3 ms·
Way to dump your own depressive tendencies on a 15 year old. Jesus.
by EdwardDiego 13y ago
Way to dump your own depressive tendencies on a 15 year old. Jesus.
- itistoday2 13y agoWay to dump your own depressive tendencies on a 15 year old. Jesus. ^-- A perfect example of the ignorance that I mentioned, thank you. To Krish: remember, people who contemplate suicide are constantly faced with such ignorance, and so in the cultures where such attitudes are common, suicide happens unexpectedly (and this is most of the world). Then people "wish they could have said how much they loved them", etc. etc.
- EdwardDiego 13y agoIgnorance? Oh my. Unfortunately, I satisfy your criteria required for understanding suicide, so I vehemently disagree with your assertion that "Suicide is a very rational reaction to life." Especially when we're discussing teenagers, who haven't even lived one fifth of their expected lifespan.
- itistoday2 13y ago> Unfortunately, I satisfy your criteria required for understanding suicide, so I vehemently disagree with your assertion that "Suicide is a very rational reaction to life." OK, you're certainly entitled to your opinion and to disagree with mine. Especially when we're discussing teenagers, who haven't even lived one fifth of their expected lifespan. It was only a short time ago that it was common in Europe and elsewhere for 15 year olds to be starting families. Today, many 15 year olds (and younger), commit suicide. What exactly are you seeking to accomplish by emphasizing his age and your arbitrary requirement on what the "right amount of life" is?
- DanBC 13y ago> Especially when we're discussing teenagers, ...and who haven't finished cognitive development.
- krrishd 13y agoI understand your view point, and will keep it in mind while designing the app.
- itistoday2 13y ago+1 :)
- mindcrime 13y agoBut he has a good point. I don't think we can say that "suicide" is a universally Bad Thing, and I think it's fair to say that if you want to help prevent suicide, you could benefit from trying very hard to understand the mindset of a person who is contemplating suicide. Reading and understanding the arguments for suicide strike me as a very valuable tool in accomplishing that. You can't really understand suicide unless you yourself are feeling suicidal, but if you approach if from multiple directions / angles and kinda circle around it, you may be able to gain a better appreciation for it (without needing to become suicidal yourself). All of this said, and saying this as someone who has contemplated suicide at least once in my life, I don't know much much any kind of app is really going to help. The times in my life that I've been depressed enough to think thoughts like that, I doubt I would have pulled up an app and consulted it. Same deal with "Suicide prevention hotlines". My feeling is that many people who contemplate suicide don't want to be talked out of it, and won't call the hotline no matter how well publicized it is or whatever. When you're suicidal, you're in a totally different mental state where the normal rules just don't apply. Which leads back to my saying that you can't really understand suicide, and why I think the GP post was valuable.
- DanBC 13y agoBut reading "pro euthanasia" information is going to be very very different from reading "pro suicide" information. > All of this said, and saying this as someone who has contemplated suicide at least once in my life, I don't know much much any kind of app is really going to help. I gently agree. I hope it gets some research and oversight. And, if it works I hope it takes off. > Same deal with "Suicide prevention hotlines". My feeling is that many people who contemplate suicide don't want to be talked out of it, and won't call the hotline The Samaritans tend to say that they're not a "suicide prevention" hotline for that reason. They even say that they'll stay on the phone with you as you die if that's what you want. They say they just listen. This is for exactly the reason you mention - people don't want preachy "don't do it" advice, but they might want to just talk to someone. > When you're suicidal, you're in a totally different mental state where the normal rules just don't apply. Yes. And sometimes all that's needed is a small diversion, a bit of distraction, to allow the person to make it through the night without the attempted suicide, and to thus get help from doctors in the morning. > Which leads back to my saying that you can't really understand suicide, and why I think the GP post was valuable. I don't understand my own suicide attempts. I certainly don't understand the completed suicides of friends and acquaintances. I'd be foolish if I pretended to understand the completed or attempted of people in other nations (with different cultural expectations and so on). But GPs post (while it may have had a germ of useful information) is just weird and misleading. Most people contemplating suicide are not in a position where euthanasia would be considered - they're suffering from some mental health problem. "Wanting to kill yourself" is not a rational reaction to life events. At least, not for most of the people who complete suicide. Some relatively minor interventions (a low interest loan of $4,000; some good debt advice; better lawyers and a decent legal system; housing advice; etc) would prevent many suicides. To suggest that suicide is a rational choice when the person is not capable of making a rational choice about life is cruel.