3 ms·
"So I could eat 10,000 calories of fat per day..." Try it. No carbs, just fat & protein, 10,000 calories. Seriously, try it. Just one day. Won't hurt you. It
by jerf 13y ago
"So I could eat 10,000 calories of fat per day..."
Try it. No carbs, just fat & protein, 10,000 calories.
Seriously, try it. Just one day. Won't hurt you.
It is possible to consume 10,000 calories of carbs in a day. Short of physically stuffing it in, you will find it effectively impossible to eat 10,000 calories of fat and protein. You'll probably find it a challenge to go beyond 3,000. (Though if you switch to a high-fat, high-protein diet you might manage in the first couple of days before your body adjusts fully. And I'm assuming you're average; a large man might get 4K, but again, that'll be a challenge.)
Calories are not fungible. And once you accept that, it's frankly hard to look at the evidence, the biochemistry and how the hormones work, and not end up fingering carbs as the source of the obesity epidemic, not fat.
You may find it interesting to note that carbs all come from plants. (But not all plants, of course.)
- mason55 13y agoThe issue people take is that when people talk about this they frequently make it sound like carbs are what make cause obesity (eg the title of this post). However it's not that carbs cause obesity it's that carbs allow you to easily consume lots of calories and excess calories cause obesity. It's funny because most of the "carbs are bad" and "carbs are fine" people agree that in reality it's calories that make you fat. For some reason when they talk to each other that point gets lost and it turns into two people talking past each other who agree in actuality.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoCarbs also trigger an insulin response, which commands the body to store excess glucose not currently being burned as fat: http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=carbohydrates+insulin+fat+storage http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=carbohydrates+insulin+fa...
- jerf 13y agoThat's because "calories make you fat" is effectively a tautology. "You are fat" and "you are over consuming calories" may be two different English sentences, but they say the same thing. People get confused because of the English and think they can use one sentence to explain the other, but it doesn't make any sense. The correct question is, why do people over consume calories? And for that you get two very different answers. One is an external answer about how food has been made very available and appealing and is manufactured to be overconsumed (and often more than a faint whiff of Puritan moralism, indeed, often a great deal more than a faint whiff), and the other is about the biochemistry of consuming food and what happens to the satiety mechanisms and your blood sugar and where the blood sugar goes and why and how it comes back out again. There's a real difference at that level.
- fingerprinter 13y agoIMO, it would be better for the general public to think of them as "bad" rather than "good" as we do now. Most people shouldn't be consuming carbs, nearly at all. In general, the average person should be high fat, mod protein, low carb (very low) and they would be in much better overall health. I think the problem is that carbs, much more than either of the other 2 macros, have more complex mechanisms at play. For instance, carbs in the morning or at night? Most people know that you are burning fat when you wakeup from your overnight fast. But what most people don't know is that the first time you eat carbs, the fat burning stops. 6 meals or 2? Smaller insulin spikes over time lead (it appears) to insulin resistance moreso than one or two big spikes. The jury is a bit out on this, but the data is leaning this way (last I looked). The meal frequency doesn't really matter with protein and fat, just carbs it seems. Those are just some examples, but I think you get the idea. My mother (65) recently asked me what she should do for her diet in old age. Simple, I told her, eat lots of fish, meat, veggies, cream and some nuts. Avoid grains, bread, over doing it on fruit etc. She's worried about living a long time, heart health and cancer. No reason she should be anywhere near carbs.
- a8da6b0c91d 13y ago> average person should be high fat You probably want to be getting a substantial fraction of your calories from sugars and starches, mixed with fat and protein. Ya know, like portions in cuisine all around the world has favored for ages. I used to buy this high fat idea before reading more broadly. Firstly, non-saturated fats should be avoided to the extent possible, and that's hard to do on a high fat diet. Secondly, high fat meals are clearly inflammatory. More inflammatory than carbs. They cause endotoxin absorption and promote dysbiosis. The hormone profile of being a "fat burner" is not so great either. Cortisol goes up, because that drives fat metabolism. This is why people who go atkins or go on a fast say they feel great. It's elevated cortisol, just like a runner's high. That's fine in short doses, but sustained it leads to breakdown and damage. Relax and have some sugary chocolate milk. It's perfectly healthy. Almost a balanced meal, in fact.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoThe first couple days are rough. "Keto flu". After that, you shed pounds like crazy. I'm 31 (on Saturday), 5'6" and 173lbs (currently). I consume ~2000 calories a day, almost all protein and fat. I endeavour to keep my carbs under 20g/day. 4 protein shakes a day (170 calories/35g protein/1g sugars), plus sensible keto lunches and dinner. With no exercise (I sit 8-10 hours/day at a desk) I lose about 1 pound every 2-3 days. Your body literally sheds fat on a low/no carb diet. EDIT: After I'm down to my goal weight (150-155lbs), I plan on powerlifting. With large amounts of exercise, anaerobic or aerobic, you need to start consuming carbs to have the energy required. You're no longer at an energy surplus; based on your exercise level, you're shooting for coming out energy neutral.
- zdean 13y agoOk, then I'll rephrase my question: If I consume 3-4k calories of fat per day and exclude all carbs, will I lose weight? The answer is still "No, not if I'm using fewer than 3-4k calories in my daily activity." I've been a lean 168, an obese 250, and am now a pretty healthy 175-180 pounds. As a matter of principle (I love food!!), I don't change what I eat over time. It's a healthy balance...but it's a lot of calories. If I'm active, I lose weight. If I'm sedentary, I gain weight. The fact is, if I have a consistent surplus of calories, I'm going to get fat. Period.
- beagle3 13y agoGood for you. For some people, level of activity matters little, and intake composition (with amounts less relevant) making all the difference. I've been a very active fat-but-not-obese 220, and a lean-but-not-active 170, and my "calorie intake" was larger on the latter. I can easily go lean by going down to a 500-calorie-a-day diet for 2 months; And then, for 6-8 months, my intake doesn't seem to matter - I stay lean - until all of a sudden, with no change of intake, and within a couple of weeks, I balloon 20-30 lbs, that stay there until the next "low-calorie" period. Yes, this is baffling. No, I haven't figured it out yet, though gut bacteria and similar explanations seem much more relevant than anything else at this point. Read this guy about consuming 6k/day: http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/sam-feltham/why-i-didnt-get-fat-from-eating-too-much_b_3428524.html http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/sam-feltham/why-i-didnt-get-... - I've known other examples. calorie counting is NOT science, physics or thermodynamics, and produces miserable results for some people.
- DanBC 13y ago> going down to a 500-calorie-a-day diet for 2 months Re-feeding programmes for people with anorexia are carefully worked out to avoid problems. How were you re-feeding after this extreme modification to your diet? > http://www.huffingtonpost http://www.huffingtonpost This ruins your credibility. > calorie counting is NOT science, physics or thermodynamics, It is. Really, truly, it is. > and produces miserable results for some people. This may well be true. Reading this thread is clear evidence that people have horrible understanding of diet and nutrition, and that people get information from weird sources. I can easily imagine someone reducing calories to 1,800 per day but having a miserable time because they're also following some stupid advice they got from a quack.