3 ms·
> In other words, the toaster company has to -- gasp! -- engage in centralized planning of how toasters will be produced, distributed and sold. Fortunately, cen
by anamax 17y ago
> In other words, the toaster company has to -- gasp! -- engage in centralized planning of how toasters will be produced, distributed and sold. Fortunately, centralized planning and coordination is only doomed to fail when the government does it, right?
One difference is that when govt does "it", govt typically forbids or at least seriously punishes alternatives. At the very least, govt takes resources from folks who would do things differently.
If I have no interest in your toaster idea, I'm free to develop an alternative and I don't end up supporting your idea. When govt develops a toaster, I pay for it even if I think that it's dumb, and govt is likely to place restrictions on my alternative.
Govt solutions are also less diverse. This takes two forms.
Each company will take a somewhat different approach to toasters while govts pick an approach and run with it. Since each attempt has roughly the same odds of success, taking multiple shots tends to produce a better "best" result.
It's also the case that one size doesn't fit all. Different companies end up optimizing their product for different users, increasing overall satisfaction. If there's only one product in a given space, as you get with govt solutions, said product ends up not satisfying a significant fraction of people and it has "flexibility" that gets in the way.
Folks rant about monopolies, but govt is the biggest monopoly of all.