3 ms·
Something I find astonishing is that the passenger/employee ratio of no-frills airlines is more than 10 times that of traditional airlines, yet all the labour r
by fauigerzigerk 17y ago
Something I find astonishing is that the passenger/employee ratio of no-frills airlines is more than 10 times that of traditional airlines, yet all the labour related savings together seem to make up a relatively small part of overall savings. Any explanation for that?
- arihelgason 17y agoMy guess is that it's because labour is not a very large % of overall costs. A similar example is the car industry. Car manufacturing plants are often located in high wage countries, simply because labour does not represent a large % of the overall cost of producing a car.
- mediaman 17y agoLabor is actually a substantial part of airlines' expenses. Southwest's most recent SEC filing indicates that its 35,000 employees represent 32% of its total operating costs, or about $3.4bn. These employees served about 101.9 million passengers. [1] That's about 2,911 passengers per employee, or $33 of labor cost per passenger. A traditional airline such as American Air, with 70,900 employees, has labor costs of $5.9bn, serving just 98 million passengers [2], which is 1,382 passengers per employee or $60 labor cost per passenger. So costs per passenger are almost 2X. That makes me question the data in this chart. The only two data points related to labor are crew costs (3% of savings) and administration (2%). But actual labor costs appear to be a much more substantial part of the savings. [1] http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/92380/000119312509015591/d10k.htm http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/92380/000119312509015... [2] http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/4515/000000451509000008/aa120810k.htm http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/4515/0000004515090000...
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoThere's probably some labour cost hidden in other categories as well, like station costs and reservation costs. But still, I'd expect labour to rank much higher considering that 10:1 productivity advantage. There's actually another thing that's surprising. Low cost airlines, at least in europe, have a younger fleet of aircraft using less fuel. That doesn't seem to figure in the chart either.
- mjs 17y agoThey fly much shorter routes. I guess the number you really want to know is the number of staff per passenger kilometer, but the graphic doesn't say... Other flaws: * Misspells Aer Lingus. * Claims low cost airlines have turnarounds of "up to 25 min" instead of "as little as 25 min." * The 43% cost advantage is unclear (that's the cost advantage per passenger kilometer, or what?) and circles are not a good way to convey amount (is the radius important, or the diameter?).
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoYes you're absolutely right. Staff per passenger kilometer is the missing piece of information. Very good point.