14 ms·
The American Police State
- spodek 13y ago> Men like him lived a paradox. The penal system was supposed to shape them up. But its tentacles had become so invasive that the opposite happened. Goffman argues that the system encourages young men to act shady—"I got to move like a shadow," one of Mike's friends told her—because a stable public routine could land them back behind bars. > Take work. Once, after Mike was released on parole to a halfway house, he found employment at a Taco Bell. But he soon grew fed up with his crowded house and decided to sleep at his girlfriend's. That resulted in a parole violation. When Mike went back to the Taco Bell to pick up his paycheck, two parole officers arrested him. He had to spend another year upstate. This passage described a poor black man in Philadelphia -- the tip of the iceberg in the story. Today I happened to read about Toronto's mayor and couldn't help compare the two. Toronto's mayor is on video smoking crack, is drunk and disorderly in public, shoves (assaults?) a grandmother, more, and isn't even removed from office, let alone arrested. How can anyone have faith in such a system with such gross inequalities? The differences in cities and countries pale in comparison to the differences in treatment between the two people. EDIT: a couple comments point out the differences between the U.S. and Canada police forces. Fair enough, but as different as Toronto and Philadelphia may be and as different as Canada and the U.S. may be, I can't imagine those differences are lost on the men jailed for smaller infractions, asking "What does it take for a rich, white guy to have to go to jail? ... Why should I bother trying to stay out if nothing I can do can keep me out?" I'm sure we could just look at police on Philadelphia's Main Line, maybe ten minutes away, to find similar effects to avoid the U.S./Canada comparison.
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoCanadian and US law enforcement are pretty different... Edit - response to your edit: The US white incarceration rate is ~5-7x the total incarceration rate in Canada.
- bediger4000 13y agoGreat, I did not know that. Which one works better? That is, which style of law enforcement produces a safer civil society?
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoI'd put my money on Canada, but the truth is probably hard to distill.
- vinceguidry 13y agoMy guess would be that law enforcement doesn't do much at all for public safety and the level of violence in any given area is probably driven by economic or other factors.
- AYBABTME 13y agoI'd say, experimental results show that the canadian way produces safer civil society. But then, I'm completely biased, being Canadian. Anyhow, I do feel much safer in any Canadian city than in the places I've been to in the US. Just compare crime rates for major cities and you'll see for yourself.
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoActually... Crime rates (homicide rates) are starkly similar across the border: http://www.unitednorthamerica.org/images//MurderRate2007.jpg http://www.unitednorthamerica.org/images//MurderRate2007.jpg The dangerous US cities in some other border states throw off the perception, but there is a heck of a lot of difference between Detroit and Toronto other than law enforcement! In general, it's the rust belt and deep south and Mexican border states which skew US homicide rates; the parts which border Canada have similar homicide rates to Canada (again aside from rust best + Illinois). It's actually a bit funny - states near Canada have similar homicide rates to Canada. States near Mexico have similar homicide rates to Mexico (much lower than Mexico, but higher than some other states). States near the Caribbean have rates like the Caribbean (again much lower than the Caribbean, but again higher than other states). Not sure how the mid Atlantic states work into that analogy, haha :)
- tobyjsullivan 13y agoNot to downplay the inequalities that exist on both sides of the border, but don't underestimate the differences between the United States and Canada - especially when it comes to things like drug enforcement and the prevalence and nature of ghettos.
- janj 13y agoI've noticed many airports have HSBC plastered all over the walls. This has been amusing to me after it came out that HSBC runs the world's largest money laundering operation for drug cartels. It's surreal thinking about how TSA and customs will put away recreational drug users for life but the bank that funds the largest drug cartels operates out in the open. Our system is broken at every level.
- Wingman4l7 13y ago(For those interested in more info: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HSBC#Money_laundering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HSBC#Money_laundering) Never mind the fundamental fact that if your fine was less than the profit you gained from your illegal activity, you can just write it off as a business expense. Fines have to be punitive or they will have no effect; it's simple math.
