10 ms·
Reddit is Growing Slowly, but Surely
- gabemart 13y agoI'd be cautious of using number of submissions as a metric for growth. It's possible that at least some of the growth in the number of submissions is caused by an increase in the ratio of spam. In fact, a growing number of submissions can be a problem for a social news aggregator. Is it fair to assume that curation capacity will scale linearly with submission quantity? Perhaps not. Even if a linear growth in submissions represents a scaled growth in visitors and user accounts, curation capacity will only scale if new user accounts have the same curation appetite as older user accounts. If you get lots of new submissions and lots of new visitors but a smaller number of new people voting on submissions, average quality of front-page material will suffer. It's possible there will be a positive feedback effect if older users with a higher appetite for curating content are more sensitive to a decline in quality and thus more likely to leave the site, exacerbating the problem. When a social news site is young and small, (non-spam) submissions are a Good Thing. But as a user-driven site matures, it's much more valuable to have better submissions rather than more submissions. I hypothesize that one solution to the seemingly inevitable decline in quality of large social sharing sites is to introduce a cost to posting new content. A trivial example would be scaling the minimum time between submissions to the user's karma for previous submissions. (For this to work without incentivizing spam via sock puppets, there would have to be heavy restrictions on posting content for new users.) The time-between-submissions could be large for less proven accounts - think days rather than minutes. There are problems with this approach, but they may be better problems to have than the alternative.
- niuzeta 13y agoexactly. the number of submissions is simply too simple a measure for too broad a site. what about karma distribution, responses, flames and all? you might have a site with ten submissions a day but of those ten nine are a good read, and another site with 100 submissions but also nine good reads.
- shiftpgdn 13y agoI run a small subreddit with about 4k subscribers and I think you're onto something. The amount of spam that beats the spam filter feels absolutely overwhelming sometimes. Even with self posts only enabled there is still a crushing amount of spam submitted daily.
- nikolak 13y agoMy experience is completely different. I run 2 subreddits, one with ~15k subscribers and one with ~2k, and I don't remember last time I even saw spam being submitted - and when it got submitted 95% of the time spam filter caught it. If I remember correctly number of spam posts that got through spam filter was a lot higher a year ago than now.
- nols 13y agoI'm not seeing that at all, I run a few subs over 10K users and I'm not seeing much spam at all.
- shiftpgdn 13y agoWhat are your subs targeted at though?
- thatthatis 13y agoThey went from just under 30k submissions a day to just under 80k submissions a day in 2 years. That's 166% growth in 2 years. That's not "slowly" Further, you'd expect growth of submissions in a "best rise to the top" system to be lower that growth of overall use. A traffic chart, or a chart of the total number of votes (not just upvotes) would be a far better estimate of their true growth.
- kristopher 13y agoI wonder how the number of daily submissions were tabulated. If reddit were using an ID based on some sort of fixed constant (for example time) then these results could be in-fact fairly linear. Please note that I do believe that reddit is growing!
- minimaxir 13y agoReddit has an endpoint where you can download all submissions. (however, due to the API limit of 100 submissions / 2 seconds, it took me about 1.5-2 months to get the 41 million submissions)
- marketforlemmas 13y agoHave you looked at number of comments instead of number of submissions? That would seem to be a better estimator of user growth. Honestly, I don't think that estimating number of submissions is a very good metric for the growth of Reddit (or Hackernews). If you want some proxy for its influence, you care about readership more than anything else. This thread [1] on Reddit (and the references therein) shows that 50% of Reddit activity comes from users that aren't even logged in. So even if you were just able to measure logged in users (which would still be a far greater number than submissions), you would still only estimate half the influence. [1] http://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/1khp85/logged_out_users_account_for_50_of_reddits_traffic/ http://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/1khp85/logge...
- jedberg 13y agoWouldn't it be easier to just look at the public traffic information at http://www.reddit.com/about http://www.reddit.com/about ?
- milhous 13y agoI signed up to reddit a few months ago and found it great for local events and meetups, with little interest and time for memes or browsing the main page. I could see it as a competitor to Craigslist, meetup.com, and others. Very versatile site.
