4 ms·
I disagree that the wifi is a terrible single-point-of-failure. The chief concern in privacy security is not a criminal on the street or a member of your local
by Pxtl 13y ago
I disagree that the wifi is a terrible single-point-of-failure. The chief concern in privacy security is not a criminal on the street or a member of your local police department - it's a vast swarm of overseas hackers or massive advertising conglomerates.
For that case? Keeping the data in your home is fine. Doubleclick and Tribalfusion aren't going to be wardriving your neighborhood.
Honestly, I'm waiting for somebody to make the one-stop zero-configuration grandma-friendly home server device. Something that gives you a DropBox-like file-server with optional internet-cloud mirroring, has a media bay with one-button backup functionality so you can easily get a detached hard-copy, runs a Print server and DNLA, its own Gmail-like webmail/imap system. If you make it a wifi router, it can also run its own domain and whatnot. The problem, of course, is half the ISPs provide a wifi router that isn't grandma-friendly to configure.
Have all your home devices talk to that thing and not the Internet.
- Glyptodon 13y agoThe router is a single point of failure if it's what's hooked up to your modem, especially now that routers frequently come with questionable built in services to make your shares and such available remotely and often have very questionable decisions made when it comes to their web interfaces and even basic things like password storage. Now that may be different than 'wifi,' but color me surprised if in the average home with wifi it's not emanating from a questionably configured router running questionable firmware with a direct connection to the Internet.
- ds9 13y agoSaying the router is a single failure point is a backwards way of saying, let these "things" talk to the internet in other ways too! If the router is properly configured (i.e. the way the owner wants it), it can be a single point of control - and that's the best case. The real threat, mentioning which would have justified the title, is that people may not be able to opt out of all the "things" reporting to outside parties.
- JonSkeptic 13y agoI like that idea a lot. I would throw money at it.
- Pxtl 13y agoPart of it is just imagining a device where you put in one name and a wifi/family password and suddenly this name gets you 1) SSID (say PxtlFamily) 2) Local domain-name for accessing your intranet (http://PxtlFamily http://PxtlFamily) with your imitations of gmail, drive, picasaweb, and the admin panel, with a built-in loginless "family" account for shared stuff. Access to the same files via an FTP server and DropBox-like application. 3) Dynamic Dns public domain name provided by the vendor (http://PxtlFamily.Dyn.Org http://PxtlFamily.Dyn.Org) for anything you want to show to the wider internet (which is nothing by default). 4) Email domain (user@PxtlFamily.Dyn.Org) 5) samba file-server name (\\PxtlFamily) to access to the same shared folder above. Boom, you give it a name and a wifi password and you get all that. Use the wifi password as an access password for wired ethernet connections. You're relying on your wifi to provide security, but that's the most you can realistically expect from home users anyways. Then you can let users create their own accounts for all the private stuff. Just let them make their own accounts since they're already semi-trusted since they've got the Family password. Obviously you would want to offer the users more granularity in configurations as they want - support for encryption, rights controls, etc. But this is the bare-minimum "I buy it and I give it a name and a wifi password". You give users a massive motherlode of functionality and it's more secure than just about everything on the internet because it's not on the internet. Just stick a cheap cellphone touchscreen on the darned thing for admin actions until the user gets around to setting up an admin account. The amount of software you'd have to write to create such a thing would be a beast though.
- eterm 13y agoBut then the fridge maker wouldn't have "anonymised usage statistics" (to sell) so where's the incentive for them to make a smart fridge?
- Symmetry 13y agoCharing you $10 more for a fridge that saves you $5 on your power bill every year. Differentiating is really hard for white goods manufacturers, so they tend to end up with commodity levels of profit on what they sell.