- wozniacki 13y agoI am always in constant bewilderment at how galling some of these corporate crimes are. How does one even go about planning these? Do the chief executives [1] [2] sit with the board members and discuss the tradeoffs of turning a blind eye to some hanky-panky stuff going on in Mexico? [3] I know that they have legal counsels and all. But do they really sit down and weigh the legal ramifications and discuss who shall be thrown under the bus, if things should flare up? Whether its a Angelo Mozilo of Countrywide Financial [4] or a Maurice R. Greenberg[5] of AIG or even a Calisto Tanzi of Parmalat [6] [7]; do these people even have a good pulse of the prosecution climate of a given administration, the likelihood of getting caught and the possible fines and sentences before they choose to set these financially murky things in motion? Or are they more like hot-shot, fledgling politicians [8] who think they are invincible and can never possibly get caught, in a scandal? If anything, the public has come to be struck in awe of these people and their mettle, rather than find their actions, reprobatory. The slap on the wrist fines and sentences ( if any at all ) that major executives and their houses have received, only reaffirms the notion that one -above all other skills and qualifications - has to be a skilled manipulator of fact, circumstance and public opinion, to head a large and highly profitable enterprise, these days. After all the cake and watermelon, I am loath to admit that deviousness and calculated deceit has become sexy. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Geoghegan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Geoghegan [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stuart_Gulliver http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stuart_Gulliver [3] http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-07-16/hsbc-aided-money-laundering-by-iran-drug-cartels-probe-shows.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-07-16/hsbc-aided-money-la... [4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angelo_Mozilo http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angelo_Mozilo [5] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maurice_R._Greenberg#Legal_issues http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maurice_R._Greenberg#Legal_issu... [6]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parmalat_bankruptcy_timeline http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parmalat_bankruptcy_timeline [7] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parmalat#Financial_fraud_.282002.E2.80.932005.29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parmalat#Financial_fraud_.28200... [8] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Edwards#Indictment_and_trial http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Edwards#Indictment_and_tri... Edit: Citations
- rdtsc 13y agoNot sure what Canada's crack smoking, grandmother-shoving mayors have to do with this. I am sure African warlords do worse, and Russian mafia is in bed with their government. The story is about the US justice system.
- freehunter 13y agoWait, Canada isn't a US state?
- pandaman 13y agoA rich black guy, Eric Holder, had been found in criminal contempt of Congress (I have a vague idea what it is but it sounds more serious than grandma-showing), he is still free and keeps his job. So it takes as much for a rich white guy to go to jail as takes for a rich black guy to go to jail.
- thebooktocome 13y agoCriminal contempt of Congress carries a jail term between one and twelve months, and a fine between $100 and $1000. Suffice it to say, it isn't very serious. Holder is still free because it's unclear from a constitutional standpoint where Congress got the authority to hold anyone in contempt, let alone a member of the Executive.
- tsotha 13y agoCongress certainly has the authority: http://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/contempt_of_congress http://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/contempt_of_congress >Contempt of Congress is defined in statute, 2 U.S.C.A. § 192, enacted in 1938, which states that any person who is summoned before Congress who "willfully makes default, or who, having appeared, refuses to answer any question pertinent to the question under inquiry" shall be guilty of a misdemeanor and subject to a maximum $1,000 fine and 12 month imprisonment. Holder is free because he's the head of the agency that's supposed to prosecute these kinds of crimes. The only way forward for Congress is to impeach him, and that's not going to happen as long as the Democrats control the Senate.
- wwweston 13y ago> Contempt of Congress is defined in statute, 2 U.S.C.A. § 192, enacted in 1938 ... by Congress, presumably? If so, it seems to me there might be questions about whether Congress can give itself increased authority when it comes to compelling the executive branch. > who is summoned before Congress who "willfully makes default, or who, having appeared, refuses to answer any question pertinent to the question under inquiry" Hmm. 5th amendment?
- JonFish85 13y ago"Why should I bother trying to stay out if nothing I can do can keep me out?" Well, for starters, living by the conditions of the parole... I'm not trying to be too snarky about it, but given the choice of "fed up with a crowded house" and the chance of going back to prison for a year, the choice seems evident. The question is whether the person really cares. Stuck in a crowded apartment, maybe it was a calculated risk: I can either get away with it, or I'll go back to the big house. In the end, maybe he doesn't feel that he lost that much.
- angersock 13y ago"living by the conditions of the parole" That's well and good, but there are numerous shit luck things that can happen that might result in a technical parole violation, right?
