7 ms·
What happens when the U.S. President uses your startup for a conference call
- bitemix 13y ago$9.99? This is why most people offer an enterprise plan.
- antr 13y agoI agree, nonetheless it's something the mixlr team will learn from and adjust their sails accordingly.
- Goopplesoft 13y agoI'm surprised OFA thought it'd work at their scale at that price point. I'd definitely be cautious and offer to pay more if I was their procurement officer. It could definitely ruin your night.
- giovannibajo1 13y agoThe blogpost says that OFA contacted them and forewarned about the size of the call. I guess that's the point where Mixlr could have asked an extra to handle the scale, while it sounds like they just said "no problems, go ahead".
- Goopplesoft 13y agoRight, I was implying that even after they said 'no problems, go ahead' (perhaps by opening the discussion about an enterprise plan). My reasoning is because it makes it easier to shift blame for the procurement officer. In the event of a service failure instead of being picked on for hosting a presidential conference for the price of a chipotle, you can blame the company you paid a good amount of money to for their crappy service. Anyhow, glad everything worked out and I'm sure they made up for it in marketing.
- giovannibajo1 13y agoI see. I reckon it doesn't work either way. Think of how wonderful would have been to run a flawless presidential conference call with $9.99, instead of, for instance, procuring a custom-made IBM+Cisco contract for $200k. Maybe there's a number in the middle, but I think it's hard to draw a line. At the end of the day, if I were a US citizen, I would prefer my government to attempt with a $9.99 service that went almost flawlessly, rather than ditch it just because "it's cheap, it can't work, we must pay at least $X".
- Goopplesoft 13y agoAlthough they're private and won't be paying using tax payer money, I agree and kudos to them. I was just addressing the risks associated with such a thing.
- zer0defex 13y agoCool story, but I hope permission was received first to divulge those account usage details.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gcb1 13y agothat subject line... "Re: draft: ask white house permission"
- JoblessWonder 13y agoWhat was there before it was deleted?
- octo_t 13y agowhat account details?
- fishercs 13y agoone suggestion after signing up for an account and using the service. I misread and thought there would be video for some reason, i just assumed webcast would mean streaming audio and video. My mistake, but regardless when i went to delete my account i found i couldn't actually do that. I had to send a request to support@mixlr.com to remove an account. Fix that! Overall though, nice product and the app seemed well laid out and easy to use.
- jmilloy 13y agoI think Greg is too close to the events: I still mostly don't know what happened when Obama used Mixlr. Can anyone help out? Some specific questions: >Unfortunately the call was marketed and promoted as a “conference call” ... which does happen to be what Mixlr is intended for Okay, so what is Mixlr for? I poked around and found out briefly, but I'm still curious what Mixlr allows that they didn't use and could have. What did you mean by "nor to the extent of what Mixlr allows"? >This led to some pretty mis-set expectations and disappointed users which wasn’t a great tone to recover from. How do you know users were disappointed? Do you have any data, or at least anecdotes, that you could show? Do users rate their experience, for example? How did you recover? And how did you decide that you recovered already? >Even 10 trolls are a lot louder than 30,000 supporters What actually happened? What features enabled a few people to effect the experience of the other listeners? >Note to self... disable comments I gather that disabling comments is not a feature available to the broadcaster? Maybe it should be; are you considering adding it? What other changes will you be making as a result of this experience? How will you "do better next time"? >the press are now all over the OFA team The write up makes it sound like the whole event went smoothly, yet you're also saying that there are negative reports in the press. I read the DailyMail article, and it sounds possible that they are exaggerating by citing the minority of users who couldn't connect. What is your takeaway here? Do you have to be perfect in such high profile situations? Or are a few errors expected? Are you getting flak or losing credibility because of the press, or is it all falling on the OFA team? > the call was flawless for the vast majority of those listeners for more than 99% of the call Are more details available? Maybe it's just me, but this sounds wishy-washy (99% always sounds to me like "a lot, we swear!") > we think we can do even better next time Great! Is there going to be a next time? And, more generally, have you noticed any effect on the call on your user base?
- nashashmi 13y agoIt allows for multiple screens to be broadcasted and the screens to be sent to everybody. Everybody can also chime in. Apparently, it was a one way feed from the President to everyone else. Nobody could chime in. How is that a conference call.
- 13y ago
- pearjuice 13y agoFrom an achievement point of view, are there are any challenges after this?
- cdibona 13y agoYep, it turns out that post Obama's use of Moderator (and then hangouts with moderator) we realized that this was only a taste of what can happen when you have a really popular person using your systems. Yes, I'm talking about Lady Gaga. Made Obama look downright pedestrian.
- JumpCrisscross 13y ago>"we realized that this was only a taste of what can happen when you have a really popular person using your systems. Yes, I'm talking about Lady Gaga. Made Obama look downright pedestrian.* If you work at Mixlr I recommend you kill this comment. It's not best practice to compare your "pedestrian" customer to someone "really popular".
- jsmthrowaway 13y agoYou are replying to Chris DiBona, who oversees open source policy at Google. He is referring to Google Moderator.
- vezzy-fnord 13y agoMeanwhile, even though we’re not US voters, our hats are off to the President and his team for being agile, using third party web services and trying to be as engaged as possible with his constituents. We love that he’s done an AMA on Reddit, that his team uses Twitter, Facebook and Instagram regularly, and we’re seriously proud they now use Mixlr too. ------- Hardly. They do maintain some sort of vain presence, so as to appease the college crowd that make use of large amounts of social media, but no actual debate or interesting conversation has been inspired by it. The AMA on Reddit in particular was one of the most pathetic PR stunts I've witnessed in a while. A few generic responses to mundane and chauvinistic questions. But, since his campaign team ended up referencing the "NOT BAD" meme, Reddit swallowed it all up with gusto. It was sad to watch.
