5 ms·
Your question boils down to: "Why not replace (insert hugely established system) with (completely new system)"? The answer to this one is obvious. In order to
by contingencies 13y ago
Your question boils down to: "Why not replace (insert hugely established system) with (completely new system)"?
The answer to this one is obvious. In order to grow, a replacements need to interoperate, ie. provide an "upgrade path". Instead of holding something up as the one true solution we are betting on the trend, which is certain. Besides, cash will always be around.
Cryptocurrencies, despite their huge number and numerous attractive properties, presently lack market depth, limiting both their stability as value stores and feasibility as trade instruments outside of rapid/realtime/automated exchange. Significant issues with the dominant one (Bitcoin) make it difficult to implement securely, hard for non-technical users to properly understand or trust (there is no benevolent dictatorial regulator, as per their established national currencies/financial service providers), they require connectivity or blockchain storage which is unvailable in much of the world's devices, and so on and so forth.
A parallel to your suggestion is the example of existing community currencies, which are essentially geographically bound equivalents of cryptocurrencies with an often more moralistic focus. I have been in contact with these groups and associations thereof, plus theorists in the area, and my understanding is that many face challenges in the same areas as Bitcoin; ie. new user education, balance of trade and interoperation with conventional established systems. Indeed, they are developing an inter-exchange protocol at present known as CXP.
As for your vast simplification, the best (from a moral standpoint) and hardest kind of change to reverse (from a potential opponent standpoint) is that which is is completely decentralized; an 'opt-in' from the edge nodes. I think this is what people are proposing in many spheres right now.
All roads lead to Rome.
- atweiden 13y ago> Significant issues with the dominant one (Bitcoin) make it difficult to implement securely, hard for non-technical users to properly understand or trust (there is no benevolent dictatorial regulator, as per their established national currencies/financial service providers), they require connectivity or blockchain storage which is unvailable in much of the world's devices, and so on and so forth. Download and install Electrum [1]. Open Electrum. Write down the 12 words. Done. There's your 100% non-technical Bitcoin wallet in three easy steps. Just takes pen and paper. Or, memorize it instead. Instant, secure brainwallet. No electricity, no Internet, no hardware and no software. Starts in seconds and syncs across Windows, Mac, Linux and Android devices. [1]: http://electrum.org http://electrum.org
- TheLegace 13y agoMy only issue with something like this, since no one is "in charge" of an account people will fail to remember their wallet or password. If they put large amounts of money and by chance they cannot access their wallet for whatever reasons who is going to give them their money back or is that money gone forever? Doesn't that also mean eventually we will loose track of a fair number of bitcoins?
- atweiden 13y agoWould a banker be able to replace your lost or stolen cash? If you're worried you might lose your Electrum wallet, write down the 12 words on several sheets of paper. Inscribe them in metal. Put them in a document, and put the document in TrueCrypt. Upload it to Dropbox. It's as easy as managing your digital music collection.
- rakoo 13y agoThat money is gone forever. It is your money, you are responsible for it. No one will be able to "give your money back", because you didn't give your money to anyone. If you fear you might lose your password, back it up. Store it in a safe. Send it to someone you trust. Tatoo it on your forearm (although this is not really secretive) Heck, if you _really_ want to be sure to have someone who could give the money back to you, just give it to someone you trust. Family, friends... or a Bitcoin bank. But if you do that, we're back to square one.
- sounds 13y agoThank you for responding in detail. I need to think over what you've written to grok the finer points, but here's one I can talk to: "Why not replace (insert hugely established system) with (completely new system)"? It's not a total rip-out-and-replace. Bitcoin might be the grease that enables the seriously broken parts of our struggling world economy to slip through the entrenched tax collectors and let the actual consumers reward the actual producers. It fills the niche of Community Currencies without the balkanization. One thing that the huge, established system misunderstands about the new entrant is where the most effective inroads will happen: The lower class. Someone already richly rewarded by the establishment is not going to be very interested in Bitcoin (other than as a toy). But someone in a nation outside the US and Western Europe? Bitcoin gives them first-world tools that completely bypass their local currency. It sounds like the classic innovator's dilemma. Suddenly trade barriers are being circumvented. Chinese currency can escape currency controls. Micropayments and small businesses have an option. I'm not convinced Bitcoin is that thing, but I'm certain the established system will fail to adapt. Develop a game plan for what that will look like and where you want to be when it happens. In thinking along those lines, I see that you're working with ISO–and in my mind, that's not where you want to be! :)
- gamblor956 13y agoBitcoin might be the grease that enables the seriously broken parts of our struggling world economy to slip through the entrenched tax collectors and let the actual consumers reward the actual producers. Bitcoin requires middleman, just like credit card processors. It also is significantly easier to trace than current financial systems, which don't assign digital fingerprints to units of currency. Bitcoin isn't going to let the world economy "slip through the entranched tax collectors." Bitcoin is a tax collector's wet dream. I've met with quite a few Treasury lawyers who work in their policy office. They're so giddy about the prospects of actually being able to trace income from start to finish, including across borders, that they've formed an internal task force to see what they can do about spurring adoption of Bitcoin or other similar digital currencies. Bitcoin gives them first-world tools that completely bypass their local currency. In many nations, you can already do that. In the US, businesses must be willing to accept USD for their services/products but they are free to also accept any other currency they wish. At the end of the day (or more accurately, their fiscal year), their books (and taxes) must be converted to USD for determining their taxes.