6 ms·
Failure to sign the Ottawa treaty (anti landmine) and the international criminal court agreements, execution of minors (and execution at all), assassination of
by lostlogin 13y ago
Failure to sign the Ottawa treaty (anti landmine) and the international criminal court agreements, execution of minors (and execution at all), assassination of opponents even if citizens (via drones), torture, war crimes, illegal invasions, use of phosphorus (probably comes under war crimes), continual killing of civilians in non declared wars, massive prison population, secret prisons, outsourcing torture, supporting some of the worst governments of earth etc. Who sees the US as a leader in human rights? No one I know.
- latch 13y agoIt's easy to distill these issues and hold a self-righteous opinion, but I personally find most too complex to form anything resembling an educated opinion. Take land mines. I've heard that they play a critical role in South Korea's defense, which was a major reason Clinton didn't sign. Military experts talk about how it's an effective tool that, when used responsibly, can benefit civilians more than harm them. They also kill and maim people. Intellectually, both sides seem reasonable to me. Of course, emotionally, one is passively helping people (or so we are told), while the other is actively harming them, so, ya, I lean towards being anti land mines. But, I fundamentally can't shake the feeling that I have no clue what's going on, so maybe I shouldn't be too quick to judge.
- fleitz 13y agoI'm pretty sure North Korea used the exact same reasoning when they didn't sign.
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoPoint being?
- sdoering 13y agoPoint being (I believe), it is expensive to take a moral position. It costs you money and thoughtful action. You could secure the South Korean border without landmines. It just would cost a lot more money. You could do a lot of other things (or rather not do them), but it might cost you your political standing. So point being - playing the moral high card, as the US do around the world, should not follow the line from a Genesis song: "Do as I say, don't do as I do..." At least in my humble opinion (the same goes for my Governement, the German one by the way.)
- alexeisadeski3 13y ago>"Do as I say, don't do as I do..." Does the US gov't say that everyone else should abandon land mines?
- benihana 13y agoThe US Government isn't a monolithic entity that has a singular opinion.
- fleitz 13y agoThe point being whatever you want to make of the similarities in the human rights records between the US and North Korea. Perhaps you think what North Korea does is the proper way to interact with the world, perhaps you think that the US should be the moral lead for countries like the Sudan, Rwanda, Sierra Leone, Afganistan, and Croatia instead of the moral follower.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoIf it is good enough for North Korea, it ought to be good enough for us! Right?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoFurther, there is a big difference between long term persistent land mines out of a plane into a civilian area (what the treaty is meant to stop), and keeping a careful inventory of (mostly wire controlled) mines in a controlled area just south of the border. The former will kill tons of non-soldiers and persist long after the war is over. The latter will kill NK soldiers moving south and can be easily collected in the event they are no longer necessary.
- lowkeykiwi 13y agoThat seems like a weak reason. The US and South Korean militaries could surely defend South Korea without mines.
- _pmf_ 13y ago> It's easy to distill these issues and hold a self-righteous opinion, but I personally find most too complex to form anything resembling an educated opinion. Ah, yes, complexity explains everything from the role of private oil companies in Iraq to the ties of the Bush family with the Bin Laden family. > But, I fundamentally can't shake the feeling that I have no clue what's going on, so maybe I shouldn't be too quick to judge. I think a very safe way, given the histoy over the last decaded, to form an opinion, is to consider everything the US defense industry-slash-ministry proclaims an outright lie and only accept very small points as true when they have been verified.
- Perseids 13y ago> It's easy to distill these issues and hold a self-righteous opinion, but I personally find most too complex to form anything resembling an educated opinion. The problem is the other extreme of not expressing an opinion where you have reasonable doubt will lead to leaving the discussion to everyone else. And there will always be a huge crowd of people who will voice their very uniformed opinion no matter what. Even worse, you become extremely susceptible to malign publicity tactics. For example I would not see it beyond the US government[1] to argue with South Korea's defense even if the land mine treaty explicitly had an exception for these well cataloged mines in narrowed down locations [2]. They would of course word their public statement carefully so they can later refuse to acknowledge a causal connection between the two in case their bluff is called. [1] And my government on other topics. [2] I'm assuming the best case here. I don't know how the mines along the border are actually distributed, or even if there are mines at all.
- cmccabe 13y agoThree-strikes laws are dumb, but so are you. Take your anti-US agenda somewhere else. I suggest North Korea, China, Venezuela, Iran, Russia, or any of the other countries not allied with us, so you can see how much "better" they are.
- lostlogin 13y agoMy country of birth, New Zealand, has plenty of dark secrets of its own. It's not as simple as being with us or against us though, surely? There are plenty of countries that are worse than the US and there are also a fair few who are better. However there aren't any countries who have a bigger international profile everywhere I have ever been. Its a pity this isn't used to create more good.
- saraid216 13y ago> It's not as simple as being with us or against us though, surely? Here in the US, we strive to bring partisan politics into every discussion.
- pessimizer 13y agoViolent nationalism isn't particularly partisan.
- saraid216 13y agoActually, it is. I mean "partisan" as in "parted into parties" which is the same as "us versus them" rather than more jargony "national political parties inside America".
- moocowduckquack 13y agoIt is usually extremely partisan. It is fairly rare for an entire country to be violently nationalisic, even if the ruling party is. Also, as saraid points out, it is by definition being partisan, just internationally rather than internally.
- 13y ago
- baddox 13y ago> Who sees the US as a leader in human rights? The vast majority of people who are raised in USA public schools.
- fleitz 13y agoIt's called mandatory education for a reason :)
- grecy 13y agoWho sees the US as a leader in any measure of what it's like to live there? No one I know.
- mossplix 13y agoThats American exceptionalism
- madaxe 13y agoThe majority of Americans, sadly.