6 ms·
One look at the average TV remote tells you enough about TV manufacturers and their ability to do any kind of UI design. Remotes like this: http://wardiesworld
by Pxtl 13y ago
One look at the average TV remote tells you enough about TV manufacturers and their ability to do any kind of UI design.
Remotes like this:
http://wardiesworld.files.wordpress.com/2012/11/raspi_samsung_remote_actual.jpg http://wardiesworld.files.wordpress.com/2012/11/raspi_samsun...
always remind me of this:
http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2006/11/this-is-what-happens-when-you-let-developers-create-ui.html http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2006/11/this-is-what-happen...
- mikeryan 13y agoRemotes are incredibly hard to design. My company builds Smart TV Apps we have just about every remote imaginable and that Samsung one you chose "just works" its like the Nokia 3310 of remotes. You can pick it up and use it without thinking about it. Show me a remote that works better then that one and I can probably tell you why it sucks.
- deletes 13y agoApple remote comes to mind: http://support.apple.com/kb/ht3176 http://support.apple.com/kb/ht3176 I would like to hear you opinion.
- mikeryan 13y agoThe Apple Remote is solid similar to the Samsung but with out all the keys. Roku's first remote was very similar but had the same problem - no back button. If you're going to do interactive apps on your TV you need a back button and an exit or "home" button - they're two different things. The Apple remote assumes very limited input almost zero text input so no numbers or extraneous keys like the color keys. My favorite remote close to the apple one was the Boxee 1 remote (it too needs an explicit back button). But the slim, pared down front side design with the full keyboard on the back was very slick and usable. http://old-blog.boxee.tv/wp-content/uploads/2010/01/Boxee-Box-remote-1024x662.jpg http://old-blog.boxee.tv/wp-content/uploads/2010/01/Boxee-Bo...
- mjbraun 13y agoThat's interesting: the remote was one of the two reasons I ditched my Boxee (the second being that the UI was painful). Initially, the keyboard was a major selling point for me over my AppleTV remote but grey text on black rubber buttons? No backlight? Trying to use the keyboard functionality of the remote in anything other than full lighting was an exercise in futility. To be fair: UI (virtual and physical) is hard. Thus far, the AppleTV is my favorite but it's a "lesser of two evils" scenario.
- Pxtl 13y agoI like this one: http://shop.lenovo.com/SEUILibrary/controller/e/web/LenovoPortal/en_US/catalog.workflow:item.detail?hide_menu_area=true&GroupID=460&Code=57Y6678 http://shop.lenovo.com/SEUILibrary/controller/e/web/LenovoPo... It's purely meant as a mouse-and-keyboard thing, and in that vein it has some failures (the mouse-buttons are face-buttons instead of console-style triggers, and the keyboard lacks a way to use the F function keys)... but in general? I used its predecessor (the N9501 instead of N9502) and found the design lovely. I could navigate my set-top PC easily with the trackball and mouse buttons, and when I needed to do text-entry I could hold it like a thumb keyboard. I even got pretty far in Cipher Prime's Auditorium with the trackball - it was quite pleasant for low-stress mouse-only games (as long as they only need click, not drag). The problem with my old version was that the trackball was not user-servicable (trackballs get dirty, fast) and it wasn't backlit. The new one uses a touchpad and has backlighting.
- mjbraun 13y agoI bought the predecessor as well and you're absolutely right: the design is lovely. While I'd say it's more of a full-featured HID than a remote it's well designed and comfortable to use. I didn't know about the new one and I'll keep an eye out for it. A problem I see is that the tasks of set-top-boxes and displays are relatively constrained, so having a reduced input device seems like a good idea. But how to support free-text searching without a full keyboard (on-screen menus are painful) or having to deal with limited battery life due to a touchscreen?
- 13y ago
- carlosedp 13y agoThe Apple remote is exactly the remote that came to my mind when I think simplicity. That's what most people use. up, down, left, right, center(for enter/go/confirm) and a menu (for options, back). Thats 99% of a remote usage, the rest is handled by any GUI.
- deletes 13y agoThat was my though too. But to do that you have to control both software and hardware which Apple can.
- Pxtl 13y agoAs does every other TV and player manufacturer. We're not talking about PCs here, or 3rd-party remote manufacturers. We're talking about Sony, Samsung, and LG and the baked-in TV software. They control the screen, the software, and the controller, same as Apple. They're just not as good at it as Apple. I don't like Apple - I don't like the horrifying complete lock-in of hardware/software/media. But I admit something: Apple wins because they're the best. Period.
