4 ms·
There goes the industry. PrimeSense was, to my knowledge, the only company selling affordable room-range 3D sensors to independent developers. There are count
by nitrogen 13y ago
There goes the industry. PrimeSense was, to my knowledge, the only company selling affordable room-range 3D sensors to independent developers.
There are countless unexplored avenues for 3D sensing technology, far beyond gimmicky gestural controls. My own application, as a high-accuracy presence detector for home automation, reached the front page of HN a few years ago (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2303395 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2303395). Others were using these sensors for DIY robotics applications, telemedicine, etc.
Now we'll probably have to wait another 20 years for another round of patents to expire before we "little guys" get another shot at depth sensing.
Good luck to PrimeSense, they probably deserve the exit, but bad news for the rest of us.
- chad_oliver 13y agoWhat about a kinect? They're capable, (relatively) cheap, and their ubiquity means that they have a good community.
- nitrogen 13y agoYes, but there won't be any new old Kinects, and the New Kinect requires entirely new reverse engineering and USB3, so it's not a drop-in replacement. My system uses Kinects, but we can't rely on them being available in the long run.
- pbreit 13y agoDon't know about he current device but Leap Motion can cover a football field. I don't think we'll need to wait too long and the tech will be even better and more developer friendly.
- nitrogen 13y agoA football field? That would be quite useful. I got the impression from reviews of Leap Motion that it only worked in a small area directly in front of the sensor.
- pbreit 13y agoI think the current device was designed only for a small area but Leap's tech easily supports much bigger areas.
- dimatura 13y agoYou're being too pessimistic. Depth sensing is not that complicated. Even vanilla stereo vision has gotten really good in the last few years and will only get better.
- onedev 13y agoCan you explain to me how Depth Sensing works at a high level?
- nitrogen 13y agoSome useful starting points: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time-of-flight_camera https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time-of-flight_camera https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structured-light_3D_scanner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structured-light_3D_scanner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Range_imaging https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Range_imaging
- nitrogen 13y agoDepth sensing as a small company in a minefield of patents is a lot easier if you buy your sensor from a company that has patents of its own.
- icelancer 13y agoWhat about the ASUS Xtion? We use them in our lab along with regular stereo cameras for DLT.
- nitrogen 13y agoThe Xtion is a PrimeSense design. We can hope for continued availability, but Apple's history suggests such hope may be in vain.
- icelancer 13y agoUnfortunate. I've moved on to using DLT with 60-120 FPS cameras but I always root for depth sensors. The problem with the depth sensors is that the sample rate on them is just horrible (25-30 Hz which is unusable for any human motion that is beyond a stroll). We'll see how it shakes out.
- nitrogen 13y agoThe New Kinect for the Xbox One is supposed to offer a much higher refresh rate, with less noise. I'm hoping that someone with the spare cash to buy a USB3 debugger will reverse engineer the protocol so we can use either the Xbox One Kinects or the next iteration of the Kinect for Windows on non-Windows systems.
- malandrew 13y agoTime to push open source software and hardware solutions. Design one, prototype and run a kickstarter.
- icelancer 13y agonitrogen's posts indicate that he works in the field of mocap, and so he probably knows just as well as I do that these designs/developments are ridiculously hard to do. Besides, kickstarters that rely on hardware fab probably have the highest failure rate on the whole site.