3 ms·
A big part of the reason the IPO market suck, i.e. why "the stock market isn’t influenced by value today like it was thirty years ago", is taxes. Specifically,
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
A big part of the reason the IPO market suck, i.e. why "the stock market isn’t influenced by value today like it was thirty years ago", is taxes. Specifically, the differential tax treatment of capital gains and dividends.
A long time back, equities were viewed as a vehicle for distributing dividends. A company earns money and pays it to investors. You build the hyperloop, customers buy tickets, you give investors a cut of the proceeds. The value of HLOOP is based primarily on the expected value of this revenue stream.
Nowadays, dividends are double taxed while capital gains are only single taxed, which means that companies mostly don't bother with dividends anymore. Investors tolerate this because the differential tax rates mean that management would be throwing away their money if they issued dividends. As a result, the value of equity is the value of expected capital gains, resulting in the current situation.
- wnoise 13y agoSo we should double tax capital gains?
- InclinedPlane 13y agoIn my opinion capital gains and corporate income tax should go away and everything should fall under individual. income tax. Simplifies a lot of things and avoids a lot of perverse incentives created by the existing system.
- PeterisP 13y agoMoving corporate income tax to individual income tax would allow to postpone paying any such tax forever, allowing company-owners to skip paying the tax, but allowing them to use the (yet untaxed) funds to purchase/invest whatever they want.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoNo, it doesn't. The IRS is very good at taxing corporate transfers to individuals (e.g., the company paying for your house, clothes and food) as income. If this wasn't already a solved problem, we wouldn't even need to eliminate corporate taxes to engage in the scheme you propose. Just book revenue, book your personal expenses as corporate expenses, and the company made no profit and hence needs to pay no taxes. This is why your company generally only provides you benefits in a very narrow set of categories that happen to be tax deductible (health insurance, 401k).
- PeterisP 13y agoYes, the part of the income that you consume would be taxed. The point is that pretty much all of what megacorps make for their owners is not consumed - on that scale, houses, clothes and food are a small percentage, a rounding error. Don't think about what a small business owner is doing with his profits, think about what happens to profits of Walmart or Microsoft. Not about income of the 1%, but income of the 0.1% (which is the big part). What is a billionaire doing with his money? A major part of it is reinvested to earn even more money - that can be done through the company; so the main feedback loop of rich-gets-richer is completely untaxed. Part of it is used to fund pet projects (like Virgin Galactic or 10,000 Year Clock project) or buy companies for control/prestige purposes - not taxed. Part of the wealth is simply accumulated to be given to your heirs - if there's no capital gains tax, would an inheritance tax stand? Part of that is used to buy political and social influence by funding parties and advertisement - not taxed. Part of that is used to buy prestige - ok, buying a fancy house to show off is taxed; but buying a major football club to show off isn't. In essence, this means that the continuing concentration of wealth is untaxed, and you're taxing only the spending of wealth, which is something that actually redistributes wealth to the rest of society. This is not sustainable; that tax policy would fuel a rising and inescapable inequality. The society is better off if billionaires spend their wealth on fancy services (giving fancy income to the service providers), instead of owning all those service providers.
- gaadd33 13y agoHow would that work? If I wanted to buy a house, and I have my corporation do that, then I live there rent free, I still have to pay taxes on the benefit given to me. You could postpone the taxation until you actually want to use the money to benefit yourself then you are taxed. I believe you can already do it with corporations that are headquartered in low tax jurisdictions.
- Retric 13y agoA stock buyback replaces dividends with capital gains directly so that's not actually an issue. AKA company can do a 5% dividend or buy back ~5% of it's stock. After the buyback the stock price should in theory not change noticeably vs the drop after a dividend however, future earnings are split among a smaller pool of stocks. Repeat for X years and you get 1.05^X years of effective growth even if earning are flat. A lot of tech company's don't do this because they consider there stock overvalued aka P/E of 30+ and buybacks can't afford significant quantities of stock.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoYes, a stock buyback can replace dividends provided the IRS views it as "not essentially equivalent to a dividend". I.e., if you issue quarterly share buybacks, the IRS will kick your ass. (Google the phrase in quotes, it's a legal term of art.)
- 7Figures2Commas 13y ago> Nowadays, dividends are double taxed while capital gains are only single taxed, which means that companies mostly don't bother with dividends anymore. Investors tolerate this because the differential tax rates mean that management would be throwing away their money if they issued dividends. Notwithstanding the fact that there are plenty of companies that pay dividends, I assume you're not familiar with REITs, preferred stock and MLPs? Dividend/distribution investing is very much alive and well.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoDividends these days occur, but they are generally a token rather than the primary means of rewarding shareholders. REITs might work for Hyperloop specifically (depending on whether the IRS believes Hyperloop is an "investment agent specializing in real estate and real estate mortgages"), but they don't work for most companies. The fact that there are a few corporate structures that avoid overtaxing dividends doesn't change the fact that they don't work for most businesses.
- 7Figures2Commas 13y ago> Dividends these days occur, but they are generally a token rather than the primary means of rewarding shareholders. I would strongly suggest that you visit a site like http://www.dividendchannel.com/ http://www.dividendchannel.com/. Your statements that "companies mostly don't bother with dividends anymore" and "they are generally a token rather than the primary means of rewarding shareholders" are simply incorrect.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoSince 1980 (the earliest year I could find data for), there has been a drastic decrease dividends. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1979501 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1979501 This paper suggests, though comes far from proving, that dividends do behave as if they are used for signalling (i.e., "look at us, we are healthy, see, dividends").
- 13y ago