- thenerdfiles 13y ago"My neighbor asked me to walk their dog..."
- girvo 13y agoIf only it was that simple. Life isn't, unfortunately, but parole expects it to be.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoCould you explain the relevant complexity, particularly as it applies to this example? "It isn't that simple" is an utterly vacuous assertion that, while trivially true, is not even wrong. Of course life is more complicated, something on the order of 10^30 atoms were involved! Is JonFish85 incorrect that the person in question could have chosen to abide by the terms of his parole?
- sbuk 13y agoOr you could use your imagination and empathy to try and try to understand how "It isn't that simple". Both are important engineering, design and entrepreneurial skills.
- rangibaby 13y agoI've come to a realization that rules and laws only apply to the "little people".
- squozzer 13y ago>"What does it take for a rich, white guy to have to go to jail?" Ripping off other rich white guys, e.g. Bernie Madoff.
- enraged_camel 13y ago>>How can anyone have faith in such a system with such gross inequalities? The system is working as designed and as intended. I think people need to rid themselves of this romantic notion that the government serves "the people" and cops in particular are supposed to protect the innocent. Both of them are ridiculously childish beliefs. The reality is much harsher. Adam Smith laid it out more than two centuries ago in his book Wealth of Nations: "Civil government, so far as it is instituted for the security of property, is in reality instituted for the defense of the rich against the poor, or of those who have some property against those who have none at all."
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bayesianhorse 13y agoEngineers tend to overestimate the impact of "intentions" on "systems" as big and complex as societies and economies. I doubt that the results the US is seeing were indeed foreseen and designed by anyone. And I would like to add that civil governments also protect the poor from the rich. Just look at undemocratic systems to see who needs protection from whom.
- ajslater 13y ago> Engineers tend to overestimate the impact of "intentions" on "systems" Everyone does. The comfort of the loonier conspiracy theories is that someone, somewhere, however evil, has a plan and is in control. And you can blame 'them' and their competence for your misfortune. Denying that conspiracies exist by people who do have some influence and leverage over systems is the other wrong extreme. There are plenty of good and evil intentions and plenty of conspiracies. Some of them kind of work out, rarely exactly as intended, and there's also lots of chaos.
- onetwofiveten 13y agoI think that romantic notion is just a part of childish naivety. When most people grow up they realise the government doesn't serve the public's interests. However, I don't think we should abandon the romantic notion that the government SHOULD serve the people. It's not entirely clear how to make that happen (or if it is possible), but I think along with social change, technology could help (e.g. crowdsourced political debate, security for whistleblowers, personal surveillance, etc.) So I'm all for hackers being a bit idealistic :)
- grecy 13y ago>Toronto's mayor is on video smoking crack, is drunk and disorderly in public, shoves (assaults?) a grandmother, more, and isn't even removed from office, let alone arrested. How can anyone have faith in such a system with such gross inequalities? I couldn't agree with you more. Every time I see a celebrity, or politician, or insanely rich person breaking the law it disgusts me. Not only are they not arrested and punished for their crimes as everyone else would be, but the media actually celebrates their flouting the law. I'm only 31 and I honestly think the system is too far broken. I personally believe we're heading for some massive, massive upheaval.
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoThey are the often singled out for harsh punishment, actually. See: Celebrities Lohan & Hilton & Martha Stewart, all singled out for harsher punishment than normal. Politicians Cunningham, Spitzer both given harsher punishment (or more ink) than a typical person would get. Rich people like the entire Enron board, telecom CEOs, numerous lawyers and execs you've never heard of charged with insider trading, trivial securities infractions, trivial tax infractions, and hounded.
- declan 13y agoAnd Mark Cuban. See this week's WSJ oped: http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052702303289904579196454016836522 http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142405270230328990...
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoAnd how many more rich people commit similar crimes and get away scot-free? How many poor minorities get the book thrown at them for far lesser crimes? "Getting tough" on the rich and powerful is very much the exception rather than the rule, and we play right along with it by eating up headline after headline about Martha Stewart while ignoring the thousands and thousands of people who are rightfully afraid of the police on a day-to-day basis. By the way, you mention "more ink" as if it's comparable. Being hounded by the media is certainly unpleasant, but it's not any part of the operation of the justice system, or shouldn't be.
