4 ms·
In what way does BTC impose a 100% reserve requirement? Unless I'm missing something here, there is nothing stopping a bank from loaning every BTC it takes in d
by sliverstorm 13y ago
In what way does BTC impose a 100% reserve requirement? Unless I'm missing something here, there is nothing stopping a bank from loaning every BTC it takes in deposit, (i.e. 0% reserve requirement) aside from possible federal regulation.
- moron4hire 13y agoBecause you can't just make up 10 new bitcoin IDs to be able to lend out against your 1 bitcoin. It would require creating bitcoin-backed bank notes. We'd be back to a reserve currency. Not that I personally think there is anything wrong with a reserve currency, but they tend to significantly curtail the power of governments to wage war, so it's extremely unlikely we'll ever go back to such a system.
- dragontamer 13y agoYou mean, like how Mt. Gox has virtual BTCs and virtual USDs in your account? It is far easier to create "virtual currency" than you seem to think.
- moron4hire 13y agoSo a bitcoin is a cryptographic hash, right? Not much more than a GUID that is truly G and really, really hard to calculate. To make a transaction, you have to check the blockchain of the bitcoin to make sure it hasn't been double-spent, that the person you're receiving the bitcoin from has the right to give you that coin. How would you fraction a bitcoin, thereby allowing 10x spending? You can't just invent new bitcoin hashes, because the creation of valid bitcoin hashes is the mining process itself, and is designed to be time-consuming.
- dragontamer 13y agoSure you can. When you transfer USD into Mt. Gox, you can then buy some "virtual" BTC. The BTC that is in your Mt. Gox account is purely virtual. Until you manually transfer it out of Mt. Gox, you don't even know if those BTC exist yet. I'm not necessarily saying that Mt. Gox is lying to anyone (although they don't strike much confidence in me...). I'm simply stating that the job of lying to the customers is a lot easier than you might think. Take GPL for instance. It "virtually" held BTC for its customers, and one day... they decided to disappear off the face of the internet. Unless those BTC are exactly in a private, offline wallet, you have NO guarantee that you are actually in full possession of those BTC. That is why BTC regulation as a currency is a necessary step forward. If institutions are forced to offer guarantees on the promised value of your BTC Accounts, then life will be a lot easier for the BTC consumers.
- phyalow 13y agoMF Global...
- AnIrishDuck 13y agoYou're right, in a way. But the main issue I'm still struggling with is credit and lending, which are core features of fractional reserve banking. And the more I think about it, the less the "fractional reserve" model makes sense when applied to bitcoin. If memory serves, this is how banking works today (beware, there are gross simplifications in here): 1. Customer A deposits $1 in Bank A 2. Customer B asks Bank A for $9 3. Bank A now needs to borrow $9. It can legally do this because it can prove to the government that its reserves ($1) are greater than 10% of its outstanding liabilities ($9). It first tries other banks, but if all else fails it can borrow from the Fed. 4. Bank A gives $9 to Customer B. I cannot see how step 3 happens in "bitcoin banking". The whole point is that there's no "central point of trust" and hence no lender of last resort. Or to restate, one of fractional reserve banking's key purposes is to influence the money supply. But this is clearly impossible under a "pure bitcoin" system, where the money supply is fixed by fiat.
- maxerickson 13y agoStep 3 doesn't have to happen for money supply expansion to take place. If the bank lends out $0.90 of the $1, people in the economy will be acting like $1.90 of money exists.
- AnIrishDuck 13y agoRight, hence what I said (which is somewhat inaccurate) about a "100% reserve requirement". The bank could lend any amount up to its total deposits, but not above. This is very different than how banking works today. Banks (in the US) can lend up to 1000% of their current deposits. This is a core feature of the fractional reserve system, and is clearly impossible under a pure bitcoin alternative.
- maxerickson 13y agoIn practice, they don't. You can compare loans and leases with deposits here (around 75% right now...): http://www2.fdic.gov/SDI/SOB/ http://www2.fdic.gov/SDI/SOB/ I guess you are saying they do accounting shenanigans with the Federal Reserve to make the deposits larger than they really are? (I will admit, I am more interested in aggregate practice here than I am in what the more extreme banks are doing)