2 ms·
Why are we arguing about the "usefulness" when it should be a crime against the human right to privacy, and possibly many national laws and constitutions throug
by mtgx 13y ago
Why are we arguing about the "usefulness" when it should be a crime against the human right to privacy, and possibly many national laws and constitutions through out the world?
At the very least, even without abuses (which is ridiculous to even contemplate that there weren't/aren't any) mass surveillance can create chilling effects on free speech, journalism, and creativity and innovation in general, as well as to progress in a society.
How do you admit you are gay or try to convince others that being gay is okay, in a society where the vast majority are against it, and the government has zero tolerance for it, for example? In a society that monitors everything, it would be very hard to turn being gay from "illegal" to "legal.
And that's just one example: women using birth control, doing abortions, being of different faith, smoking pot, copying an image "illegitimately" from the web and so on, can all be "illegal" at some point, in any society.
- DanBC 13y ago> Why are we arguing about the "usefulness" when it should be a crime against the human right to privacy, and possibly many national laws and constitutions through out the world? It's a pragmatic approach to preventing this stuff from happening. The "privacy is a right!" stuff just doesn't work for some people. So, for those people, it's handy to have other arguments. "It's expensive and doesn't work! Let's spend that money on cops and gang-reconciliations instead!" may be more effective.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoThis 'pragmatic approach' unfortunately changes the subject from the important one to something refutable. As such, it could be a political ploy to create support for illegal/unconstitutional wiretapping etc.
- DanBC 13y ago> unfortunately changes the subject Supplements the discussion. There are plenty of people, with real power, who don't care about what's legal (and perhaps what's constitutional) because terrorists. (See also because pedophiles). For those people you need to let them know that their over-reaching privacy invasions aren't just a matter of constitutional niceties (their terms, not ours) but actually ineffective.
- JoeAltmaier 13y ago...unless it isn't actually ineffective. Then they're vindicated, conversation over. That's the ploy.