4 ms·
I'm confused why the ACLU is objecting to this. It seems like having police be trackable by their own departments while on duty should present absolutely no pr
by pmiller2 13y ago
I'm confused why the ACLU is objecting to this. It seems like having police be trackable by their own departments while on duty should present absolutely no privacy concern. And, for what it's worth, I think it's a good idea. At the very least, it will give police departments more data about what their officers are actually doing, and maybe it will prevent a few abuses of power.
I'd agree with the ACLU that this would be totally unconscionable if we were talking about tracking them 24/7, but that's clearly not the intent here.
- koenigdavidmj 13y agoThe argument that I have heard so far is that up until this point, when police enter a house and make an arrest, the jury doesn't see the accused until his lawyer gets to clean him up, put him in a suit, and get him to shut up. With ubiquitous cameras, the jury will now see the accused and his residence and will have that as their first impression of him.
- AnIrishDuck 13y agoI imagine that, if necessary, the accused's lawyer could argue that showing such footage would be unduly prejudicial. This would preclude the jury from ever seeing it (unless its probative value outweighed its prejudicial impact).
- nknighthb 13y agoSuch a video would be utterly irrelevant in most cases anyway. If you're in and out to arrest someone on a warrant, the actual events of that arrest have nothing to do with the reason they're being arrested, and would almost never come up in a trial to begin with.
- pmiller2 13y agoCorrect, but that doesn't apply to GPS in police cruisers. All that data can tell you is that the car was at X address at Y time, which is already obvious.
- amirmc 13y agoThey're not quite raising an objection, but rather using the opportunity to draw attention (and support) to their cause. "...That's why we hope police officers will join us in demanding that the state legislature pass forward-looking privacy protections to ensure that if the government wants to track a private citizen—by license plate reader, GPS device, or cell phone—it needs to first get a warrant" Note that it refers to 'private citizen' not police officers.
- oofabz 13y agoThe ACLU stands for civil liberty. Civil liberty is about protecting the rights of individuals from the government and other powerful actors. In this case, the privacy of individual officers is being threatened by the government. One might argue that on-duty police shouldn't have privacy, that society benefits from transparency. But that's not the job of the ACLU. Personally I respect their ideological consistency. It reminds me of Richard Stallman; even when I disagree with him, I'm glad he's out there doing what he does.