2 ms·
It confuses me that anyone can believe that liberalism or technological advance are not universally desirable. You want a quick sampling of various theories?
by patio11 17y ago
It confuses me that anyone can believe that liberalism or technological advance are not universally desirable.
You want a quick sampling of various theories? (I should point out that I don't believe everything I've read, if it wasn't totally obvious from my first comment.)
Liberalism is a myth that the West uses when it needs a convenient excuse for a war and/or resource exploitation.
Cultural diversity is groovy. (Sometimes phrased as: cultural diversity, like ecological diversity, is imperative to the physical survival of the human race.) Introduction of "foreign" technology inevitably results in culture loss.
Technological advance sometimes results in taking the old evil things and making us much, much better at them. See: ultrasounds in China, radios in Rwanda, railroads in the United States, civil engineering in Iraq, the cotton gin in the American South, etc etc
On balance, I think most technological progress is a great thing. I might not be quite a booster if I had been kidnapped by a rival tribe to be sold across the ocean into slavery because some American inventor had figured out how to make cotton farming scale. And I don't think I would be that persuaded to change my mind just because a lot of people were finally able to purchase cotton shirts due to the deal.
- nopassrecover 17y agoThanks. Fortunately, in collaboration liberalism and technological advance avoid some of the pitfalls you talk about. I agree that liberalism isn't practiced widely enough or honestly enough, but this isn't a fault with liberalism. The cultural diversity argument is weak. From a pragmatic viewpoint, if this diversity was imperative to survival then it would itself survive the influence of other culture. Secondly, culture can and is incorporated (albeit selectively although this may be a good thing) into rapidly developing cultures. If cultural homogeneity means we lose cannibalism, ritual and religious mutilation and millions of children dying to smoke inhalation each year then I can live with that. I think the good and distinct components of undeveloped cultures will be embraced by developed cultures and cherished by the developing cultures themselves.