- saraid216 13y ago> How can anyone have faith in such a system with such gross inequalities? Keep in mind that you only consider these to be travesties because you're in the 21st century. You've had the benefit of hundreds of years of philosophy and public discussion, now passed onto you as an obvious truth. That would seem like a perfectly sensible inequality to someone three hundred years ago, who wouldn't. It would also seem like a perfectly sensible inequality to a lot of people today. These are the same people who will back tough-on-crime bills and political platforms. Not politicians, who are taking up their vote. Find these people. Talk to them. Figure out how to convince them. Show them the human faces and human stories. Explain the systemic problems that are causing this. Bring them over. Break the support for these policies.
- likeclockwork 13y ago> That would seem like a perfectly sensible inequality to someone three hundred years ago, who wouldn't. That would depend on which side of the inequality they were on, would it not?
- geoka9 13y agoThey are more likely to be on the "wrong" end. However, for many such people it's the lack of imagination that defines their opinions; they just can't imagine themselves on the short end of the stick. It's like arguing with Stalin apologists which are now abundant in Russia. "OK, many innocent people were prosecuted. But we can forgive him for that, because he made us a superpower!" - that's how their logic usually goes. When you ask them what if they were among those wrongly prosecuted - would that change their opinion - they are usually genuinely incredulous: "Why would they come for me?"
- saraid216 13y agoIt's partly that. It's also worth noting how many ways you can be on the wrong end. "I'm not black," is a legitimate form of reasoning on how you wouldn't be hurt by American slavery, but that doesn't actually express how you're still on the short end of the stick because it turns out you're Chinese or Irish.
- RyanMcGreal 13y ago> isn't even removed from office Canadian here. I know this isn't the point of your post but I feel obliged to make excuses for the fact that Toronto's mayor has not been removed from office. The reason Toronto City Council and the Ontario Provincial Government don't have the power to do this is that under the parliamentary traditions on which the Canadian political system is based, it is inconceivable that a politician could behave in so utterly disgraceful a manner and not have the basic human decency and shame to resign on his own volition. Also, for what it's worth, Canada's record of judicial fairness with respect to race is not much better than America's, and our Conservative Federal Government has adopted an American-style tough-on-crime stance that has embraced mandatory minimum sentences and so on - some of which has already been declared unconstitutional. http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/minimum-gun-sentence-ruled-unconstitutional-1.2423693 http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/minimum-gun-sentence-ruled-unc...
- rayiner 13y ago> This passage described a poor black man in Philadelphia -- the tip of the iceberg It's not the tip of the iceberg, it's the base of the pyramid.
- rayiner 13y ago> This passage described a poor black man in Philadelphia -- the tip of the iceberg It's not the tip of the iceberg, it's the base of the pyramid.
- xacaxulu 13y agoAlice Goffman might be one of the bravest women of our generation. She's a true revolutionary.
- chris_mahan 13y agoI've put her book in my amazon shopping basket. Will pick it up when available.
- jboynyc 13y agoIn the meantime you can read her ASR article, which someone was kind enough to make available here: http://www.soc.umn.edu/~uggen/Goffman_ASR_09.pdf http://www.soc.umn.edu/~uggen/Goffman_ASR_09.pdf
- tga_d 13y agoI'm sorry, but that is ridiculous. Don't get me wrong, she was very brave for wilfully going into that sort of an environment, and a very intelligent person. But remember that there are thousands who live in a similar manner in just that city alone - people who have been living in these environments for their entire lives, and who come to much of the same conclusions that she has, only without academic language or a parent's name. After a run-in with law enforcement that left me with a bitter taste (I was arrested for a crime I wasn't guilty of), and seeing first hand many of the horrors of the justice system I had only heard or read about, I asked a friend of mine who had spent a decent amount of time in jail what he thought the justice system believed it doing for him by sentencing him. He responded that jail time was never about changing the people inside, it was about how everyone else felt outside. This is arguably the entire premise of Goffman's work: the police crack down on frankly minor charges in predominantly black areas has nothing to do with actual safety or reform for those individuals. "But after braving violence and intimidation to get this story, Goffman now faces a different challenge. How can she keep the focus on black poverty, and not her own biography?" Indeed. No, Alice Goffman is neither the "one of the bravest women of our generation" nor a "revolutionary," she's an academic who is well-off enough to get in the paper and sell books. Who knows, maybe her book could be the "Silent Spring" of the prison-industrial complex, but don't deify her like that - it belittles the people who actually do get coerced, imprisoned, and killed for living their lives.
