3 ms·
Nonviolent != victimless. My point is not about 'should X be punished' but 'how do we handle definitely punishable small crimes repeated ad nauseam'. Think abo
by PeterisP 13y ago
Nonviolent != victimless. My point is not about 'should X be punished' but 'how do we handle definitely punishable small crimes repeated ad nauseam'.
Think about a routine drug user (say, heroin addict) who regularly (daily/weekly) performs theft to sustain the habit - car radios, shoplifting, maybe an apartment if he gets a chance. It is a very common scenario in many places, if the user can't quit (or always restarts a few months after therapy/quitting) and the needed drugs are all illegal & expensive; as the only real non-crime [here] alternative they have is prostitution and many of them consider theft as the more pleasant option.
Even a small, friendly village community who know everyone and help each other would likely vote [for laws] to imprison him in order to stop the behavior. Rehabilitation is another option, but the idea is that after 3-strikes you have to admit that your rehabilitation (however good or bad it is) doesn't work and you have to do something else.
Or think of a genuine kleptomaniac. Unless it's successfully treated, you still need to take some measures to prevent repeated crimes.