10 ms·
Car Mechanic Dreams Up a Tool to Ease Births
- RokStdy 13y agoThis reminds me of an idea I've had. I think it'd be nice if there were a website where experts from a certain field could go and post their problems. Then knowledgeable people working in other fields with other backgrounds could weigh in on their problem and provide possibly novel solutions. I have always thought that you don't necessarily need to be in a field in order to be able to provide new insights into issues.
- bernardom 13y agoWould SO work? Or would you need different formatting?
- nether 13y agoInnoCentive and Quirky do pretty much this. > InnoCentive is a Massachusetts-based open innovation company that accepts by commission research and development problems in a broad range of domains such as engineering, computer science, math, chemistry, life sciences, physical sciences and business and frames them as "challenge problems" for anyone to solve. It gives cash awards for the best solutions to solvers who meet the challenge criteria.
- sliverstorm 13y agoThe problem is the signal-to-noise. You get cross-field insights sometimes, but they are very rare and more often come from someone who is actually versed in both fields. The majority of the time you'd spend fielding hare-brained ideas.
- ivix 13y agoThat supposes experts know that they have a problem, and can express it in a way disentangled from their other problems.
- saraid216 13y agoInstead of posting their problems, I think it'd be more effective to have explanations of current theories intended for people who don't understand it at all. You'd establish a single rule: the expert isn't allowed to expect full comprehension from the layman. It would be, really, university for people interested in mental tinkering and disinterested in certification of any kind. A salon, perhaps.
- Scaevolus 13y agoThis looks much safer than the alternatives of forceps, vacuum extraction, or C-section. The intuitive leap from "extracting cork in wine bottle" to "extracting baby in birth canal" happening during a dream is fascinating. Neurons rearranging during sleep cause the oddness of dream logic and can find unexpected correlations -- like the link he found.
- tantalor 13y agoIt appears to be very comparable to vacuum extraction. In fact it allows the same ~40 lbs of pulling force. (http://www.odondevice.org/device.php http://www.odondevice.org/device.php) However, the device looks a lot less likely to fail (let go) than vacuum extraction, due to the firmer grasp.
- Scaevolus 13y agoSimilar effects, but the force is spread over a larger area, and shouldn't swell the scalp.
- TrainedMonkey 13y agoAdditionally better friction coefficients when getting the head out - should make things somewhat easier as well.
- JshWright 13y agoOn top of that, the force is spread over an area that is much more suited to withstanding that force (as opposed to the as-yet unfused parietal bones of the skull)
- rsanders 13y agoThat's important. My older son had severe jaundice due in part to the hematoma caused by use of a vacuum extractor during a difficult birth.
- dopamean 13y agoLooking at the picture in the Times article I'm having a hard time understanding how this doesn't hurt the infant's neck.
- everettForth 13y agoIt reminds me of this patent: http://www.google.com/patents/US3216423 http://www.google.com/patents/US3216423
- headgasket 13y agoyes I can totally see my wife looking forward to an attraction park ride while in heavy labor... I'd go with the bag, at first at least.
- spectre256 13y agoWhen I went to the doctor's office for a shot as a child, they offered me a choice: you can get the shot in the arm like the doctor would prefer, or you can choose to get the shot in the leg, but then the doctor has to go get a bigger needle. This could work the same way. You can forgo the bag, but then we have to put you in the centrifuge.
- refurb 13y agoThat apparatus would seem to make the unpleasant experience (for most) of childbirth even more unpleasant.
- duskwuff 13y agoMorning sickness, meet motion sickness! Bad jokes aside, an opera was recently written (and performed - as part of the Ig Nobel ceremony!) about this device and its inventor, titled "The Blonsky Device". http://www.henryakona.com/the_blonsky_device.html http://www.henryakona.com/the_blonsky_device.html
- utopkara 13y agoHow is the bag supposed to securely attach into the canal?
- utopkara 13y agoHere it is in action: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eW-n914Vqtc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eW-n914Vqtc
- ceautery 13y agoSafe my big ol' butt. You're inflating something against baby's head and pulling on it. You're also losing tactile feedback that you'd get by direct contact with baby, which may cause you to inadvertently pull harder than you intended to.
- PeterisP 13y agoUmm, 'direct contact with baby' like when pulling his head with an attached suction cup and the damage often caused by that?
- ceautery 13y agoNo. That wouldn't be direct contact, and is, again, more likely to cause injury because you're not getting good kinesthetic feedback. What I'm talking about is what the L&D doctor did when my daughter was born a couple months ago to aid my wife, who was exhausted and in pain: manual manipulation of the vaginal opening, and carefully inching baby's head forward using nothing more than his fingers. As it turned out, this doctor some work delivering babies in Africa in third-world conditions, and only low-tech solutions were available. Things that American hospitals aren't fond of, like having mom stand up and move around, eat and drink to keep her strength up, and finding a birthing position comfortable for the mom, like squatting, hands and knees, whatever her body is telling her to do. This device is better than forceps only that it is less likely to crush a skull, but it still carries a risk of breaking baby's neck.