- wrongc0ntinent 13y agoThis is a pretty misleading title. As to its actual subject, best of luck with the book. edit: Just pointing out the clickbait aspect. It's hyperbole, not the technical usage.
- l33tbro 13y agoBad conversion strategy for the publisher. I was on Amazon ready to buy. Maybe don't publicize this until it's available to the public (book comes out in April next year)
- thenerdfiles 13y agoRight. Okay, Upstartuppers, let's play Reconstruction of the Bottom Line. > Men like him lived a paradox. The penal system was supposed to shape them up. But its tentacles had become so invasive that the opposite happened. Goffman argues that the system encourages young men to act shady—"I got to move like a shadow," one of Mike's friends told her—because a stable public routine could land them back behind bars. If an African American man walked into your startup, given some negligible* felony history and a "shady look", but showed you an SPA he built in prison, how would the "culture fit" measure factor in your decision procedure to hire him? *: And [if] you do hire him, do you poke and prod for social metadata until you discover this feature of his personality?
- anonyHN 13y agoI like how you try to tie this into startups (hackernewserizing the thread as it were) Kudos!
- thenerdfiles 13y ago"Did a murderer and a sex offender just save Oklahoma $20 million?" (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6664588 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6664588) Let's connect the dots. (The obvious follow-up is: Are these men African American?) ((Obligatory response: Point still stands. Change all the variables. Make them androids with upgraded and legally "blessed" virtual mental cores for all I care.))
- rdtsc 13y agoActually, I think it was an interesting observation. It is a relevant example to illustrate a point. Say, if he was talking in a car mechanics's forum, he would have have used body shop instead of start-up. The interesting thing is the personal dissonance between ideal principles and concrete experience. Pretty sure most here fancy themselves as not being racists. Going out at night and seeing a group of black young men start crossing the street and heading towards you, would you be scared? Would you be less scared if they were white and wearing argyle sweaters instead of black hoodies and baggy pants? Thinking about it, yeah I would be afraid. Rationally I know I am not a racist but in that case, I can see myself running as fast as I could. Back to a black person walking into the start-up. Well that is kind of interesting, because of the way it is presented. Walking in? Almost sounds like he "breaks" in? How often do you hire people that just "walk in" to your startup off the street. The hypothetical example is already biased and infused with stereotypes the way I see it. Did we already do a phone Skype interview and passed? Hey he might have a good chance. I also don't see "felonies" as being a clear cut yes or no differentiate. I can see looking more into what those felonies were and balancing it against other aspects.
- eof 13y agoIn 2003 I was pulled over for not wearing a seatbelt; I was in Saratoga NY; I had just moved out of my apartment.. having gone to school in Troy, NY and I was working as a "quality assurance analyist" looking for bugs in some lotus software. My license plates were from TX because I never registered in NY; I probably was supposed to, I just never did. The cop pulled me over and was immediately convinced I was running drugs from Canada to TX. I had been across the border somewhat recenctly, maybe he could see that(?). I had no previous convictions other than a speeding ticket. My car was dirty and filled with crap; but I was pretty clean cut and just came out of an office job like 3 minutes earlier. I did in fact have a couple pipes and a couple grams of mid grade bud; and I was dumb and didn't insist on my rights and essentially "let" him search my car. I made my mistake when he found the little jar and I got cocky; as NY had recently decriminalized.. so I just told him to give me the ticket and leave me alone. He promptly arrested me for "driving while ability impaired"; impounded my car, nicked my license, I spent the night in jail, was humiliated, I still can't go back to Canada; I had been detained for 3 hours by the time I was given a 'sobriety' test; I was literally in the police station by then.. reflecting on it, it was clear I was being fucked with; walking a line with my arms spread out, bent ninety degrees at the waist, told to turn around without lifting my feet. I hired the only lawyer I could afford, who basically did nothing but show up for me; paid him 500 bucks and about that in fines; but it has haunted me ever since.. and I was literally 100% sober in every way. I have never trusted cops since then as a whole; though I have personally come to know a couple that have eased my deep hatred somewhat. My story here I know isn't directly related to the article; but it was an extreme abuse of power by a cop exerting his authority over what was genuinely a punk-kid; and I just wasn't in a position to do anything about it, both financially and because I didn't know then what I know now.
