4 ms·
The question is whether the arguments behind "anti-democracy" (bad terminology: not all non-democratic forms of government have anything in common with each-oth
by eli_gottlieb 13y ago
The question is whether the arguments behind "anti-democracy" (bad terminology: not all non-democratic forms of government have anything in common with each-other other than their lack of democracy) are value arguments or effectiveness arguments.
There's a huge difference in saying, "We have a system that serves the people's values and interests better than democracy does", and "You proles don't deserve a voice." Unfortunately, the vast majority of anti-democratic rhetoric right now is of the latter kind.
- crassus 13y agoIf a system works well, how does having a voice add anything? If a system is broken, how does having a voice matter? In the United States, "Voice" is just rhetoric used to make people accept the status quo.
- eli_gottlieb 13y ago>If a system works well, how does having a voice add anything? It's entirely possible for the system to work well at doing something people hate. Hence why the people need a voice.