4 ms·
Er, Gold was a currency for a few thousand years. Deflation is a good thing in a currency since it increases it's value when you aren't spending it. I've heard
by Houshalter 13y ago
Er, Gold was a currency for a few thousand years. Deflation is a good thing in a currency since it increases it's value when you aren't spending it. I've heard some argue that that might be bad for the economy at a large enough scale, but at an individual level that is certainly a positive.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Deflation is a good thing in a currency since it increases it's value when you aren't spending it. Its a good thing in a store of value and a bad thing in a medium of exchange. Modern currency mostly tries to optimize for the medium of exchange use case, which encourages investment in other things -- like businesses, land, etc. -- for store of value of purposes.
- Houshalter 13y agoYes that could possibly have a slight impact on the economy, but as I said, from an individual perspective increasing value is definitely a good thing.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Yes that could possibly have a slight impact on the economy In the same wall that a concrete wall across a freeway could have a slight impact on traffic. > from an individual perspective increasing value is definitely a good thing. From an individual perspective, its only "definitely a good thing" if you ignore all of the effects of everyone else using it except the effect of providing you the opportunity to use it and actually causing the increase in value.
- Houshalter 13y ago>>Yes that could possibly have a slight impact on the economy >In the same wall that a concrete wall across a freeway could have a slight impact on traffic. Well you'd have to have a significant percent of people invest in bitcoin instead of investing in something else. And even then I'm not certain how much an effect it would have as speculating on commodities is very common already and a necessary part of the economy. Also it's impossible to avoid if the supply of currency isn't finite. If so then whoever is increasing the supply is also going to significantly affect the economy. Like a tax from everyone that has money to the government or banks or gold miners or whoever. And from an individual perspective, having slightly more money in your pocket or bank account everyday is definitely a good thing.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Well you'd have to have a significant percent of people invest in bitcoin instead of investing in something else. Right. Bitcoin is mostly harmless so long as its not a significant currency. > And even then I'm not certain how much an effect it would have as speculating on commodities is very common already and a necessary part of the economy. Speculation on commodities that are outputs of production/extraction provides a useful function in terms of signal for resource allocation in a market economy. > And from an individual perspective, having slightly more money in your pocket or bank account everyday is definitely a good thing. If you have a net positive position in a currency, sure; if you're a debtor, having the value of the currency in which your debt is denominated being slightly more valuable each day is definitely a bad thing. Deflationary currency basically serves as an continuous upward transfer of wealth.
- Houshalter 13y ago>If you have a net positive position in a currency, sure; if you're a debtor, having the value of the currency in which your debt is denominated being slightly more valuable each day is definitely a bad thing. Deflationary currency basically serves as an continuous upward transfer of wealth. Interest rates would go down to match the deflation rate for that reason, or people could always make contracts that adjust for deflation. Besides bitcoin is meant for trading over the internet which until now has been an extreme pain. Loans and contracts will continue to be made in their nations currency for the most part, even if it does become widely adopted. (The benefit of competing currencies.) Also many people argue the same thing about printing money to cause inflation being a continuous upward transfer of wealth. >Speculation on commodities that are outputs of production/extraction provides a useful function in terms of signal for resource allocation in a market economy. It's more than that. Even for purely finite resources, someone buying a bunch of it up because they predict the price will go up, helps stabilize the price. They conserve the resource in the present for future buyers who value it more/are willing to pay more for it. And the speculator benefits of course. The opportunity cost is that they could have invested in another resource/investment instead of that one. Instead someone with a lower time preference will buy that resource (ie someone who values using it in the short term more than the long term.) But is that objectively a bad thing? In this scenario the people with higher time preferences are better off because they make more profit off their investments. The people with lower interest rates are better off because all other resources become cheaper. Is anyone actually worse off?
- rsynnott 13y ago> but at an individual level that is certainly a positive. It could arguably be a good thing for an individual provided that (a) they are relatively wealthy, and thus have significant amounts of money sitting around to benefit from deflation and (b) that their wealth doesn't come from industry, which is fueled by investment and credit, both of which can be expected to suffer severely in a deflationary economy, and (c) that their wealth doesn't come from employment, where wages would be expected to drop, and which is of course also fueled by investment and credit. Basically, it might make sense if you were a member of the pre-19th century landed gentry, but probably not otherwise.
- Houshalter 13y agoWell no anyone that holds money would benefit from the value of their money increasing. If the deflation was large enough then it might have an affect on investments but even then I'm not sure that's a negative thing. What's true of a finite currency is also true of any finite resource. Is the economy suffering because everyone is hoarding gold and oil and every other commodity rather than investing? The reason it might not be a negative thing is because investments aren't inherently a good thing. That is people with a higher time preference take up resources at the expense of people with a lower time preference. E.g. if you build a factory you take a ton of steel and concrete and land out of the economy which all becomes more scarce/expensive for everyone else. Sure the factory might benefit them when it's finished in a few years, but if they cared about that they would have invested in it in the first place. Anyways none of these things are true for bitcoin which is just for trading things online. It's not a replacement for national currencies, it's economy won't be that huge.