3 ms·
Can't NSA datacenters with specialized crypto chips simply get 51% of bitcoin mining power for some time, if they want? Now that would be 'fiat currency'.
by PeterisP 13y ago
Can't NSA datacenters with specialized crypto chips simply get 51% of bitcoin mining power for some time, if they want? Now that would be 'fiat currency'.
- bigiain 13y agoI wonder… I've seen a lot these last few weeks about the volume of Chinese Bitcoin transactions. I wonder if the "hobbyist/geek/hacker/early-adopter" Bitcoin miners will end up attempting to "hold the balance of power" while state-backed Chinese and US crypto-clusters fight each other for 51% of the hashrate? So long as "we" can keep a few percent of the global hashrate out of US/Chinese government control, perhaps they'll both escalate at similar-enough rates that a few thousand USB ASICs and a few tens of thousand gaming-rig GPUs might keep everybodies stach of Bitcoin "safe"?
- wmf 13y agoIt seems unlikely that two parties would try to launch 51% attacks at the same time. And if one party started an attack it would probably take someone else at least 30 days to fab enough chips to respond, by which time the attack would be over one way or the other.
- rictic 13y agoThey could spend a lot of money and gain the ability to double spend and stall any (or all) transactions, but they couldn't create more coins than allowed or seize assets.
- sliverstorm 13y agoIf they control the network, can't they determine the mining difficulty? Difficulty is a single, unified knob that combined with the miners directly controls the rate of BTC generation. Also, if they can freeze (stall) certain wallets indefinitely, that's pretty much as good as asset seizure.
- tlrobinson 13y ago51% attacks don't allow you to mine arbitrary amounts of Bitcoin. At worst they could DoS the Bitcoin network and double-spend their funds, but the recipients (their own citizens? other governments?) would find out and be pissed.
- PeterisP 13y agoDoS it long enough, and you in effect confiscate/destroy the wealth of all Bitcoin holders, if you wish so; and as they have the most experience in producing specialized crypto-processing hardware on a large scale, it wouldn't be that expensive when compared to the [future] value of Bitcoin network. Others getting 'pissed'? What are they going to do? The very limited consequences of Snowden-leaks pretty much show that they can do such things and ignore protests, if the government leaders are okay with that.
- moron4hire 13y agoThe citizenry is already pissed and it means nothing. They do what they want.