4 ms·
And my company will be huuuuge, once it captures 1/4 of the market of China.
by wlesieutre 13y ago
And my company will be huuuuge, once it captures 1/4 of the market of China.
- SwellJoe 13y agoBitcoin isn't a company. It's not comparable to much that has existed before, actually. So, while I won't try to predict where BTC will end up, I think it's not a useful analogy to compare it to a company and discuss market share in those same terms.
- astrodust 13y agoIt is not going to eclipse gold in terms of importance. It won't even come within an order of magnitude.
- SwellJoe 13y agoThat's an assertion I've heard, mostly from goldbugs who have a vested interest in gold remaining high and going higher. But, I haven't heard any useful evidence to support the thesis.
- astrodust 13y agoSeriously? Will the US and other major countries hold their reserves in Bitcoin? It's not goldbugs or small-time hoarders. There's literal tons of the stuff held in vaults around the world. This is just one vault: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2247196/Pictured-Professor-Poliakoff-takes-TV-cameras-inside-Bank-Englands-gold-bullion-vault-197BILLION-precious-metal-stored.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2247196/Pictured-Pro... The total reserves are 31,000 tons of gold (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_reserve http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_reserve) which at $35M works out to about $1 trillion. So if the sum of all Bitcoins is to be worth the same, then you'd need a per-Bitcoin price of $51,600 for all 21 million theoretical Bitcoins. I find it unlikely that price could be sustained.
- SwellJoe 13y agoI've asked you why you think gold is a better currency than Bitcoin. You've answered, roughly, "There's a lot of it being hoarded by some people all over the world." I think maybe I just don't understand you. Are you saying because gold is one popular store of value, it is a better currency than Bitcoin? That's kinda what I'm hearing, but that doesn't really make sense, so I assume I'm misinterpreting you. From my perspective, the US currency (and most of the currencies found the world over) are not backed by gold or other precious metals. The idea of gold==money has been kind of dead since before I was born, and I'm not convinced there's a useful reason to return to it in the Internet age. Sending gold over a wire is not feasible, so I'd have to trust someone to hold my gold for me, were I to use it as a currency. That's not really appealing to me. The de-centralized nature of BTC is what makes it so disruptive. It just feels like a really old-fashioned idea that we should return to gold for currency (and I've felt that way even way back when I was a card-carrying member of the LP and a subscriber to Reason and Liberty magazines).
- astrodust 13y agoThe thing is, gold is a physical commodity that requires great expense to mine, process, and produce in a form that's useful. This limits the amount of gold that can be produced. That's why, historically speaking, it was used as a backing for currency, or as currency itself in some circles. Worst case scenario, no matter what the price of gold is, you still have the gold itself, and it can be made into things. If Bitcoin collapses you have nothing, the currency is intrinsically worthless. You can easily validate that someone owns a certain amount of gold, and you can be reasonably assured that, if you've put a gold brick in your safe, that barring someone physically breaking into your safe, that it'll still be there when you need it later. Bitcoin, on the other hand, is digital, and comes with it all the risks of digital data. It can be stolen silently, invisibly, or your wallet can become corrupted, or you can lose your password, which renders it utterly worthless. I'm not saying we should return to gold, but that gold is a commodity with more stability than Bitcoin. Bitcoin could utterly collapse tomorrow and the impact on the markets wouldn't even register. If gold collapsed tomorrow the markets would crumble.
- olefoo 13y agoYes. It's a new class of entity, politically and financially. And that means that prognostication and prediction is going to be really hard. Especially since so many of the possibilities are completely non-linear. Here's a link to a shared document listing some possible outcomes. Read/Write: http://www.writeurl.com/text/b7q9kx4x324ldwn732r8/rd29dbbpd73tbl0u2yfl/d1pn21u2egkngnsw03oo http://www.writeurl.com/text/b7q9kx4x324ldwn732r8/rd29dbbpd7... Read-only: http://www.writeurl.com/text/b7q9kx4x324ldwn732r8/rd29dbbpd73tbl0u2yfl http://www.writeurl.com/text/b7q9kx4x324ldwn732r8/rd29dbbpd7... Hop in and make some suggestions.
- lmg643 13y agodepending on the market dynamics, it is quite often that "someone" can capture 1/4 of the market (it just may not be you). if there are many perfect stores of digital value then bitcoin will be one of many, not that special, and unlikely to dominate. i am not familar with the alternatives. my post is a thought exercise on potential value of a digital currency. with regards to bitcoin dimes and quarters - i stand corrected. although i confess to having a hard time imagining how folks will keep track of all this.
- wmf 13y agoif there are many perfect stores of digital value then bitcoin will be one of many, not that special, and unlikely to dominate. If there's no difference between digital currencies then the first one will dominate, and the first one is called Bitcoin.