- rdtsc 13y ago> I have personally come to know a couple that have eased my deep hatred somewhat. I have quite the opposite experience if you wish. I was never personally abused or treated unfairly by the cops during a stop. But, I still distrust cops. If anything because of the ones I met in an informal settings. In my extended family and network of acquaintances there are 3 cops. And 2 of them physically abuse their wives and kids, are very brutal and scary. In fact if I didn't know they are cops they could just as well fit the profile of street thugs.
- pstuart 13y agoAnd a keystone of this madness is the War on Drugs. End it, and the police will have a lot less to do...
- trimbo 13y agoI'm almost scared of what happens when we have so many bored police and unclear laws in this country.
- nyrina 13y agoDoesn't matter much, it will only take about a year before everyone is arrested and put into jail. The jails will become the new America
- Amadou 13y agoEven if the War on Drugs was cancelled today, we'd still be dealing with the criminal effects for decades. When prohibition was repealed, all the criminals who had been bootlegging didn't decide to start living straight lives, they switched to other criminal enterprises. Prohibition was a big part of how the mafia got a foothold in the US. Its even plausible that massive decriminalization would lead to more work for the police. I'd like to think it would be more productive work though, instead of just hassling easy targets like so many do now.
- pstuart 13y agoYeah, the criminals will become bankers.
- mortyseinfeld 13y agoYeah, this is what happens when people defer to government authority as a consequence of looking to government to solve all their problems. This leftist shift will only make the situation worse.
- enraged_camel 13y agoHilarious. Would you rather leave this to capitalist corporations or the free market? I mean, maybe we should just have lots of Blackwaters running around performing "protection" services for the highest bidder.
- aric 13y ago> "capitalist corporations" "Capitalist corporations" are the direct result of corporate states serving corporate law. The irony in your comment is strong. Blackwater and its derivations became powerful specifically because of [the many] having their labor (e.g. taxation) and choice (e.g. systemic control) forcefully deferred to [the few] of the state (in its singular, arbitrary version of existence). The rest of the US military is already nearly wholly dependent on so-called private interests. Realistically, there is no difference between private and public entities on this same platform. Either an entity is accountable to such oligarchical 'control' or it is not. > Free market Like most terms that become distorted and perverted through political propaganda, a "free market" can have wildly different meanings. You may find that you support a freer market. A free market as some people define it is one in which groups of trade (businesses) are less powerful because "corporations" would not exist in law. People would exist. Business would exist. Legal buffers from responsibility of actions would not exist. Those buffers currently afford the largest corporations of today the luxury of exploiting people and land through the use of government -- not only protecting directors from their violent actions but also increasing the platform where police/military force serves their corporate law. In a free market where abstract entities are not state-protected, all actions fall under the same domain of scrutiny. Frameworks of law as far as business is concerned would be relegated to protecting people from direct contractual fraud or abuse, only to the extent financial or physical damage is actually taking place. Therefore, egregious economic fines and prison sentences for non-violent actions that disobey corporate law would be a token of more brutal eras. Systems of this sort are often paired with models that give people, the public, more direct control over the flow of their own labor/money, thereby making it harder for abusive or surreptitious entities (e.g. every war/surveillance company) to gain vast power through the current top-heavy, centralized money pools of a government's taxation. A transition to more human freedom such as this isn't possible overnight; but it is worth aspiring to in the evolution of governmental systems. That's humanist. Other people define a "free market" as a system in which corporations are still greatly protected yet even less susceptible to recourse by people. That's problematic.
- tsotha 13y agoI can't help wondering what the black women in the neighborhood thought of Miss Goffman.
- squozzer 13y agoIt's quite possible the purpose of the criminal justice system is to remove the young male (and dare I say black?) population from the breeding cycle. Is that a falsifiable hypothesis?
- anoncowherd 13y agoWell, they do breed just fine even in the current system.
- rurounijones 13y agoKind of ironic that the article talks about how she is annoyed that the story is focusing on her. At which point the article basically starts focusing on her.
