3 ms·
With fractional reserve banking, it's not that the bank has to keep 1% of the money they have on deposit, it's that the bank gets to invent 1000% of the money i
by moron4hire 13y ago
With fractional reserve banking, it's not that the bank has to keep 1% of the money they have on deposit, it's that the bank gets to invent 1000% of the money it has on deposit. And it doesn't have to borrow money from the Fed in order to do it, it gets to make up the money on its own. Steps 2 and 4 should read $10 and Step 3 doesn't exist.
And step 4 should really read "Bank A marks Customer B as having $10". The vast majority of the money in our economy is numbers on ledger sheets. From there, Customer B uses it to pay off a debt of some kind with Customer C, who then pays Customer D, etc., until supposedly the money eventually gets back to Customer B in some way. Except Customer C deposited the money in Bank B, so Bank B can now lend out $100 to Customer E.
That's why pyramid schemes are illegal, the banks hate competition.
So yes, it especially doesn't work for bitcoins, because how do you make a blockchain for fractional bitcoins based on a mined bitcoin? The mined bitcoin is the one that has the blockchain. You can't make a bitcoin transaction without first checking the blockchain for double-spending, say nothing about 10x spending.
- AnIrishDuck 13y ago> With fractional reserve banking, it's not that the bank has to keep 1% of the money they have on deposit, it's that the bank gets to invent 1000% of the money it has on deposit. And it doesn't have to borrow money from the Fed in order to do it, it gets to make up the money on its own. Steps 2 and 4 should read $10 and Step 3 doesn't exist. I haven't studied this subject in some time, so can't remember the exact mechanics. This summary sounds accurate. I would like to say that "it gets to make up the money on its own", while correct from one perspective, is another way of saying "other banks can respect its credit (how much money it says it has) if it plays by a certain set of rules". I don't remember if this mechanically occurs via some kind of direct lending or via the Fed sanctioning "Bank A's" credit as satisfying reserve requirements for a "Bank B". The ultimate result is the same. > That's why pyramid schemes are illegal, the banks hate competition. I'm assuming that this is said tongue-in-cheek, but pyramid schemes are an example of perversion of credit and lending on a scale that separates them from banks. In particular, the core feature of pyramid schemes is a rate of return that is unsustainable, and thus requires rapid creation of new customers instead of gradual growth of new wealth. If fractional reserve banking is indeed really terrible, what is the alternative? I think a massive body of research is required for someone to assert the superiority of such a system. > So yes, it especially doesn't work for bitcoins, because how do you make a blockchain for fractional bitcoins based on a mined bitcoin? The mined bitcoin is the one that has the blockchain. You can't make a bitcoin transaction without first checking the blockchain for double-spending, say nothing about 10x spending. This was ultimately my point. The principles behind fractional reserve banking and bitcoin seem fundamentally incompatible. Given that fractional reserve banking has worked for many centuries, any alternatives that are radically different should be approached with caution.
- nhaehnle 13y agoWhat matters in the banking system are capital requirements. The amount of money a bank can lend out is a multiple of the bank's capital, because when a loan defaults, the corresponding amount is subtracted from the bank's capital, i.e. from the net value of the bank (assets minus non-capital liabilities). We as society want to limit the amount of loans that a bank can make to such an extent that its bank capital won't go negative. Because if bank capital were to go negative, the bank would be in default and would effectively have given money out "for free". And banks are limited exactly in this way: Loans are limited in terms of the amount of capital that banks owe their owners. You may argue that the capital requirements are too low (and they are...), but qualitatively, the system makes sense. It actually makes much more sense than this foggy picture of reserve banking that most people have in their heads.
- SkyMarshal 13y agoThat's not how fractional reserve banking works. An individual bank cannot just "invent 1000% of the money it has on deposit," but the banking system as a whole can create a multiple of the total amount of money on deposit. No need to try to explain when Wikipedia provides a clear explanation and a table showing how this works and how the Money Multiplier effect is calculated from the Required Reserve Ratio: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional_reserve_banking#Example_of_deposit_multiplication http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional_reserve_banking#Exam...