3 ms·
> we already know the simple principle by which you can lose weight. We know of one simple principle (eat less, to the point of losing weight), that's extremel
by beagle3 13y ago
> we already know the simple principle by which you can lose weight.
We know of one simple principle (eat less, to the point of losing weight), that's extremely hard to practice. Turns out that no other principle works consistently for all the population (usually around 80%), and this one simple principle (doctors hate it!) leads some people (I heard estimates range from 5-20%) to significantly worse quality of line (including depression, sleep problems, anxiety, concentration problems).
It is easy to change your routine in many ways - e.g., a lot of people have no problem adding a couple of jelly donuts per day. Or to stop going to the gym even if you've done it for years. It is possible that such a change of routine is possible for overweight, but it hasn't yet become popular (or discovered).
From all the anecdata I've been able to collect, Soylent seems to leave people satisfied for long, compared to foods with similar caloric content (Not comparing to other meal replacements here - to your random everyday food). So does fat in general, if consumed sufficiently far away from carbs (Bullet proof coffee) or flavour (shangri-la "diet"). None of these seem to work for everyone, but e.g. 80% of people on shangri-la self-report an immediate, considerable, appetite suppression affect.
The accepted body of knowledge with respect to nutrition, appetite and hunger seems to be all wrong; nutrition "science" is not. There's actual science to be done here, but it is not done in academic institutes - mostly by individuals, so it's taking longer than you expect to get quality results (and even longer to take them seriously when they are found).