is that that you personally wrote the linked article, when in fact you may be referring to a different article you wrote about US tax implications that has yet to be published (as you stated above). Hope this clears things up for anybody else that may have unintentionally made the same inference. I'm meeting Mr. Robbins on Monday to discuss some of the issues he raised in his article. EDIT: I see that he's put a warning at the top of article to clear up any misunderstandings.
- gamblor956 13y agoAh yes when I posted my comment it was originally obvious that I wasn't referring to the same post as the linked article. My article is for a print tax publication targeted at tax advisors, and comes out next spring; Mr. Robbins' article is clearly not intended for print and is aimed more toward laymen. Also, Mr. Robbins has updated the article since I posted my comment, so generally all of the questions I have received would now be answered by his article.
- Zircom 13y ago>Evidently he's been downvoted trying to point this out. That shouldn't really come as a surprise, given the way he went about it. Making an entire post using caps lock is usually frowned upon, to say the least, and, as has been pointed out, no such claims were ever made in the first place, it's perfectly clear that grandparent is referring to a completely separate article that's yet to even be published.
- pathy 13y ago>Evidently he's been downvoted trying to point this out. As he should have been, replying in all caps while being unable to comprehend what gamblor956 wrote. gamblor956 did not imply that he was the author of the article, rather the author of AN article on a related topic. Coming to hasty conclusions and calling out a friendly poster hardly speaks highly of the OP. He should read more carefully in the future and not overreacted, I would be hesitant to trust such a personality, an attorney should know better.
- simonebrunozzi 13y agoHey, thanks for your availability. This is my situation: I bought a few bitcoins on Coinbase (US account), made some money, sold them. Is that profit taxable?
- gamblor956 13y agoProbably. Making money = income, and income is taxable. The question really is...what type of income? For the most part, unless you've held the coins for longer than a calendar year, the income is short-term capital gains, or as it is frequently known to tax advisors, ordinary income with a special name.
- simonebrunozzi 13y agoThanks a lot.
- ctn75 13y agoHey guys. I'm a simple man with a knack for trading. I have a situation here that's probably similar to some of you and I'm hoping any of you can shed some light. Got into bitcoin trading last 3 weeks ago on localbitcoins and I've made some gains due to recent spike in btc price. I've probably made purchases around $1,400 at most. Some of my deals were done with buyers who are also outside the country and converted to USD. Would that constitute my activities as illegal? I just recently read about the FINCEN regulation and I've now decided to stop trading bitcoins. Am I still obligated to register at FINCEN as an MSB even if I'm planning to discontinue after 3-4 weeks of trading? Would I be fine if I just honestly report my gains in my income tax? Or should I fear anyone coming knocking at my door? Please advise. Thanks so much and I would really appreciate it if you can shed some information.