15 ms·
There is not much value in pedantically debating the differences between the two. Better to focus our energies on the similarities which are overtly real: the
by dmix 13y ago
There is not much value in pedantically debating the differences between the two.
Better to focus our energies on the similarities which are overtly real: the extreme sentencing mismatching the level of harm done. It's an issue of the state seeking vengeful punishment for political purposes and not seeking to maximizing public safety or victim compensation. In addition to computer hacking/unauthorized access laws having unusually high maximum sentences vs other more more harmful offences.
- mindslight 13y agoComputer hacking laws actually have pretty light sentences compared to their historic counterparts. A show trial followed by some years in jail is much nicer than being executed for witchcraft.
- duairc 13y agoSo we should feel good about it, or feel that we're lucky, or not try to fight back against this system? I know you probably think you're “not saying that”, but if you're not, why did you feel the need to post that?
- mindslight 13y agoShould 'witches' have been thankful that they weren't tortured as horrifically as the victims of the Inquisition ? TH;DR: I said it to highlight the commonality of mass hysteria fueled hyper-punishment for socially distasteful actions.
- andrewfong 13y ago10 years doesn't strike me as unreasonable. What he did basically amounted to burglary and over $1M in credit card fraud. 10 years is at the upper end of what I would sentence for those crimes, but it's not out of range -- especially considering that he's relatively unrepentant about the whole thing.
- billmalarky 13y agoOver a million dollars in credit card fraud? 10 years sounds reasonable for something like that.
- angersock 13y agoMillion dollars? As opposed to the billions lost in 2008, and the people rewarded with bailouts for their fraud? Pshyeah, hokay. Justice is truly being served here.
- lowkeykiwi 13y agoHe didn't steal any money. He stole a crap load of information and credit card numbers were in there. They've extrapolated to a million dollars by adding all the credit limits together.
- gngeal 13y ago10 years doesn't strike me as unreasonable. ...while in Norway, you typically only get the maximum 21 years of imprisonment for multiple murders. And even that is apparently with the possibility of an early release after 14 years and unsupervised weekend parole after 7 years. And even with murder on your hands, they just might send you off to Bastøy to rehabilitate yourself properly. And somehow, the crime rate in Norway is still much lower, as are the reoffending rates. I just wonder, what comes next in the US, two years for littering, perhaps?
- pessimizer 13y agoLife sentences for repeat offenders caught shoplifting food are last decade's news.
- VladRussian2 13y ago>I just wonder, what comes next in the US, two years for littering, perhaps? well, theoretically you can get up to 1 year in many states, though i suspect usually it is much-much less harsh than that. http://www.ncsl.org/research/environment-and-natural-resources/states-with-littering-penalties.aspx http://www.ncsl.org/research/environment-and-natural-resourc...
- rayiner 13y agoThe sentence has to be understood in context of Hammond's criminal record: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeremy_Hammond#Arrests_and_criminal_history http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeremy_Hammond#Arrests_and_crim.... Hammond has a history of taking political protest over the line to breaking into things, destroying property, etc. Also important to remember is the fact that Anonymous didn't just leak the e-mails, but stole a bunch of credit card numbers and made $700k worth of charges. To be fair, I think the sentence is too long, but more because I have a philosophical problem with the sentencing guidelines and how it punishes repeat offenders and not because I think Hammond was particularly singled out.
- crististm 13y agoWhat was the problem after all, "political protest", "destroying property" or the $700k charges made by "Anonymous" ?
- dopamean 13y agoIt's very easy to claim to be the victim of political showboating when you tie your criminal activity to a political cause. It kind of reminds me of terrorists launching attacks from areas densely populated by civilians and then vilifying the counter attacks that end up hurting civilians.
- alcari 13y ago> then vilifying the counter attacks that end up hurting civilians Attacking civilian targets is wrong regardless of which side is doing it. Having previously engaged in the same behavior does not make the act any less wrong, or the vilification any less deserved.
- mpyne 13y ago> Attacking civilian targets is wrong regardless of which side is doing it. What about a single civilian in a civilian building filled with a company of soldiers? In the law of armed conflict this kind of thing is called "perfidy" and brings no protection.
- diogenescynic 13y agoAnd on the other hand, the complete lack of prosecution against Wall Street executives for fraud over the financial crisis. Shows our government's priorities.