4 ms·
That is an interesting narrative. Microsoft didn't "lose" anything, they have made billions over the last decade. So you have a profitable company bringing in b
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
That is an interesting narrative. Microsoft didn't "lose" anything, they have made billions over the last decade. So you have a profitable company bringing in billions of dollars that is pretty much qualifies as "doing a good job."
So when people talk about the 'lost billions' they create a hypothetical Microsoft, the one of today which made billions of dollars but also dominated in new markets and made billions more. There is absolutely no evidence that Microsoft could have done both, regardless of who was at the helm. It would have been epic, but it isn't clear that it was possible.
So this article was Ballmer's take on his reign, he's not going to say "I didn't capture the smartphone market" he is going to remember that he made a lot of money off enterprises for his employees and his shareholders. I would happy to be that successful.
Google has never made serious money off their hardware products or operating system products, Apple has never made serious money off their operating system products or their network products, and Microsoft has never made significant money on either network products or hardware products. All three have a space where they are really good, all three are so so in the other two spaces. Why is Ballmer presented as an idiot and Page and Cook not?
- r00fus 13y agoImagine if Apple spent billions on boondoggles that made it such that instead of having $150B in their bank account, they only had $100B or $50B - because that's what's evident - MSFT might have double it's current cash ($80B) [1] if it had executed well on those new key ventures. Is it any less a managerial failure to repeatedly fail to execute like this than it is to push a company from profitable to unprofitable (or run it into bankruptcy)? And that's ignoring the cultural morass that failed policies like stacked ranking promote - that could likely have poisoned Microsoft's productivity well.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoWell if you are unconstrained from reality you could argue that Apple could have made MacOS available for any x86 laptop and sold it from $50/copy and completely STOLEN what was left of the technical Windows market. But no, their stupid reliance on only putting it on some over priced hardware left BILLIONs on the table. You see how that works? In lots and lots of ways MacOS is much better than Windows 8, and yet Apple won't sell it to Dell or Lenovo to pre-install on their laptops, they won't even talk to them about it. But it would be cool (and we know its possible with all the Hackintoshes out there). Everyone agrees that Microsoft fumbled on the phone business and Apple executed very well. Apple so far has totally fumbled their network products offering, social music network? icloud? not stellar.
- r00fus 13y ago"Unconstrained from reality" is an understatement for your example. I'm not arguing that Microsoft should have abandoned their cash cows and say "put office on the web" as a target. Instead they should have, for example, actually stove to make money from their Xbox division (it's still in the red from it's inception). Or made phones that didn't suck back in the early 00s - I had a colleague doing testing for mobile enterprise software for WinCE and each weekend he'd show me his return list - a half dozen or more OQO, HP, Dell, or Compaq handsets that just up and died during his testing - every week. Ultimately, Microsoft could be making so much more than what they are. Apple's 1st and second most profitable areas didn't even exist 8 years ago. Microsoft's have existed for 20+, they simply can't make a new profitable venture. That's a failure of management.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoI don't know of anyone who set out to not be successful. That is why looking backwards in time is so strange sometimes. You say "Gee, that decision cost you so much time and money!" but you don't necessarily get to see what they were looking at when they made it. Imagine one comes to a fork in the road, unmarked, both lead in the general direction of your goal, one of them has a bridge washed out. At the bridge it is obvious which fork to take, at the fork, which cannot see the bridge, not so much. I'm not apologizing for Microsoft executing poorly, what I am saying is that there success is a matter of positive degree rather than one of success or failure. We can productively discuss if they may have been more successful had they invested differently but there shouldn't be any discussion that they are not successful. I don't know where you are in your career or life, but I know that everyone gets a chance to look back and see some things that look obviously stupid in the future looking toward the past. If you are like me, and you see some things that would have really made things different (I turned Bill Gates down when he offered me a job in 1978, I held my tech stocks in 2000 hoping there would be a recovery, Etc.) don't dwell on them. Figure out whether or not you made the right decision with the information that was available, and if so let those past decisions lay in peace and not haunt your dreams. I have found that this statement : "Ultimately, Microsoft could be making so much more than what they are." is nearly always true. When looking back in time, a path can be plotted which would have made you more money (I could have bought 1000 BTC for $250 for example, I didn't) but that exercise is useless unless it helps to learn something about how to make better decisions right?
- jusben1369 13y agor00fus I think that huge pile of Apple cash is a problem for Apple just FYI. It's indicative of a lack of new product vision as they're not doing anything but piling it up from selling legacy products.
- 8ig8 13y agoHard to believe that sitting on a pile of cash is a problem. I would think having a huge pile of cash allows you to make smarter, less-pressured decisions. That's my small business perspective. Do you have any examples where accumulation of cash corresponded with lack of innovation. No challenge, just curious.
- tanzam75 13y ago> Do you have any examples where accumulation of cash corresponded with lack of innovation. No challenge, just curious. Aren't we discussing an article about Microsoft? Certainly the perception is that Microsoft has not innovated. (Whether or not you agree, that's at least the general perception.) Microsoft has been piling up the cash, despite the fact that Microsoft has been paying a dividend for ten years. They've bought back 20% of the outstanding shares. They've bought dozens of companies. They've spent a billion dollars repairing Xboxes. And despite all that, they just can't spend it fast enough. Their cash hoard just keeps increasing in size. Note: Correlation does not imply causation.
- massysett 13y ago"Why is Ballmer presented as an idiot and Page and Cook not?" Maybe because Page has not defined his company's success in terms of how many Nexus devices it sells; nor does Apple define its success in terms of how many licenses it sells to enterprises. Ballmer, on the other hand, not only has entered foreign market spaces such as Web search, hardware, and phones. He has also thumped his chest about how Microsoft is going to wallop the competition in those spaces. Google and Apple typically do not talk about how they are going to beat everybody else; instead, they talk about how good their products are. Ballmer laughs at other companies' products and enters the market late and says he will beat everybody else. Thus, Ballmer has failed on the terms that he defined for himself. He said he would wallop other companies. He did not. Not only did he not wallop other companies, but while trying to do so, he destroyed good products and hurt Microsoft in its strong markets. See for instance Windows 8, which is useless for Microsoft's big corporate customers and gets it nowhere in the tablet space it has so desperately tried to make headway in. So, maybe if Ballmer spent less time chasing markets that Microsoft is no good in, and more time reinforcing the company's strengths, he would not be presented as an idiot.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoIts a reasonable criticism that he wasn't able to follow through or execute on his vision for the company, like Apple couldn't follow through on its Ping vision or Google its 'iGoogle' vision. Any I still disagree on the narrative that he 'lost billions.'
- brianpgordon 13y ago> There is absolutely no evidence that Microsoft could have done both, regardless of who was at the helm. I don't buy this argument. Anyone can say "no" instead of saying "yes." It was Ballmer's responsibility to green-light major products for launch, and he decided wrong time and again.