- rpsw 13y agoSubmissions is only a small piece of the puzzle. The number of active commenter's and even the number of consumer-only are quite important measures to get an accurate picture of growth. In a community there can be small core of active submitters, but there could also be a large number of passive users clicking ads. Someone might never have made a submission, but could have given or received gold, as well.
- 001sky 13y agoHelpful tip to for author/analysis might be to add some components of velocity or acceleration. Submissions seems akin to a 'mass' but what one is trying to understand is 'energy', and this feels too one-dimensional IMHO.
- buckbova 13y agoI love the freedom of the platform. Create any subreddit you like. Moderate it anyway you like. Upvote what you want to see downvote those with no value. But, as with digg, I couldn't have reasonable discussions there. It was always a flamewar or an attack by the hivemind. Then there is the memes. Too too many on nearly every board. Don't get me started on rage comics.
- vinkelhake 13y agoThe greatness of Reddit is indeed in the subreddits. Just curious, which subreddits did you try to have reasonable discussions in? The ones I find myself in are moderated efficiently and there's not a trace of memes or rage comics.
- DanBC 13y agoLook at Minecraft - the regular /r/minecraft has active moderation, but threads are full of up-voted low quality comments. /r/trueminecraft should be better, and the submissions are great but there's very little discussion there.
- criley2 13y agoSorry, but /r/minecraft targets tweens and kids. Yes, a subreddit primarily frequented by 8-15 year olds is going to appear "non-academic". Even subreddits like /r/feedthebeast, which has become the de-facto modded minecraft subreddit (for Forge flavors, at least) host much higher quality discussions and content and have almost no memes/jokes upvoted. But again, that's probably because the FTB subreddit has less overall subscribers (less incentive to post for karma, as there are less potential viewers to reward you) as well as an average higher age of the users.
- idProQuo 13y ago> But again, that's probably because the FTB subreddit has less overall subscribers (less incentive to post for karma, as there are less potential viewers to reward you) Hold up, you might be on to something. What if reddit divided karma received by the number of subscribers in the sub where something was posted? They'd need to then multiply it by some constant multiplier or something, there'd be some details to tweak, but that might do a lot to mitigate the problem of subreddits getting crappier as they get more popular.
- dpatrick86 13y agoNumber of participants in secret santa might be a nice metric to throw in with the growth metrics too.
- kin 13y agoDoes anyone see subreddits making forums obsolete?
- dublinben 13y agoMaybe in some cases, but not when the pace of conversation is slower. Reddit locks threads after a few months, and anything beyond the latest 100 submissions is pretty much gone.
- TillE 13y agoThat's optimistic. In even a lightly active subreddit, posts disappear after about 48 hours. Stickies kinda solve part of the problem, but Reddit's comment system is entirely unsuitable for ongoing discussions. I'm not sure traditional forums are the best we can do either, but Reddit is certainly worse.
- dublinben 13y agoYou're totally right. Reddit is terrible for any kind of ongoing discussion.
- jedberg 13y agoIt's not like reddit's traffic is a secret. When I worked there, we had no trouble sharing our uniques and pageviews, it is still the same today. Just ask them. And for the record, the traffic doubles about once every 18 months. The pageviews double about once every 14 months (so slightly faster then user growth). In fact, the traffic is right here: http://www.reddit.com/about http://www.reddit.com/about
- twelvechairs 13y agoFunny that growth of this speed can ever be considered 'slowly'
- simcop2387 13y agoAnother great source for this kind of data and analysis of the site has been TheoryOfReddit[1]. Along with traffic data, there are people doing network analysis of all kinds between the groups on there, and even comment analysis. [1] http://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit http://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit
- jedberg 13y agoBe careful though, those folks are wrong more often then they are right. I've tried to point out their mistakes in the past, but they usually just accused me of trying to be deceptive, so I gave up.
- simcop2387 13y agoThat wouldn't surprise me too much about some of them. The only ones that I'd really read are the ones that are actually releasing the data they got on it all, which is still a fair bit of them. That said, there is still a large amount of speculation going on there.
- dxm 13y agoReddit went all out with April fools day in 2013, they pitted users against each other (Periwinkle vs. Orangered) which is likely the spike in submissions compared with other years.