- austinl 13y agoOn a similar topic, I would highly recommend the book The Birth of the Prison by Michel Foucault. http://www.amazon.com/Discipline-Punish-The-Birth-Prison/dp/0679752552 http://www.amazon.com/Discipline-Punish-The-Birth-Prison/dp/...
- sologoub 13y ago>"In modern history," Goffman writes, "only the forced labor camps of the former U.S.S.R. under Stalin approached these levels of penal confinement." That's actually a pretty offensive comparison. Stalin's regime resulted in an untold number of completely innocent people being worked to death. There was no due process, no hope of any humane treatment. Just terror and dumb luck that kept people from being picked out of a crowd. Maybe my views are biased by growing up in Russia, but such rhetoric seems to use horrors of the past to advance a particular agenda, that has little to do with the horrors themselves. It also denies the respect and dignity to those innocents that died. The very introduction admits that there were drugs and guns in the apartment, so crimes happened and unfortunately, people are being prosecuted with somewhat questionable methods. But how is this the same as NKVD coming for you in the middle of the night and you are never heard of again?
- declan 13y ago>"There was no due process" If you have an unjust law on the books, you can have all the due process you want while being arrested, tried, convicted, sentenced, and jailed, and that doesn't help you one whit.
- loxs 13y agoActually, that was exactly the case in the Eastern Block. All those laws for "crimes against the state" were on the book. Most of the GULAG prisoners were in fact jailed after a "due process". And I think it's the same now with the US. Tons of laws that you can never be sure you are not breaking. Tons of laws that everyone is breaking (copyright law, anyone?) etc. Every empire will collapse eventually. Under its own weight.
- sologoub 13y agoThe laws were on the book, but the due process, as understood in the western societies, includes the presumption of innocence and proof of the crime. For most victims of the GULAG, the charges were false, confessions obtained with force, and witness testimony made up. Essentially, if I don't like somebody, I just make an anonymous report to NKVD, and 99% chance is that they'll disappear. That doesn't sound like the due process we all know in the US...
- groupthinker 13y agoThis submission is not "Hacker News".
- bananacurve 13y agoIt is how HN is now. It is not up voted because because they want America to improve, it is upvoted because they want to pretend America is failing. I can sort of understand the attitude as Europe should really have more power in the world but don't for reasons that are unclear.
- Amadou 13y agoYet Alex vehemently resisted being taken to the hospital. Police crowd the emergency room, running the names of young black men through their database Seems to me that the hospitals that let this happen in their ERs have forgotten their mission -- to heal people. They may have come up with some rationalization that says it is not a technical violation of doctor-patient confidentiality, but it sure as shit is a violation of the intent of that precept which is if you can't trust your doctor you won't get medical treatment. As a comparison, after the PATRIOT Act was passed librarian associations stood up to the surveillance state by starting to redesign their computerized lending systems to be resistant to national-security-letter searches. Instead of keeping a lending history, as soon as a book is returned all records of it being borrowed are purged. That privacy is important for exactly the same reason, a borrowing history can be very revealing - medical books, law books, financial books, they can reveal quite a bit of personal information and if people feel like they are being watched, they simply won't borrow the books they need. You'd think doctors would stand up for their patients at least as much as librarians. http://www.ila.org/advocacy-files/pdf/Confidentiality_Best_Practices.pdf http://www.ila.org/advocacy-files/pdf/Confidentiality_Best_P...
- Grue3 13y agoDid I accidentally stumble onto /r/politics on reddit or what? A bunch of first worlders complaining about "police state" in their first world country. Give me a break.
- st0neage 13y ago> "What her research shows is that these institutions may be self-defeating and may carry very significant social costs," Western says. "And so the whole effort to improve public safety through criminal-justice supervision and through incarceration may have significantly backfired, and may in many ways have contributed to the ongoing poverty and shortage of opportunities that we see there. That's a fairly new story." Everybody with half a brain has known this forever.
- FedRegister 13y agoSo what do we do? It's all good and well that we've made this observation, but what do we do about it?
- tootie 13y agoNot to make light of this serious subject, but this isn't what a Police State is. A Police State refers to use of the police for political ends. Like arresting dissidents or placing armed guards next to voting booths. It does not refer to overly aggressive enforcement and certainly not to the enforcement of laws some people don't like. Drug prohibition was a response to public outcry and we live in a democracy.