- clarky07 13y agodidn't they have planted questions too?
- Wingman4l7 13y agoWhat evidence was there of this?
- clarky07 13y agodidn't they have planted questions too?
- clarky07 13y agodidn't they have planted questions too?
- Wingman4l7 13y ago> A few generic responses to mundane and chauvinistic questions. If you honestly expected any candid answers from a sitting President that diverged from preset soundbites, I have a bridge to sell you.
- biot 13y agoIf I were their VP of Engineering, the questions jmilloy asked would be top of mind for a post mortem. I'd also raise the issue of whether the $9.99 all-you-can-eat plan should have a specific limit in terms of absolute number of live connections. From their pricing page, it looks like OFA could have just used the Basic (free) plan. Even still, they will never recoup their costs from this one call even if OFA remains a $9.99/month subscriber for a decade. If "We worked all weekend..." means two engineers worked 4 hours Saturday and 4 hours Sunday, that's 8 hours/engineer * 2 engineers * $100/hour = $1600 of time was spent. That's 13 years at $10/month, not even factoring in infrastructure or bandwidth costs from the call itself. And I'm guessing that estimate is an order of magnitude less than the actual time spent. If I were a potential customer evaluating providers, I would be scared off by your current offer of what appears to be unlimited usage and unlimited priority support for $10/month as I'd have serious doubts of your ability to remain in business a year from now. No doubt the effort invested in preparation for the OFA call will pay dividends for future scalability, but I doubt the people at OFA would have blinked an eye if you told them that there's a $5 CPM rate for connections beyond the first 100. 140K connections would have been a paltry $700. Obviously, only an analysis of your customer usage patterns would indicate whether you'd impact any serious customers if the basic plan was capped at 100 simultaneous live listeners, with additional tiers for higher peak use. Check out PubNub's pricing model for peak connections as this model makes financial sense: http://www.pubnub.com/pricing http://www.pubnub.com/pricing
- eridius 13y agoYou seem to be under the impression that every single customer needs to generate more money via their subscription than they cost in service. That's absolutely not true. You just need enough customers that pay more than they cost such that it covers the costs on the customers that don't. And don't forget that providing an excellent deal to high-usage customers is a great way to encourage them to refer your service to people they know.
- jason_tko 13y agoThere is a tremendous benefit of grabbing hold of an opportunity, and doing whatever the hell it takes to strangle the value out of it. Which is what these guys were trying to do. This was such an outlier in terms of standard use cases of their system so far, I think the way they responded was great. There's little value in going back and saying "Ohh... this will cost $700, but it's not written on the website, is that still ok?" and risk dealing with rejection. The value of having POTUS use your service far outweighs the engineering time spent on this. This is now a fantastic leading story for all sorts of marketing efforts and meetings moving forwards, such as this blog post. Calculating the return on this effort through short-term ROI measured in days seems a bit shortsighted.
- abbottry 13y ago40 comments, not one trace of "Congrats", who cares what Obamas intentions were, for any founder out there you know this is exciting -- HN is becoming difficult to read. Congrats guys, it has to feel great having something like this go so well!
- shitlord 13y agoSeriously, it's a huge accomplishment, and they deserve to be proud of it. When the president uses your product (even if it's not good) you know you've made it.
- mcenedella 13y agoI disagree with this point, which is not supported by the facts: "The press are now all over the OFA team and criticising their ability to procure technical solutions or web services (rightly or wrongly). But in this case, obviously we’re a third party service provider so this really has nothing to do with the President’s team’s ability to execute." It is indeed a reflection of the President's team's ability to execute when they reach out to a vendor on a Friday for a Monday call, mangle the details so that the vendor and the audience have mis-set expectations, and, most importantly, did not do testing to determine whether or not their event will reflect well on their boss and organization. They've done these calls before - for example, after the State of the Union: http://www.politico.com/politico44/2013/02/obama-doing-ofa-call-after-state-of-the-union-156672.html http://www.politico.com/politico44/2013/02/obama-doing-ofa-c... -- so dropping this order in the lap of a new vendor with 72 hours to go almost guarantees that some mistake will happen. I understand this is OFA, not the White House, and perhaps for a seat-of-the-pants campaign style event under normal circumstances, this would be excusable. But these are not normal circumstances. When your boss is under fire for his rollout of the most important government tech program since the Moon landing, and you arrange a call to discuss that rollout, it is imperative that you make sure the technology works. Guaranteed. No questions asked. If you can't guarantee that, then don't use that vendor, don't do the event as a conference call, or don't do the event. Why? The resulting PR mess, which might not be germane to a start-up tech audience, but is very germane to the Office of The President, will come and will be costly. The post serves to reinforce the image of a management team around the President that does not understand that making very urgent requests of technologists does not mean that the technology will automatically obey.
- hadem 13y agoI never understand the decision behind blogs not putting a link anywhere on their blog to their actual website. 1. Mixlr in the header points me to blog.mixlr.com. 2. Footer links, all of them link to the page I'm on... I know there is a link in the content of the post, but what about other posts? Why is there not an easy way for me to get to your main site without manually modifying the URL in the address bar?
- justhw 13y agoMan, I'm gonna start a list and track sites that do this, like plain text offenders.
- gregPC 13y agoHide from drones?