- carlosedp 13y agoActually that's not necessary. I have XBMC installed into an old Macbook that uses the Apple Remote perfectly. Their usage fits into A.R. layout and buttons.
- vidarh 13y agoExcept when you have nearly 100+ channels, and remember the 3 digit code for most of the ones you care about - then you want a numeric keypad rather than fiddling around moving up and down in a menu. I'd never want to be stuck with just an Apple remote.
- mortenjorck 13y agoLayers upon layers of broken systems built upon broken systems. You only have a few channels you like, and should be able to simply switch between them with a D-pad. But the cable industry's broken business model requires you to subscribe to an order of magnitude more than you want. Clunky set-top box UIs have you constantly paging up and down massive lists. A "favorites" system is nestled deep within some unintuitive menu, and never displays anyway when you go to the channel guide, always requiring more button presses followed by high-latency screen redraws. And thus, you're stuck dialing in a numeric code like it's 1968. I'm sure you'd be ecstatic to be stuck with an Apple remote, if only the entire rest of the TV experience were up to speed with it.
- Pxtl 13y agoThat was my first-cut search and so it's certainly not the worst example, but in software if I put buttons like "T.Link" and "DMA" and 4 unlabeled colored buttons right on the main home-screen of a consumer-oriented UI I'd be laughed out of the room. Buttons like that are an artifact of the days when TVs didn't have on-screen UIs. The remote should not be designed for the 1% of users that fiddle with such things. Do heatmaps and find out which buttons are actually used frequently give those big clear buttons with unabbreviated labels, and move everything else into the menus. And the menus themselves - you have a whole screenful of space, you can actually describe to the user what each option does in helpful detail.
- barnabee 13y agoThe LG Magic Remote is by far the best remote I have ever used, particularly for "smart" content, browsing, using apps such as NetFlix, etc. It's almost as natural and simple as using a mouse and hands down beats other TV type input methods I've seen (game controllers, Apple remote, etc.). Shame LG seem intent on ruining it with the spying, I hope they have a change of approach and resolve this.
- prawn 13y agoI had that Samsung remote and then upgraded to a newer model as the previous Samsung glass TV base literally exploded. And amusingly, the newer remote is far worse than the one you've used as an example. I wish I could revert!
- bgruber 13y agohave you seen the 2013 samsung remote? http://www2.crutchfield.com.edgesuite.net/pix.crutchfield.com/ImageHandler/fixedscale/400/300/products/2013/17/305/x30565F8000-R.jpg http://www2.crutchfield.com.edgesuite.net/pix.crutchfield.co... It's like the remote designer's revenge. "Too many buttons? I'll show you what it's like to not have buttons!" This remote literally has a button on it that brings up an on-screen picture of a remote that you use by swiping around on the trackpad, so you can get at the buttons your remote is missing.
- Pxtl 13y agoAhh, Samsung. Always masters at figuring out how to do the right thing completely wrong. Holy crap that's ugly.
- WalterBright 13y agoOne interesting thing about UI design - it all seems so obvious. But a guy who designed airplane cockpits told me that those "obvious" aspects were all paid for in blood. They're obvious only in hindsight.
- lelandbatey 13y agoI'm a little surprised that these are all held up as "bad examples". For example, I looked at the picture of the Windows `wget` gui and thought "that doesn't look that bad." Sure there's a lot of dense information, but things are pretty well explained and it's pretty clear how it works. It is ugly, but it's also totally functional. I guess ultimately, I really don't care how ugly something is if it's at least consistent and informative. However, I know I'm an outlier in this.
- Pxtl 13y agoImagine it wasn't wget, but a tool you'd never used before and you didn't know what the arguments meant. All those options are poorly defined. Also, it's confusing how filetypes switch from checkboxes to a listbox. Trying to cram everything into one panel has left us with nothing but the controls and very little space for information. Also, even if you wanted that layout, the alignments are terrible and the use of frames is arbitrary and inconsistent.
- lelandbatey 13y agoIf I were in that situation, and I find I often am, my choice is to go and read the manual. I think this comes from years of reading man pages for command line tools, but the first step I feel should always be to read the instructions.
- Angostura 13y agoYou are not the target user for GUIs.