- tehwalrus 13y agoIt is argued in one of the comments (on the link) that this is a response to the civil rights movement of the '60s - if you can't legally exclude the Minority Ethnic community from voting, lock them all up instead. I'm not saying that's a true analysis, but it's certainly one way to make this story seriously political. Even if you just make it about stopping poor people voting, instead of some other subdivision, it's still leaks out of the "law and order" debate.
- tootie 13y agoThat's a roundabout argument and I don't think you can prove any criminal intent about that. Unless you can prove that the political process encourages the targeting of minorities, then it's just an enforcement issue. And not every state will ban you from voting for a non-violent offense.
- tehwalrus 13y agoIt doesn't have to be "criminal" on the part of the law makers/enforcers to be a political issue - your bar is too high there. cf "institutionally racist"[1]. On the point of who bans you from voting, I think that's hardly the point - the types of crimes that are common in these communities are felonies. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institutional_racism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institutional_racism
- john103141 13y agoI hold a degree in Sociology but I lack the teary eyed outlook on life which seems a requirement if one if going to make a name for themselves in the field of Sociology in this era. For that reason I also earned a degree in engineering and opted for a steady income instead. But, like so many other sociology majors, I read nearly everything Erving Goffman ever published. For a time I was a nearly complete fanatic of his work and style. Unfortunately, Alice Goffman's writing lacks the depth of her father's studies; indeed American Police State is just another Martinique Hotel handwringer complete with all the hopelessnes and despair as the subtext. Why can't sociology majors ever concentrate on the individuals who grow up in ghettos and get on with life? Surely they must represent the majority. I believe that as long as sociologists continue to write in the Martinique Hotel manner an undue number of tears will be shed without any real work being done. In physics such a machine would be one-hundred percent entropic, i.e. fuel in, nothing out. Or, in the case of Alice Goffman's piece, tears in, nothing out. It is time for a new generation of sociology majors to concentrate on the winners and do research on them to see what makes them different, i.e. such as making the right decisions before acting. Pitiless in Seattle
- john103141 13y agoI hold a degree in Sociology but I lack the teary eyed outlook on life which seems a requirement if one if going to make a name for themselves in the field of Sociology in this era. For that reason I also earned a degree in engineering and opted for a steady income instead. But, like so many other sociology majors, I read nearly everything Erving Goffman ever published. For a time I was a nearly complete fanatic of his work and style. Unfortunately, Alice Goffman's writing lacks the depth of her father's studies; indeed American Police State is just another Martinique Hotel handwringer complete with all the hopelessnes and despair as the subtext. Why can't sociology majors ever concentrate on the individuals who grow up in ghettos and get on with life? Surely they must represent the majority. I believe that as long as sociologists continue to write in the Martinique Hotel manner an undue number of tears will be shed without any real work being done. In physics such a machine would be one-hundred percent entropic, i.e. fuel in, nothing out. Or, in the case of Alice Goffman's piece, tears in, nothing out. It is time for a new generation of sociology majors to concentrate on the winners and do research on them to see what makes them different, i.e. such as making the right decisions before acting. Pitiless in Seattle
- john103141 13y agoI hold a degree in Sociology but I lack the teary eyed outlook on life which seems a requirement if one if going to make a name for themselves in the field of Sociology in this era. For that reason I also earned a degree in engineering and opted for a steady income instead. But, like so many other sociology majors, I read nearly everything Erving Goffman ever published. For a time I was a nearly complete fanatic of his work and style. Unfortunately, Alice Goffman's writing lacks the depth of her father's studies; indeed American Police State is just another Martinique Hotel handwringer complete with all the hopelessnes and despair as the subtext. Why can't sociology majors ever concentrate on the individuals who grow up in ghettos and get on with life? Surely they must represent the majority. I believe that as long as sociologists continue to write in the Martinique Hotel manner an undue number of tears will be shed without any real work being done. In physics such a machine would be one-hundred percent entropic, i.e. fuel in, nothing out. Or, in the case of Alice Goffman's piece, tears in, nothing out. It is time for a new generation of sociology majors to concentrate on the winners and do research on them to see what makes them different, i.e. such as making the right decisions before acting. Pitiless in Seattle