3 ms·
Yes that could possibly have a slight impact on the economy, but as I said, from an individual perspective increasing value is definitely a good thing.
by Houshalter 13y ago
Yes that could possibly have a slight impact on the economy, but as I said, from an individual perspective increasing value is definitely a good thing.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Yes that could possibly have a slight impact on the economy In the same wall that a concrete wall across a freeway could have a slight impact on traffic. > from an individual perspective increasing value is definitely a good thing. From an individual perspective, its only "definitely a good thing" if you ignore all of the effects of everyone else using it except the effect of providing you the opportunity to use it and actually causing the increase in value.
- Houshalter 13y ago>>Yes that could possibly have a slight impact on the economy >In the same wall that a concrete wall across a freeway could have a slight impact on traffic. Well you'd have to have a significant percent of people invest in bitcoin instead of investing in something else. And even then I'm not certain how much an effect it would have as speculating on commodities is very common already and a necessary part of the economy. Also it's impossible to avoid if the supply of currency isn't finite. If so then whoever is increasing the supply is also going to significantly affect the economy. Like a tax from everyone that has money to the government or banks or gold miners or whoever. And from an individual perspective, having slightly more money in your pocket or bank account everyday is definitely a good thing.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Well you'd have to have a significant percent of people invest in bitcoin instead of investing in something else. Right. Bitcoin is mostly harmless so long as its not a significant currency. > And even then I'm not certain how much an effect it would have as speculating on commodities is very common already and a necessary part of the economy. Speculation on commodities that are outputs of production/extraction provides a useful function in terms of signal for resource allocation in a market economy. > And from an individual perspective, having slightly more money in your pocket or bank account everyday is definitely a good thing. If you have a net positive position in a currency, sure; if you're a debtor, having the value of the currency in which your debt is denominated being slightly more valuable each day is definitely a bad thing. Deflationary currency basically serves as an continuous upward transfer of wealth.
- Houshalter 13y ago>If you have a net positive position in a currency, sure; if you're a debtor, having the value of the currency in which your debt is denominated being slightly more valuable each day is definitely a bad thing. Deflationary currency basically serves as an continuous upward transfer of wealth. Interest rates would go down to match the deflation rate for that reason, or people could always make contracts that adjust for deflation. Besides bitcoin is meant for trading over the internet which until now has been an extreme pain. Loans and contracts will continue to be made in their nations currency for the most part, even if it does become widely adopted. (The benefit of competing currencies.) Also many people argue the same thing about printing money to cause inflation being a continuous upward transfer of wealth. >Speculation on commodities that are outputs of production/extraction provides a useful function in terms of signal for resource allocation in a market economy. It's more than that. Even for purely finite resources, someone buying a bunch of it up because they predict the price will go up, helps stabilize the price. They conserve the resource in the present for future buyers who value it more/are willing to pay more for it. And the speculator benefits of course. The opportunity cost is that they could have invested in another resource/investment instead of that one. Instead someone with a lower time preference will buy that resource (ie someone who values using it in the short term more than the long term.) But is that objectively a bad thing? In this scenario the people with higher time preferences are better off because they make more profit off their investments. The people with lower interest rates are better off because all other resources become cheaper. Is anyone actually worse off?
- rsynnott 13y ago> Interest rates would go down to match the deflation rate for that reason Huh? Why? Look at it from the bank's perspective. Lending money would be more costly for them than it would be in a normal mildly inflationary economy, so they'd _further reduce_ their profit on lending money? In a transition to a deflationary economy, banks would likely have to raise consumer rates just to stay in the black. > Also many people argue the same thing about printing money to cause inflation being a continuous upward transfer of wealth. Do they? Who?
- dragonwriter 13y ago
- rsynnott 13y ago> If so then whoever is increasing the supply is also going to significantly affect the economy Of course. This allows _control_. For instance, the UK currently has a rate of inflation that's a bit higher than optimum, and there are methods for the BoE to influence that downwards. The Eurozone has an uncomfortably low rate of inflation, and it's likely that there'll be intervention there (there has already been some in the recent surprise rate cut). In a system where nobody controls the money supply (or in, say, Milton Friedman's automatic money printing system), if severe deflation or inflation threatens, there is very little that the authorities can do. This seems like a bad thing. > And from an individual perspective, having slightly more money in your pocket or bank account everyday is definitely a good thing. But that wouldn't actually happen for most people. Normal people would be paid less, and might lose their jobs as lack of investment and credit hit industry. Rich people would make less as their holdings in companies and so on performed worse (your modern rich person typically doesn't just have a big stack of money in the living room; it's mostly in use). It's hard to see who would actually benefit.