4 ms·
Help me understand: is it a terrible problem to design one website so that it looks similar to another website, but not a terrible problem to reproduce a copyri
by tokenadult 17y ago
Help me understand: is it a terrible problem to design one website so that it looks similar to another website, but not a terrible problem to reproduce a copyrighted musical recording and share it with your friends? I'm trying to figure out what the general principle of fairness (or morality) is here.
- dtf 17y agoI'm no fan of copyright. But in the case of music, unless we're talking about sampling or covering or remixing, then the reproduction is verbatim. Possibly bit-for-bit. This cannot happen with a website, as there are too many components: design, layout and artwork; back-end implementation; server architecture; business processes; staff; management; customer service and public relations... You can't be a "bit-for-bit" copy of Kayak's business. You can only be an also-ran or a better Kayak.
- boryas 17y agoFile sharers don't directly compete against musicians the way bing travel competes with Kayak. I would say the closer comparison is instead of remixing/sampling a popular band you just release their song on your own album. I don't understand or intend to comment on any of the legal aspects of this dispute, but as far as morality goes, Bing travel looks like a clone of Kayak with a different logo, and that doesn't feel fair to me.
- paulgb 17y agoIt's a shame people are downvoting this rather than answering it. It's a good question, and certainly within the scope of this article and HN.
- grellas 17y agoCopyright protects original works of authorship when they are fixed in any tangible medium of expression. Musical works classically fall squarely within the type of protection copyright was designed to afford, the stated goal being to promote creative expression. Interface designs, though, do not. The problem with claims alleging infringement of designs is that a party may, if courts are not careful, be given what is effectively a monopoly on an idea (Apple tried to get away with this in the early 1980s by claiming that its iconic depictions of common office items were protected by copyright). In any case, this is not the place to get into legal technicalities but simply to point out (in answer to your question) that the principle of fairness embodied in the copyright laws is to protect original expression (such as is embodied in musical works) while not setting up arbitrary barriers to originality (such as would happen if a someone were allowed to corner exclusive rights on common ideas such as how an interface might be designed). Thus, the type of case that might be brought against Microsoft is actually a tough one. It can be won but the showing that needs to be made has to be very strong. I understand that there is a philosophical argument against the very idea of copyright, and the issues are exacerbated in our era of intense inter-connectivity, but the above sets forth the key principles as the existing copyright laws seek to uphold them.
- enomar 17y agoThe culture isn't (completely) homogeneous here. The people saying it's bad to rip off web sites aren't necessarily the same people saying it's ok copy mp3s. I would imagine that many people believe that the morality of stealing depends on who you're stealing from. Additionally, many probably don't consider it theft if there isn't an immediately apparent victim.
- baddox 17y ago"Who you're stealing from" is a bad argument for (or against) piracy. The only sound (pun intended) argument for piracy that I know of is the fact that intellectual property laws are fundamentally a bunch of crap.
- incomethax 17y agoSharing an mp3 is dramatically different from designing a similar website. When I give a song to my friend, its like I put a website in an iframe. The whole site is still there, attributed to the website's owner, the owner just doesn't get money for it. When I make a design that looks eerily similar to someone else's, I am trying to pass it off as my own. That's plagiarism, and that is the line that is more morally reprehensible because of the implicit deceit. That's not to say that infringing on someone else's property is not wrong, but infringing with deceit is IMO much worse than infringing without deceit.
- mbrubeck 17y agoPersonally I wouldn't do either. But I think a lot of people feel a line is crossed when you make money by copying someone else's work, as opposed to making copies for free (and for personal use).
- mattmaroon 17y agoThat's maybe an accurate depiction of what you'd get from the community if you put it to a vote, but it wouldn't be anywhere near unanimous. I personally tend to go the other way. Copying a website is like a band doing a cover version of a song.
- fatdog789 17y agoBing and Kayak both use the same underlying (third party) database. Furthermore, Kayak is a clone of Fly.com's design, so Kayak really has no ground to argue about Bing allegedly copying them.
- ojbyrne 17y agoUm, fly.com launched 4 months ago. Kayak has been around for several years. I.e. you have it exactly backwards. In addition the comment about the same underlying database is a gross simplification. While ITA software aggregates a bunch of government mandated databases, both Kayak and Bing get data from other sources.
- cousin_it 17y agoNo, the musical counterpart would be performing someone else's song and claiming you wrote it. Plagiarism != copyright infringement.