2 ms·
If you are suicidal and someone tells you that action 'X' will convince you to change your views and want to go on living, why would you 'take action X'? The r
by jodrellblank 13y ago
If you are suicidal and someone tells you that action 'X' will convince you to change your views and want to go on living, why would you 'take action X'?
The result 'want to go on living' is not a goal you want to reach.
(Where 'X' might be phoning a helpline, downloading an app, talking to a therapist, doing a thought experiment).
But that doesn't mean your desire to commit suicide is valid and coherent and respectable. We, the living, agree that living is better than non-living, that happiness is better than sadness, and that health is better than illness.
When someone is too ill to physically take care of themselves, we take over and act where possible "in their best interests" until they recover.
When someone is suicidal, they don't want to go on living, and offering help isn't enough because they won't reach out and take it. The only respectable act on our part is to consider them incapable and take over control of their life, assume their best interest is 'survival' and help them towards that.
anyone in this thread who supports your cause, a terrorist and/or sadist. I will accuse you of in fact not helping people, but misguidedly (due to complete and utter ignorance on your part) torturing people by encouraging them to experience more suffering.
Why would you assume that the goal would be to dump the person right into a life of suffering, instead of to help them out of the suffering as well? Current suicide prevention interventions don't always help as much as they could, but that's rather because they are implemented poorly than because they want people to suffer.