- jlgreco 13y agoForceps also have the risk of injuring the baby in other ways. Part of Sylvester Stallone's face is paralyzed because of forceps used during his delivery.
- travisp 13y agoIt's to replace the vacuum extractor or forceps. Nobody uses any of these tools if you can do it by hand. Both have their own risks (and forceps are going away because the skill required is high and not enough doctors know how to do it to teach new doctors).
- riggins 13y agohere's a fun trivia question. How many years did the Chamberlen family keep the invention of the forceps secret so they could enjoy monopoly profits?
- jlgreco 13y ago"The brothers went to great length to keep the secret. When they arrived at the home of a woman in labour, two people had to carry a massive box with gilded carvings into the house. The pregnant patient was blindfolded so as not to reveal the secret, all the others had to leave the room. Then the operator went to work. The people outside heard screams, bells, and other strange noises until the cry of the baby indicated another successful delivery." Holy hell...
- ggchappell 13y agoIt's worth pointing out that this is why we have patents. Inventors disclose how their inventions work, in exchange for a legally enforced temporary monopoly.
- femto 13y agoTry keeping a secret since the widespread adoption of the Internet. Paradoxically, we now have trade secrets laws to help inventors help keep inventions secret, so they can obtain a patent, so they can reveal how the inventions work.
- raverbashing 13y agoElon Musk seems to be successful at this at SpaceX There was a story mentioning this some time ago "We don't patent anything that's part of our secrets"
- femto 13y agoThat's exactly my point! Musk almost certainly wouldn't be able to keep employees or visitors from spilling his secrets, if it wasn't for the laws that are in place to protect trade secrets [1]. I'd contend that it only makes sense to argue for patents on an information dissemination basis in the absence of laws to protect trade secrets. [1] http://acuriousguy.blogspot.com.au/2013/04/protecting-space-technology-through.html http://acuriousguy.blogspot.com.au/2013/04/protecting-space-...
- jonah 13y agoI bet we'd reduce the need for extreme intervention like this if we'd encourage women to deliver in more traditional positions. Prone and sedated is just about the worst possible way to have a kid.
- marquis 13y agoThat's a very 20th century view of birthing positions and certainly not in poorer countries. Clean equipment, good pre-natal care and general excellent health plus some good luck are needed more. http://www.midwiferytoday.com/articles/globalissues.asp http://www.midwiferytoday.com/articles/globalissues.asp "Outcomes in these maternity centers were so good that Dr. Araujo began to study what the traditional midwives did, and ended up incorporating hammocks, more patience, and upright positions for birth into the hospital"
- jonah 13y agoThese two sentences follow: 'This system functioned efficiently until his death; it has since been dismantled due to lack of support and interest on the part of the younger obstetricians who replaced him. While it existed, this system was an excellent example of Graham's "partnership paradigm" or what Brigitte Jordan has called "mutual accommodation" between biomedical and indigenous systems.' i.e. The traditional methods are occasionally acknowledged but rarely adopted.
- marquis 13y agoFair enough. It's true that I have bias, my wealthier friends who give birth are 'over-educated and academic', and the understanding of a natural birth is a given, while ideally being as close as possible to a good hospital in case of complications. The time I've spent in developing countries, it's just anecdotal to me that a midwife is the first call for a pregnant woman rather than an obstetrician.
- rayiner 13y ago> my wealthier friends who give birth are 'over-educated and academic', and the understanding of a natural birth is a given This is what happens when over-educated people take first-world problems to the extreme and turn them into third-world problems. Like a highly-educated acquaintance of my brother's who married a sherpa and is now upset that he won't accept her working outside the home. > The time I've spent in developing countries, it's just anecdotal to me that a midwife is the first call for a pregnant woman rather than an obstetrician. My father (who works in international development and has long specialized in maternal health) has spent much of his life trying to disabuse women in developing countries (like his native Bangladesh) of this habit.
- stereo 13y agoSo, how do you remove a cork from a bottle like that?
- ggchappell 13y agohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uL1ovAYtKuQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uL1ovAYtKuQ
- rokhayakebe 13y agoIsn't this going to stop the baby from breathing?
- ianferrel 13y agoWhat do you think the baby is breathing in the womb/birth canal? (presumably you don't leave the baby in a plastic bag after it's out)
- chrsstrm 13y agoHa, I read this in Morpheus' voice. "Do you think that's air you're breathing now?..."
- rokhayakebe 13y agoI see now.
- ceejayoz 13y agoBabies don't breathe at this point, as they've got a face full of female reproductive tract at the time.
- rayiner 13y agoThe baby is attached to the placenta, which remains in the womb, via the umbilical cord and gets oxygen this way during the birth process. Once the baby is fully out it starts breathing (the first cry). Then the placenta is delivered.
