4 ms·
Perhaps I am too influenced in my opinions of philosophy by my girlfriend, an ardent adherent to Kantian (transcendental) idealism - and she's German, to boot.
by barrkel 17y ago
Perhaps I am too influenced in my opinions of philosophy by my girlfriend, an ardent adherent to Kantian (transcendental) idealism - and she's German, to boot. We've gotten into heated standoffs over it, so we've mutually agreed not to bring it up.
I agree that a priori knowledge is tautological and subject to refutation via Gödel; and as a self-described software engineer (as opposed to a computer scientist) I suspect I have an inherent bias towards valuing empiricism over idealism.
I don't subscribe too strongly to the "blank slate" idea, at least not insofar as it relates to the "nature vs. nurture" debate. I believe a lot more is embedded in the nature, in the inherited evolutionary makeup, than most people would like to admit. I think much "knowledge" (such as how to acquire language) is "baked in" at the physical level, in the genome and proteome; but of course, this knowledge is not a priori, it comes from the "experience" that the evolutionary line of mechanical interactions has shaped.
- Locke1689 17y agoYes, I was unclear. When I meant knowledge, I was using Hume's treatment of knowledge, which is predominantly intellect based. That is, instinct and human brain capacities etc, etc, are not part of "knowledge." The current nature vs nurture debate is important, but not what I was talking about.