3 ms·
Allow me to present some "middle-ground" scenarios, from the top of my head: - Your spouse gives you trouble for something you said on a relationship advice fo
by marvin 13y ago
Allow me to present some "middle-ground" scenarios, from the top of my head:
- Your spouse gives you trouble for something you said on a relationship advice forum
- One of your friends causes drama after you express a political opinion not popular in your group
- It gets awkward at your family dinner because a couple of people found out that you posted under your full name at a BDSM forum
- You discussed some personal matter online with other people, and now the other people involved in the personal matter give you grief because you violated their trust by seeking advice or venting with others
None of these scenarios could in any concievable circumstance be called abuse. These are all scenarios which would pre-internet happen behind closed doors, in a social context where the people who would be offended by the statements couldn't hear them. On the internet, they are accessible to everyone. Having anonymous forums is clearly a better solution than creating seggregated online communities which emulate the "closed-doors" scenario which would occur in the physical world. That's not to say that the "closed-doors" scenario is outdated. But online anonymity in a forum of strangers provides an arena of expression which gives better opportunities for communication, than a strict opt-in community with close acquaintances [edit: and full names].
- ogreyonder 13y agoFor the sake of argument, let's say I agree with you. What are the corresponding points in those scenarios off the top of your head where being forced to use your full, real name is a middle-ground good? I can't see a benefit to the people in your stories having used their real name in the first place.
- marvin 13y agoOn the contrary, I am arguing that these are scenarios where anonymity is a good thing, but which are nowhere near the edge cases of online contributors abusing anonymity or hiding from persecution.
- ogreyonder 13y agoAh, that makes sense now. I was reading it wrong; thanks for clarifying.