5 ms·
Sigh. When are we going to stop trying to use things that are not meant to be identifiers (ip addresses, phone numbers, email addresses, SSNs) as identifiers?
by ams6110 13y ago
Sigh. When are we going to stop trying to use things that are not meant to be identifiers (ip addresses, phone numbers, email addresses, SSNs) as identifiers?
- thaumasiotes 13y agoIP addresses vary. The entire point of my phone number, or my email address, is to identify me. Email doesn't get sent "to whoever is interested", it gets sent to designated people. How are those not meant to be identifiers?
- damncabbage 13y agoSSNs, IPs and Phone Numbers get reused. People often have multiple email addresses. (Bonus: Yahoo! email addresses get reused too.)
- thaumasiotes 13y ago> People often have multiple email addresses. That doesn't affect the fact that the email address exists to identify the person. You'd need to say "people often share email addresses in common", which they don't.
- bandushrew 13y agoyes, they do. we have a shared email address between us that the kids use, and I use to sign up for some stuff. My parents have 3 emails addresses between themselves, and use them pretty much interchangeably. I worked at a distance education provider for a couple of years, and we commonly had entire families using the same email address. It turns out that when you sign up with an ISP, they give you a single email address by default, and you can - if you wish to, and know how, add more of your own. Outside of the tech industry, nobody knows how.
- bigiain 13y agoinfo@, accounts@, abuse@, webmaster@, support@, mail@ domains@ - those are just a few shared email addresses that I read.
- andrewaylett 13y agoI've found it very difficult to convince some people that my wife and I have separate email accounts -- sufficiently so that I set up a shared alias that forwards to both of us so I can give it to those people. I know plenty of couples who share an email account.
- tommorris 13y agoOn Wikipedia, we tend to not use indefinite IP blocks (there are some, but not many). For business and organisation IPs, if we get vandalism from that IP, we'll stick it on a long-term block (usually a year) and renew that block if there's recurring vandalism when the block expires.
- Amadou 13y agoHow are those not meant to be identifiers? They are intended to be delivery points for messages, not identifiers for non-messaging uses. The fact that the two functions are similar does not mean they are identical. Treating them as if they are identical just creates all kinds of (often unexpected) failure modes where the two functions don't overlap.
- josteink 13y agoSince when was a social security number not meant to be an identifier? Correct me if I'm wrong, but I presumed that was its one stated purpose?
- minikites 13y agoNope: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_number#Purpose_and_use http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Security_number#Purpose_...
- josteink 13y agoThanks for the reply and the correction! Ok. So you have me on one thing: it wasn't originally intended to be used as a personal identifier. You learn something new every day. But then according to your very own link, it has universally been used and repurposed for this exact thing for the last 45 years, without issues, and with duplicate SSNs no longer being a problem. I'd say that sounds like a very proven form of identification. So what problem do you (OP / ams6110) have with people using it as such?
- ketralnis 13y ago> without issues That's a stretch. Because: > So what problem do you (OP / ams6110) have with people using it as such? A SSN is the "secret" bit to a small amount of otherwise-public info (name, address, some other bits) to getting a loan or credit card or other credit-related actions in my name. I went to a small two-year school that used SSNs as their personal identifier numbers. Someone broke in and stole student records. Now the school's poor identity choices has put thousands of students' financial identities at risk.
- RexRollman 13y agoI remember the state of Virginia used to use SSNs for driver's license numbers but I've heard they've stopped doing that.
- 13y ago
- davidgerard 13y agoWhen there isn't money in the idea. (Or in selling the idea, even if it's a completely wrong idea.)