3 ms·
If he's engaging in naive statist technocracy, you're engaging in naive proprietarian minarchism: "Just get the state out of everything except property and cont
by eli_gottlieb 13y ago
If he's engaging in naive statist technocracy, you're engaging in naive proprietarian minarchism: "Just get the state out of everything except property and contracts and it'll all work out fine somehow!"
- mseebach 13y agoPlease quote the bit where I said that? No? Ok, then. My position is that we do need the state, but we need to inject a lot more realism (ie cynicism) about what what government can realistically do (not to mention, do well) into the debate in order to get to a better place. EDIT: I suspect that you might be referring to my comments on different posts. I find that arguing the libertarian point of view is a useful method of injecting the mentioned realism. Do I find the stateless society appealing? Yes, in theory, as a construct to debate the extreme consequences of ideas. It's a rewarding intellectual exercise to consider how justice might work without the state. But I'm no utopian and I have no illusions about the extreme dangers of revolution. So my "real world" political contributions is in the space of injecting more cynicism into the democratic process in the hope of inspiring more people to avoid reflectively turning to the state to mend their ills and consider, for an example, technological solutions instead.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoAnd I would say that if you think there is a one-dimensional battle, "State: for or against? Pick a side, we're at war!", then you're ignoring most of real politics.
- fennecfoxen 13y agoYou're right! Most 'real' politicians only pick the 'for' side. ;)
- Zigurd 13y agoThe problem is an entrenched system that has nerfed the ability to impose change at the ballot box, and it is the same problem for everyone looking for substantive change. Statism, fascism, the military industrial complex, corporatism... call it what you like. Voting, or even engagement with the political process, is not the starting point. Obamacare is the recent high water mark for change. Woo! Right? We have to solve that problem first.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoOk, let me state very clearly my problem with the term "statism": it is a negative. Not a negative in the sense of having a negative emotional connotation, but a negative the way a piece of photographic film is negative. "Statism" doesn't tell me anything about the position being labelled statist. It only tells me that the person doing the labelling is a ~~libertarian~~ proprietarian minarchist. Left-anarchists don't even use the unvarnished term "statist", not even as a term for policies they oppose. I want people to stop using terms that tell me about their personalities and start using terms that tell me about the politics under discussion.
- mseebach 13y agoOh, it's a good thing that all of your comments are so constructive and engaging with the subject, then. FWIW, in my usage "Statism", is a reference to the assumption that by default, a problem should always be dealt with by the state, and when a problem isn't dealt with correctly, the default assumption is that it's a symptom of the state holding too little power and too few resources. I think that these assumptions are not always false, but they are false often enough that the possibility that they are warrants careful discussion.
- eli_gottlieb 13y ago>FWIW, in my usage "Statism", is a reference to the assumption that by default, a problem should always be dealt with by the state, and when a problem isn't dealt with correctly, the default assumption is that it's a symptom of the state holding too little power and too few resources. These are "assumptions" that almost zero real people actually assume.
- mortyseinfeld 13y agoThese are "assumptions" that almost zero real people actually assume. No, that's pretty much the default assumption of the statist. It sounds like you just don't like the term.