- Gigablah 13y agoThere's some irony in that plastic bags wrapped around the head are normally a suffocation risk for children, yet used in this manner could potentially be a lifesaver.
- Noxchi 13y agoExactly what I thought. Yet like most, most solutions to problems are non-obvious and counter-intuitive.
- kosei 13y agoYes - very cool. Ah, the miracle of life and umbilical cords. http://blog.al.com/smarter-every-day/2012/02/why_you_didnt_die_at_birth_a_l.html http://blog.al.com/smarter-every-day/2012/02/why_you_didnt_d...
- drawkbox 13y agoGreat idea and he's kept a young and innovative mind at almost 60. Ideas are what you do with them, this guy went to work.
- yetanotherphd 13y agoThis is amazing. It makes me so happy to see people coming up with technology like this to make people's lives better. I know almost nothing about the medicine of childbirth, but I think this is most likely a great technology if the WHO got behind it so fast.
- Wingman4l7 13y agoWe need more collaboration between engineers and the field of medicine. I'm reminded of Tal Golesworthy, an engineer who did a TED talk or two about how he collaborated with his doctors to design a cardiac implant that fixed his dilated aorta. He had some very insightful comments about the development process and his doctors' opinions of different approaches coming from outside the medical community.
- f7t7ft7 13y agoClearly the real solution is to insert the air hose from an impact wrench into the uterus, past the baby, to inflate the uterus and blast the baby out. This way the pressure isn't just on the baby's head.
- malandrew 13y agoInteresting idea. I wonder if it has been tried.
- frank_boyd 13y ago> Car Mechanic Dreams Up a Tool to Ease Births Pure gold.
- kineticfocus 13y agoThere's a TED talk about a Plumber fixing his own Heart (Aorta)... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9-qHrhrTktc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9-qHrhrTktc
- goggles99 13y ago>The current options in those cases are forceps — large, rounded pliers — or suction cups attached to the baby’s scalp. In untrained hands, either can cause hemorrhages, crush the baby’s head or twist its spine. Really? you mean these things are going to be available at WalMart so that untrained people can use them? I really cannot see this being adopted. how are you going to slip this thing past the cervix and pubic bone? The whole reason that you need this thing in the first place is that there is literally zero room there. Also, the inflation is going to cause an even larger object to have to move through the birth canal thus exacerbating the original problem. How are you even going to know if you have it on completely? you really cannot see in that tight space. What about fetal distress? I cannot imagine that this thing squishing their entire cranium would bode well for distress which leads to many potential complications. Maybe most importantly is the fact that this device would likely prevent the infant from ingesting the very important birth canal bacteria which colonized as flora in the baby's gut. c-section births lack this as well and they are at much higher risks for many things because of it. This is a poor replacement for vacuum extractions (suction cup method) IMO. Maybe in developing countries it could be helpful (MAYBE safer for untrained midwives), but I doubt even that, given it's own disadvantages.
- jkldotio 13y ago"I really cannot see this being adopted. how are you going to slip this thing past the cervix and pubic bone?" This is a typical HN top comment dismissal. It works with corks, it works with his basic prototype, it works with medical training dummies and it works with the 30 Argentinian women in live births but a comment dismissing it as being impossible is the top HN comment. Unbelievable.
- goggles99 13y agoYou use a naive argument to attempt to refute one point of my whole comment (which contains several reasons this will not work) and call the whole thing garbage? Yours is the typical HN top comment dismissal, not mine. On top of this, your criticism is not even valid. Let me explain why. You clearly have never given birth with or even assisted in an obstructed delivery? Corks, prototypes, and dummies are not made to fit as tight as an obstructed birth canal and do not even try to replicate this scenario. If you've read the article carefully, and paid attention to the details you would know the live births used are no evidence that his will work when it is actually needed. >So far, the device has been safety-tested only on 30 Argentine women, all of whom were in hospitals, had given birth before and were in normal labor. So the diameter of these women's birth canals were far larger than typical obstructed ones because they had given birth before. They also were in normal labor. There would be far more room available to use this device when it is not actually needed. Try shoving something like this down and around a curved surface with an obstruction preventing it's passage. The material would have to be very stiff, but to curve properly around the head and face, it would have to be very flexible. These things are mutually exclusive. Even if you managed to get it worked into place eventually (without it folding over someplace) it would take a fairly long period of time to work it into place. Suction is very quick to attach and is often used when that baby is already in distress (needs to come out in a hurry). Here are some more reasons this won't work. Sizing. Babies craniums are vastly different sizes. Either they will need 8 sized of these hanging on the wall, or the inflation part will have to allow for dramatic size differences. If there is only one size, and the baby's head is small, you are increasing the size of the object that needs to pass through the canal by a large margin (Actually adding to the problem). I suppose that big hospitals could have 8 sizes of these on hand, but not third world midwives. If there is enough room for this thing to fit on, there is enough room for the Dr or midwife to just use their hands. This is far better anyway as they will have far more tactile feel.